Pizza dough/crust is really not good. Ordered thin and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Alenq A.
This place should be closed asap. I gave it 2 chances. 1st time it took close to 2 hours for delivery and the delivery and this store were blaming each other. Second time the cheese was like plastic and the wings were thinner than my pinky. It was laughable. Also what is up with the scary workers outside every single day smoking and hanging out? Disgusting.
Justin Reyes
Pizza was delicious and fast
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Boneless Bites
Jan Z.
For me, a pepperoni pizza isn't a pepperoni pizza unless it features the pepperonis that turn into little bowls of grease. The fact that you'll get all that AND some burnt ones for that little bit of extra crunch makes Fresh Brothers a winner in my book. In 2 visits here, service has been impeccable--patient and accommodating, even during the last hour before the shop closed for the day. Thank you, Taylor, for always being exceedingly friendly, kind, and professional! Really top-notch customer service every time. To save yourself some time, pick up the phone or place an order online and you'll have fresh, hot pizza out of the oven within 20 minutes. Pepperoni lovers, do not miss out on the Trippple Pep, featuring pepperoni 3 ways, while the Charcotta pizza takes it to the next level with scoops of ricotta on each square-cut slice. The inside dining area is clean and has ample tables and seating for small groups. There is also plenty of parking behind the restaurant. The menu features several other creative pizza combinations, as well as classic topping choices that you can order on your pizza(s) as you see fit. They also offer options for crusts as well as salads, wings, and other goodies. Like any good pizza joint, delivery is also available.
Mr. D.
Georgee's pizza you are not! First, the place in empty....at opening all the way until they close. I made the mistake of trying the place even though they basically closed Georgee's down and they spent an entire year closed after that. How on earth do they keep 5 people working all day (they are a private equity owned company, by the way)? Two medium pizzas were delivered at almost $75.00! Were they good?Well....they were ok. About what you would expect from a fast food chain. On par with Dominoes or Pizza Hut at 4 times the cost. The pizza was delivered cold and late. How do you do that when you are so close to us? I hope in the future it changes to a better restaurant that is not owned by private equity. Probably the funniest thing they have done is put a huge banner in the front window saying "they now have BEER" in huge writing. Guess what, still nobody showed up. This place was amazing when it was Georgee's.....now it is hands down the worst restaurant in the city. I am sorry to be so blunt, but it is horrible.
Cc
While the pizza was pretty tasty, the cutting needed some MAJOR improvement. The slices were not cut all the way, making it difficult to pick them up without tearing the pizza. Aside from this, the service and food were fairly good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Shelby L.
I'm not really sure what's up with this place. Gave it another chance, and we went to pick it up considering how terrible delivery service was. Somehow, the order was worse? Ordered 3 sliders, got 2. The pizza was essentially par baked, so much so pieces of mozzarella were not melted. Totally abysmal. Avoid at all costs.
Mike R.
Pizza is so-so, but edible. Did not make me ill. Sauce is kinda blah. It's just okay.
Wylmarye K.
If dehydrated chicken are a thing welp here ya go. Of course they looked NOTHING like the menu photo or I wouldn't have spent $12.99 on 12 wings. You had the option of crispy or regular and I chose regular, im not particularly fond of my gums being attacked by my food. These were very crispy, so if these are regular buyer beware if you like crispy, I think crispy will definitely be the consistency of a dehydrated jerky with a bone. I've seen their adds on social media and decided to give them go, so as far as the dehydrated UNhydrated wings it's a definite NO! Well moving on to the pizza. I did purchase the extra large pep and customized it half and half, the pizza did look like the menu and I asked for extra sauce which was perfect! However, the sauce was a little sweeter than I wanted today, somedays it's fine. My tastebuds wanted more savory than sweet. However I'd try them again when I want more of a sweeter sauce, the vegetables on one half ( supreme) were fresh, and of course you may know the wings are a NO for me.
Georgee's pizza was my family's go-to for years. I remember cramming into the wooden booths with my teammates and having a blast playing space invaders in the corner. Not only that, but their pizza was to die for. This is our first time back since they switched to 'fresh brothers.' There is no joy left in this restaurant. The employees seemed miserable and I don't blame them. Pizza is mid, it's no wonder LC Imports has an hour+ wait for pizza nowadays. not even a competition. Who cuts square slices?!
Alexandra H.
Good pizza! They have a keto crust so that was super cool! They only downside is it was very expensive. We got two personal sized pizzas and wings and it came out to $80. Each pizza was regular with keto and 3 toppings, was about $25 for one.
Ryan O.
Service was great. Give everyone a raise. Food was really bad. Burned edges, undercooked middle. Toppings sliding off the gluten free crust. Won't be going back. Do not recommend.
Becky d.
Easy ordering, fast delivery and liked the ability to order a split pizza with different toppings. The chicken park sliders were good! We like the pesto tomato sauce blend. Gave them 4 stars because a little pricey for pizza delivery. I'm new to the app so hope to get some coupons moving forward.
Nathaniel B.
1 star because what in the **** was that..... ok ok ok but seriously this is not pizza.... Why was the dough so doughy like not even cooked kinda doughy no crisp at all if you want to sell pizza get rid of the microwave you cooked this pizza in and get some real dough get a new oven preferably brick oven I mean you can even get a pizza stone if you like I feel taken advantage of because I'm a pizza lover and get so offended as a New Yorker when I get really bad pizza and this is really bad pizza if you guys want to advance in this industry take pride in what you serve and really learn to make a pizza invest in quality products like dough and sauce and good cheese but that oven has to go first things first baby steps no more serving your patrons this Red Baron Pizza from the grocery store!!! I got faith you guys can turn this around or at least drop the prices to what it's worth $4.99 for a large!!!
Our favorite pizza spot! Absolutely delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza dough/crust is really not good. Ordered thin and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
This place should be closed asap. I gave it 2 chances. 1st time it took close to 2 hours for delivery and the delivery and this store were blaming each other. Second time the cheese was like plastic and the wings were thinner than my pinky. It was laughable. Also what is up with the scary workers outside every single day smoking and hanging out? Disgusting.
Pizza was delicious and fast
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Boneless Bites
For me, a pepperoni pizza isn't a pepperoni pizza unless it features the pepperonis that turn into little bowls of grease. The fact that you'll get all that AND some burnt ones for that little bit of extra crunch makes Fresh Brothers a winner in my book. In 2 visits here, service has been impeccable--patient and accommodating, even during the last hour before the shop closed for the day. Thank you, Taylor, for always being exceedingly friendly, kind, and professional! Really top-notch customer service every time. To save yourself some time, pick up the phone or place an order online and you'll have fresh, hot pizza out of the oven within 20 minutes. Pepperoni lovers, do not miss out on the Trippple Pep, featuring pepperoni 3 ways, while the Charcotta pizza takes it to the next level with scoops of ricotta on each square-cut slice. The inside dining area is clean and has ample tables and seating for small groups. There is also plenty of parking behind the restaurant. The menu features several other creative pizza combinations, as well as classic topping choices that you can order on your pizza(s) as you see fit. They also offer options for crusts as well as salads, wings, and other goodies. Like any good pizza joint, delivery is also available.
Georgee's pizza you are not! First, the place in empty....at opening all the way until they close. I made the mistake of trying the place even though they basically closed Georgee's down and they spent an entire year closed after that. How on earth do they keep 5 people working all day (they are a private equity owned company, by the way)? Two medium pizzas were delivered at almost $75.00! Were they good?Well....they were ok. About what you would expect from a fast food chain. On par with Dominoes or Pizza Hut at 4 times the cost. The pizza was delivered cold and late. How do you do that when you are so close to us? I hope in the future it changes to a better restaurant that is not owned by private equity. Probably the funniest thing they have done is put a huge banner in the front window saying "they now have BEER" in huge writing. Guess what, still nobody showed up. This place was amazing when it was Georgee's.....now it is hands down the worst restaurant in the city. I am sorry to be so blunt, but it is horrible.
While the pizza was pretty tasty, the cutting needed some MAJOR improvement. The slices were not cut all the way, making it difficult to pick them up without tearing the pizza. Aside from this, the service and food were fairly good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
I'm not really sure what's up with this place. Gave it another chance, and we went to pick it up considering how terrible delivery service was. Somehow, the order was worse? Ordered 3 sliders, got 2. The pizza was essentially par baked, so much so pieces of mozzarella were not melted. Totally abysmal. Avoid at all costs.
Pizza is so-so, but edible. Did not make me ill. Sauce is kinda blah. It's just okay.
If dehydrated chicken are a thing welp here ya go. Of course they looked NOTHING like the menu photo or I wouldn't have spent $12.99 on 12 wings. You had the option of crispy or regular and I chose regular, im not particularly fond of my gums being attacked by my food. These were very crispy, so if these are regular buyer beware if you like crispy, I think crispy will definitely be the consistency of a dehydrated jerky with a bone. I've seen their adds on social media and decided to give them go, so as far as the dehydrated UNhydrated wings it's a definite NO! Well moving on to the pizza. I did purchase the extra large pep and customized it half and half, the pizza did look like the menu and I asked for extra sauce which was perfect! However, the sauce was a little sweeter than I wanted today, somedays it's fine. My tastebuds wanted more savory than sweet. However I'd try them again when I want more of a sweeter sauce, the vegetables on one half ( supreme) were fresh, and of course you may know the wings are a NO for me.
Restaurantji Recommends
Georgee's pizza was my family's go-to for years. I remember cramming into the wooden booths with my teammates and having a blast playing space invaders in the corner. Not only that, but their pizza was to die for. This is our first time back since they switched to 'fresh brothers.' There is no joy left in this restaurant. The employees seemed miserable and I don't blame them. Pizza is mid, it's no wonder LC Imports has an hour+ wait for pizza nowadays. not even a competition. Who cuts square slices?!
Good pizza! They have a keto crust so that was super cool! They only downside is it was very expensive. We got two personal sized pizzas and wings and it came out to $80. Each pizza was regular with keto and 3 toppings, was about $25 for one.
Service was great. Give everyone a raise. Food was really bad. Burned edges, undercooked middle. Toppings sliding off the gluten free crust. Won't be going back. Do not recommend.
Easy ordering, fast delivery and liked the ability to order a split pizza with different toppings. The chicken park sliders were good! We like the pesto tomato sauce blend. Gave them 4 stars because a little pricey for pizza delivery. I'm new to the app so hope to get some coupons moving forward.
1 star because what in the **** was that..... ok ok ok but seriously this is not pizza.... Why was the dough so doughy like not even cooked kinda doughy no crisp at all if you want to sell pizza get rid of the microwave you cooked this pizza in and get some real dough get a new oven preferably brick oven I mean you can even get a pizza stone if you like I feel taken advantage of because I'm a pizza lover and get so offended as a New Yorker when I get really bad pizza and this is really bad pizza if you guys want to advance in this industry take pride in what you serve and really learn to make a pizza invest in quality products like dough and sauce and good cheese but that oven has to go first things first baby steps no more serving your patrons this Red Baron Pizza from the grocery store!!! I got faith you guys can turn this around or at least drop the prices to what it's worth $4.99 for a large!!!