The best banana pudding you’ll ever have. Recipe is his grandmothers and he’s a super nice guy. I tried lots of flavors and they were all amazing. My favorite had to be the original banana pudding though. Must try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
dyanna torres
Very helpful with service and very delicious pudding.Wheelchair accessibility: Facility has entrance for wheelchair access
Did it live up to the hype? Yes, yes, and yes. Ever since I got back from New York where I had some of the best banana pudding, I've been on the hunt for something similar in San Diego. I found myself near the area, so I stopped by to try Extraordinary Banana pudding, and I am so glad I did. They had many different flavors but I am basic and like original stuff, so I went with the regular and also tried the banana pudding cupcake. The pudding was fluffy, smooth, had fresh bananas, and wafers - it was so delicious. The cupcake was also just as good, it reminded me of banana bread in cupcake form. The only thing I wish was different is the packaging and the pudding to have more wafers, but that is obviously a personal preference. The owner is also very friendly and welcoming. Large trays were available, but I believe those need to be ordered in advance. It is a bit pricey, but what isn't, inflation is everywhere. Overall, I will be back for more!
Eric Skorupski
Really nice guy runs the shop. The pudding is amazing. The cookies were too sweet but that pudding, man all of of them pudding good!
I swung by today after my shift at the USS MIDWAY and it was way worth the drive. I bought the Oreo, Coconut and Vanilla and all I have to say is that this is the best Banana pudding I have ever tasted in my life. I was a cook in the navy and my pudding never came out this good. Go try it and you will see what I am talking about.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bryan And G.
We saw EXTRAORDINARY BANANA PUDDING on KUSI NEWS, Channel 69, yesterday; and it looked so good that we decided to drop by the LA MESA STOREFRONT to pick up a Large BANANA PUDDING w/ TWO COOKIES on top. We met the founder, who was very nice, and we explained how much we liked his story. WE THOUGHT THAT THE BANANA PUDDING WAS ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! We understood that he got the recipe from his grandmother, SHE WOULD BE VERY PROUD OF HIM, and his three storefronts. He also gets us early six days a week to make every recipe in Scripps Ranch. He's a very industrious man and a true asset to La Mesa, Ca!!!
Gabriela M.
Saw this place featured on a KUSI segment and had to try it out. A lot of variety in pudding flavors, they let you sample a few which is very helpful as hard to decide which ones to get. Tried the OG banana which was my favorite, pistachio was great and Ube which was a lovely color and flavorful. This place is dangerous because can easily eat this pudding all day. Go at your own risk!
Danieli Gabardo (True Nature Therapies)
Amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pudding, Cheesecake
Carol J.
Amazing. Best banana budding ever and I've had a lot of banana pudding in my life. Owner was so very nice. They have tons of different options but I like the traditional banana pudding the best. Plain simple and delicious
I was really disappointed in this place. I heard about it and the hype but unfortunately it did not live up to it. I felt like I wasted $40 on 4 different types of pudding. It tasted like it come out of a box.. I can’t even be mean about it, it just was not good. The man behind the counter was engaging, I’ll give him that. The environment was lack luster. Just damn.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Rasmuzzen
My kids love it. Defiantly worth
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding Taco
Christian K.
Came here with a couple guys to try some of their pudding and it was fire. The owner of the store was working during that time and he was dope and helped us out with what we wanted, and you can just tell the difference between his customer service and the standard customer service you normally see. We talked while we tried some of it and the customer service was fire as well. We ordered a bunch of different flavors, my favorite was pistachio and cheesecake. Probably coming again soon
Kaela M.
great pudding and great owner! i highly recommend the ube and banana bread pudding. i will definitely be returning :)
Kristin C.
Great service and amazing pudding! The bread pudding was my favorite. Didn't get to try the original but will come back for it. Brought some to work and everyone enjoyed it!
The best banana pudding you’ll ever have. Recipe is his grandmothers and he’s a super nice guy. I tried lots of flavors and they were all amazing. My favorite had to be the original banana pudding though. Must try!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very helpful with service and very delicious pudding.Wheelchair accessibility: Facility has entrance for wheelchair access
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana 8oz, Banana Cheesecake, Strawberry Banana 12oz
Did it live up to the hype? Yes, yes, and yes. Ever since I got back from New York where I had some of the best banana pudding, I've been on the hunt for something similar in San Diego. I found myself near the area, so I stopped by to try Extraordinary Banana pudding, and I am so glad I did. They had many different flavors but I am basic and like original stuff, so I went with the regular and also tried the banana pudding cupcake. The pudding was fluffy, smooth, had fresh bananas, and wafers - it was so delicious. The cupcake was also just as good, it reminded me of banana bread in cupcake form. The only thing I wish was different is the packaging and the pudding to have more wafers, but that is obviously a personal preference. The owner is also very friendly and welcoming. Large trays were available, but I believe those need to be ordered in advance. It is a bit pricey, but what isn't, inflation is everywhere. Overall, I will be back for more!
Really nice guy runs the shop. The pudding is amazing. The cookies were too sweet but that pudding, man all of of them pudding good!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Cheesecake, Banana Bread 8oz
I swung by today after my shift at the USS MIDWAY and it was way worth the drive. I bought the Oreo, Coconut and Vanilla and all I have to say is that this is the best Banana pudding I have ever tasted in my life. I was a cook in the navy and my pudding never came out this good. Go try it and you will see what I am talking about.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We saw EXTRAORDINARY BANANA PUDDING on KUSI NEWS, Channel 69, yesterday; and it looked so good that we decided to drop by the LA MESA STOREFRONT to pick up a Large BANANA PUDDING w/ TWO COOKIES on top. We met the founder, who was very nice, and we explained how much we liked his story. WE THOUGHT THAT THE BANANA PUDDING WAS ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! We understood that he got the recipe from his grandmother, SHE WOULD BE VERY PROUD OF HIM, and his three storefronts. He also gets us early six days a week to make every recipe in Scripps Ranch. He's a very industrious man and a true asset to La Mesa, Ca!!!
Saw this place featured on a KUSI segment and had to try it out. A lot of variety in pudding flavors, they let you sample a few which is very helpful as hard to decide which ones to get. Tried the OG banana which was my favorite, pistachio was great and Ube which was a lovely color and flavorful. This place is dangerous because can easily eat this pudding all day. Go at your own risk!
Amazing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pudding, Cheesecake
Amazing. Best banana budding ever and I've had a lot of banana pudding in my life. Owner was so very nice. They have tons of different options but I like the traditional banana pudding the best. Plain simple and delicious
Highly recommended ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I was really disappointed in this place. I heard about it and the hype but unfortunately it did not live up to it. I felt like I wasted $40 on 4 different types of pudding. It tasted like it come out of a box.. I can’t even be mean about it, it just was not good. The man behind the counter was engaging, I’ll give him that. The environment was lack luster. Just damn.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
My kids love it. Defiantly worth
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Banana Pudding Taco
Came here with a couple guys to try some of their pudding and it was fire. The owner of the store was working during that time and he was dope and helped us out with what we wanted, and you can just tell the difference between his customer service and the standard customer service you normally see. We talked while we tried some of it and the customer service was fire as well. We ordered a bunch of different flavors, my favorite was pistachio and cheesecake. Probably coming again soon
great pudding and great owner! i highly recommend the ube and banana bread pudding. i will definitely be returning :)
Great service and amazing pudding! The bread pudding was my favorite. Didn't get to try the original but will come back for it. Brought some to work and everyone enjoyed it!