The best sandwiches and service!! I had a problem ordering online and they caught it on their end and called me to make sure they had my order correct. Above and beyond service!
Cheryl B.
The two sandwiches we had where horrible, one pastrami one combo. Bread was Dutch Crunch as hard as a rock. Hey where's the meat!! I tried to call the manager but I can't even get thru (mailbox full) I will never eat or ever recommend this place! Complete Waste of Money!
Alexia Cerritos
The sandwiches are very fresh.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: The Mr Pickle
Charles C.
called ahead for Cali-Tuna and Italian sandwiches, both on sourdough and they were ready when I arrived to pick them up and were very tasty.
Charlotte J.
So disappointed in the quality. I had to write this. Chicken salad was pieces of cubed chicken. Barely and of it, there was hardly any lettuce, pickles or peppers and one piece of avacado. The cheese sandwich was old lettuce and 2 pieces of cheese hardly any lettuce and a scrap of bacon that should not even be on the sandwich. that is disgusting. probably dirty cutting board. I took photos. You make your decision if you would eat there. $16.00 for the chicken salad
Tom Rush
Fantastic! My Rueben was made quick, everything fresh as could be, including the bread! So yummy. The staff were also wonderful. Overall a very solid 5/5! Highly recommended.
This is what a half sandwich looks like. $9Cj pastrami.
Anita H.
Arrived 2p on a Tuesday. Most tables were full but there was no line at the counter. We were cheerfully greeted as soon as we entered, and our pastrami sandwiches were made up relatively quickly and exactly as ordered (we substituted other cheeses). Very tasty, and free cookies are always nice! I especially appreciate being able to order a half sandwich. They're a little more expensive than, say, Erik's, but the included cookie offsets that a bit.
The Challenger
Had my sandwich delivered (cold cut) outstanding quality fresh ingredients. Even the free cookie was above expectations. It was soft and gooey.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kell B.
I put in my order half an hour ago online. Three minutes after my order is supposed to be ready, they tell me it will be another 10 minutes. They're clearly prioritizing the walk up customers, even though they've known about my order for going on 35 minutes at the time that I'm writing this.
came here on a weekday after lunch rush. Hoping it was an easy go in go out kind of deal. I had heard that they make a really good tuna sandwich and yes they were right they make a fantastic tuna sandwich. The bread was on point as well as the fillings. Definitely not your average tuna sandwich. Will be coming back for all my tuna sandwich needs.
Gilroy Gators M.
The Gilroy Gators swim team was hosting a very large swim meet at the Morgan Hill Aquatics center with almost 15 teams in attendance and we needed lunch for 60 adults. Jenna and her staff did not disappoint. We needed the sandwiches to be picked up at 10:30 AM which was early for a Saturday. The staff of Pickles came in early to prepare the sandwiches and they were very delicious. We had lots of compliments from the swim coaches how good the sandwiches were. There were no leftovers. The order was placed four days in advance. Thank you Pickles sandwich shop for your part in making our team hosted swim meet a success.
Mike M
Love this place. People are friendly and efficient. Sandwiches might be alittle pricey but the never leave you wanting
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hang Loose
Monte W.
Sandwich was overpowered by the mayonnaise. I couldn't taste the meat at all. Why do they call it Mr. if they don't even give you one? Mediocre chain restaurant that I have no desire to return to.
Ruchard A.
I have had various sandwiches at Mr. Pickles and all were delicious, and bread and ingredients were fresh Potato salad and macaroni salad were good too. Service is usually quick. Employees are friendly and accommodating. Employee have been cleaning table after sitting customer leave. On a nice day we site at table outside and enjoy the fresh air. Nice to have a good selection of meat. Bread, ingredients and non alcoholic drinks.
The best sandwiches and service!! I had a problem ordering online and they caught it on their end and called me to make sure they had my order correct. Above and beyond service!
The two sandwiches we had where horrible, one pastrami one combo. Bread was Dutch Crunch as hard as a rock. Hey where's the meat!! I tried to call the manager but I can't even get thru (mailbox full) I will never eat or ever recommend this place! Complete Waste of Money!
The sandwiches are very fresh.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: The Mr Pickle
called ahead for Cali-Tuna and Italian sandwiches, both on sourdough and they were ready when I arrived to pick them up and were very tasty.
So disappointed in the quality. I had to write this. Chicken salad was pieces of cubed chicken. Barely and of it, there was hardly any lettuce, pickles or peppers and one piece of avacado. The cheese sandwich was old lettuce and 2 pieces of cheese hardly any lettuce and a scrap of bacon that should not even be on the sandwich. that is disgusting. probably dirty cutting board. I took photos. You make your decision if you would eat there. $16.00 for the chicken salad
Fantastic! My Rueben was made quick, everything fresh as could be, including the bread! So yummy. The staff were also wonderful. Overall a very solid 5/5! Highly recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lightly Toasted, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Regular Chips
This is what a half sandwich looks like. $9Cj pastrami.
Arrived 2p on a Tuesday. Most tables were full but there was no line at the counter. We were cheerfully greeted as soon as we entered, and our pastrami sandwiches were made up relatively quickly and exactly as ordered (we substituted other cheeses). Very tasty, and free cookies are always nice! I especially appreciate being able to order a half sandwich. They're a little more expensive than, say, Erik's, but the included cookie offsets that a bit.
Had my sandwich delivered (cold cut) outstanding quality fresh ingredients. Even the free cookie was above expectations. It was soft and gooey.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I put in my order half an hour ago online. Three minutes after my order is supposed to be ready, they tell me it will be another 10 minutes. They're clearly prioritizing the walk up customers, even though they've known about my order for going on 35 minutes at the time that I'm writing this.
Restaurantji Recommends
came here on a weekday after lunch rush. Hoping it was an easy go in go out kind of deal. I had heard that they make a really good tuna sandwich and yes they were right they make a fantastic tuna sandwich. The bread was on point as well as the fillings. Definitely not your average tuna sandwich. Will be coming back for all my tuna sandwich needs.
The Gilroy Gators swim team was hosting a very large swim meet at the Morgan Hill Aquatics center with almost 15 teams in attendance and we needed lunch for 60 adults. Jenna and her staff did not disappoint. We needed the sandwiches to be picked up at 10:30 AM which was early for a Saturday. The staff of Pickles came in early to prepare the sandwiches and they were very delicious. We had lots of compliments from the swim coaches how good the sandwiches were. There were no leftovers. The order was placed four days in advance. Thank you Pickles sandwich shop for your part in making our team hosted swim meet a success.
Love this place. People are friendly and efficient. Sandwiches might be alittle pricey but the never leave you wanting
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Hang Loose
Sandwich was overpowered by the mayonnaise. I couldn't taste the meat at all. Why do they call it Mr. if they don't even give you one? Mediocre chain restaurant that I have no desire to return to.
I have had various sandwiches at Mr. Pickles and all were delicious, and bread and ingredients were fresh Potato salad and macaroni salad were good too. Service is usually quick. Employees are friendly and accommodating. Employee have been cleaning table after sitting customer leave. On a nice day we site at table outside and enjoy the fresh air. Nice to have a good selection of meat. Bread, ingredients and non alcoholic drinks.