I Love Pie Bakeshop

6241 Fair Oaks Blvd Ste L, Carmichael
(916) 969-7791

Recent Reviews

Shane S.

Pies were ok flavor (had custard and a salted caramel apple) but for the size and price, I'll take a Nation's pie.

Ky K.

The small pies have gone from $9 to $12 to $15!!! I personally cannot afford that for a very small pie .. I know housing is up,gas is up, food is up, everything is up.. but that's just entirely too much.. love the shop.. love the pies.. love the owner.. but it just isn't affordable for me :( it's going to have to be a once a year treat.. I bought one the other week and was horrified at the price but paid it anyways.. UPDATE: I will try the app you suggested.. I've changed the three stars to five stars..

Banks M.

The pies were DELICIOUS!!! I was at the goodwill across the way when I decided to slide thru and see what these pies were hitting for & omg , heaven . Will definitely be back.

Sristi Sharma

Really good pies. Salted caramel apple pie is always a fav.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Salted Caramel Apple

Teresa B.

The staff couldn't have been more friendly and patient in answering my questions. I've made my own pecan pie for years, but I don't see any reasons to do that any longer because the BEST pecan pie I've ever tasted is right here at I Love Pie Bakeshop. I'm super excited for a new item that I heard might be coming for Christmas 2024, too! PS...I would post a photo but only crumbs are left :-)

Senor Buffalo D.

This is pretty good pie shop. Not very big but good. Will I recommend them , probably not , a bit pricey. But overall enjoyable. Good staff

Joseph Z.

My wife was hankering for sweets. He had these guys before but at the old location. The new location is the easiest to find but it's tucked inside next to the ice cream place. But that whole complex is an awesome video. Restaurants and dessert/coffee options. I got there pretty late so there wasn't a huge selection, but that's on me. They had multiple types of apple pie - Dutch, Carmel, crumble. We went with banana cream. It was exactly what we needed. Perfect creamy but not overly sweet. Plus a super flakey crust. We will be back!

Adam G.

This shops makes the best pies. The crust is a masterpiece of buttery and crispy greatness. The flavor combinations that incorporate seasonal fruits are very flavorful. My wife and I love the banana cream pie the best, but you can't really go wrong with and of their pies. We highly recommended this shop!

Pam A.

Wow! The pies here are wonderfully delicious! The crust melts in your mouth! I am so happy I found this pie bakeshop.

Brittany E.

Omg absolutely love this place! I do wish they offered slices since $15 for a mini pie is pricey, buuuut the pies are so good. The owner is also an absolute gem. You can tell she truly loves her business. She took her time and answered all my questions. I ultimately decided on the Millionaire and Banana Cream pies. Both were delicious but that Millionaire pie...soooooo addicting. Will definitely be back!

Beka C

Yummy pies they taste so delicious ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Julienne M.

Was looking for last minute pies for my husbands birthday and so glad I decided to give this place a try. Yum!

Jim J.

Exceptional baked goods with fabulous staff. This is our go to shop for homemade tasting pies.

Monica Bellamine

I love pie by far has the best pie in Carmichael. Hands-down, the customer service is great, the pie is delicious, and an added bonus is getting to meet the pie shop owner almost every visit! If you have not tried this pie, you’re missing out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Karen Crockett

Hardest location to locate while driving. As the employee said to me, it's like a fancy mall food court.. an apt description. Loved the blueberry pear pie I bought.

Load More