Amici pizza most delicious pizza in Lake Forest. Great and very friendly delivery guys. We love Ameci Pizza and Pasta! We always get the pasta we choose. We have also had their veggie pizza, which were wonderfully cheesy and the pizza was delicious as well. Everything has great flavor and the staff is always very friendly and accommodating. Thank you, Amici pizza You guys deserve five stars. *****
JD H.
Love the sandwiches here! Their bread is so good! Been going here so long it's crazy & it's still so good!
Janelle Weinberg
A family favorite for over ten years!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mimi V.
Always great pizza and quality never had any issues. The garlic cheese sticks and mushroom pepperoni pizza thin crust is our go to.
5 Minute Noodles
I remember hearing somewhere that they went under new ownership, though I don’t know if this is true. Either way, their recipes changed. This really pains me because this used to be one of my favorite pizza places. Honestly? Just order anything here without cheese if you plan to purchase food from here. The cheese is extremely oily and greasy, and the pizzas are soggy and soaked orange.
Jackelyn Jones
I want to love this place. The pizza has the potential to be the best around because of the flavor and ingredients. Unfortunately, every time we have ordered our pizza has been under cooked. The pizza is wet and soggy in the middle *except for the plain cheese. I just can't do the expense of its going to be poorly cooked. It's too expensive to take the gamble.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Jackelyn J.
I want to give them 5 stars, but it's too expensive for soggy undercooked pizza. However, if you just get plain cheese it should be fine. EVERY time we've ordered toppings the pizza has been wet and soggy in the middle. One time we added artichokes for $2.49 and there was maybe 5 pieces on the whole pizza and not even the little heart bit. It just isn't worth the money until they can get quality for price under control.
MITCH P.
Went here Sunday and first time to try to their pasta and their famous calzone. Out of this world it's so good. I would recommend trying their ziti and Alfredo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti with Sausage Tray, Homemade Meatballs & Marinara Sauce Catering, White Knight Pizza, Saugage & Pepper Sandwich
Lindsey R.
Our delivery was over an hour late and the pizza just wasn't what I remember it to be 20 years ago
Leo
We’ve honestly tried this place a number of times, especially since it is a small chain business, and we have had issues every…single…time. A few examples:-Ordered through DoorDash for pickup only to find they didn’t even realize they had the order and had to wait at the place for over half an hour even though the app said it was ready for pickup. Bad look when there is one guy in the back is frantically working to make pizza but the other staff are hanging out on their phones.-Ordered on the website for delivery for the food to get delivered more than 90 minutes past the projected delivery time. Had to call multiple times to figure out what was going on with the person on the phone giving me random incorrect guesses on time and “accidentally” hanging up on me twice.-Ordered through the website, said it’ll be done in 15 minutes for pickup. No confirmation email. When I called to confirm if they got it, I had to prod to figure out how long it’d take to pick up and was told to wait another 40 minutes. Took over an hr after it was all said and done. Again made us feel like a nuisance for even asking.This is how a business steadily tarnishes their reputation and lose customers. Maybe they are busy because there is low density of local pizza places and can get away with these issues.Well good thing that is changing. More pizza places are available in the area.Suggest you order elsewhere.
Their pizza is good, but they constantly get our toppings wrong. We usually get our pizza at Costco ($10), but every once in a while we splurge and get two pies at Ameci's so I can get a pep/sausage/mushroom and my husband can have a deluxe with no mushrooms. $58 Dollars later, my pie is missing the only ingredient I really want (mushrooms). I double checked the handwritten order receipt and they wrote it correctly, but whoever made it didn't read it correctly. It makes me angry because of the high cost, and it doesn't help that the staff are unfriendly every time we pick up. This might finally be the final pizza order from Ameci for us. SMH 4.5 Stars for food taste/quality 2 Stars for getting the order not quite right every time 1 Star for staff (c'mon, you're in the service business -- serve your customers well!)
l F
Order half cheese and half pepperoni ?? with French bread ? was great and delicious ?Upon delivery pizza was still hot fresh. My son and I enjoyed it will order
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Two Slices of Pizza w One Topping
Eric Schechter
Excellent pasta and great service! I love the Philly cheesesteak, it’s excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Lam
Good pizza and nice service.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Rich J.
they r busy they are on their game. popular because its good- the pasta dishes are good for two meals!!
Amici pizza most delicious pizza in Lake Forest. Great and very friendly delivery guys. We love Ameci Pizza and Pasta! We always get the pasta we choose. We have also had their veggie pizza, which were wonderfully cheesy and the pizza was delicious as well. Everything has great flavor and the staff is always very friendly and accommodating. Thank you, Amici pizza You guys deserve five stars. *****
Love the sandwiches here! Their bread is so good! Been going here so long it's crazy & it's still so good!
A family favorite for over ten years!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always great pizza and quality never had any issues. The garlic cheese sticks and mushroom pepperoni pizza thin crust is our go to.
I remember hearing somewhere that they went under new ownership, though I don’t know if this is true. Either way, their recipes changed. This really pains me because this used to be one of my favorite pizza places. Honestly? Just order anything here without cheese if you plan to purchase food from here. The cheese is extremely oily and greasy, and the pizzas are soggy and soaked orange.
I want to love this place. The pizza has the potential to be the best around because of the flavor and ingredients. Unfortunately, every time we have ordered our pizza has been under cooked. The pizza is wet and soggy in the middle *except for the plain cheese. I just can't do the expense of its going to be poorly cooked. It's too expensive to take the gamble.
Food: 2
Service: 3
I want to give them 5 stars, but it's too expensive for soggy undercooked pizza. However, if you just get plain cheese it should be fine. EVERY time we've ordered toppings the pizza has been wet and soggy in the middle. One time we added artichokes for $2.49 and there was maybe 5 pieces on the whole pizza and not even the little heart bit. It just isn't worth the money until they can get quality for price under control.
Went here Sunday and first time to try to their pasta and their famous calzone. Out of this world it's so good. I would recommend trying their ziti and Alfredo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spaghetti with Sausage Tray, Homemade Meatballs & Marinara Sauce Catering, White Knight Pizza, Saugage & Pepper Sandwich
Our delivery was over an hour late and the pizza just wasn't what I remember it to be 20 years ago
We’ve honestly tried this place a number of times, especially since it is a small chain business, and we have had issues every…single…time. A few examples:-Ordered through DoorDash for pickup only to find they didn’t even realize they had the order and had to wait at the place for over half an hour even though the app said it was ready for pickup. Bad look when there is one guy in the back is frantically working to make pizza but the other staff are hanging out on their phones.-Ordered on the website for delivery for the food to get delivered more than 90 minutes past the projected delivery time. Had to call multiple times to figure out what was going on with the person on the phone giving me random incorrect guesses on time and “accidentally” hanging up on me twice.-Ordered through the website, said it’ll be done in 15 minutes for pickup. No confirmation email. When I called to confirm if they got it, I had to prod to figure out how long it’d take to pick up and was told to wait another 40 minutes. Took over an hr after it was all said and done. Again made us feel like a nuisance for even asking.This is how a business steadily tarnishes their reputation and lose customers. Maybe they are busy because there is low density of local pizza places and can get away with these issues.Well good thing that is changing. More pizza places are available in the area.Suggest you order elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Their pizza is good, but they constantly get our toppings wrong. We usually get our pizza at Costco ($10), but every once in a while we splurge and get two pies at Ameci's so I can get a pep/sausage/mushroom and my husband can have a deluxe with no mushrooms. $58 Dollars later, my pie is missing the only ingredient I really want (mushrooms). I double checked the handwritten order receipt and they wrote it correctly, but whoever made it didn't read it correctly. It makes me angry because of the high cost, and it doesn't help that the staff are unfriendly every time we pick up. This might finally be the final pizza order from Ameci for us. SMH 4.5 Stars for food taste/quality 2 Stars for getting the order not quite right every time 1 Star for staff (c'mon, you're in the service business -- serve your customers well!)
Order half cheese and half pepperoni ?? with French bread ? was great and delicious ?Upon delivery pizza was still hot fresh. My son and I enjoyed it will order
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Two Slices of Pizza w One Topping
Excellent pasta and great service! I love the Philly cheesesteak, it’s excellent!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza and nice service.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
they r busy they are on their game. popular because its good- the pasta dishes are good for two meals!!