Wow! Of course all the food here is incredible but this review is going to be about Evette... What an incredible server! We came here last Sunday with about 30 people! She handled all of us with such ease, grace and kindness...I wonder if anything ever rattles this girl! She was just so kind and patient which is just unbelievable for such a large group! I was embarrassed to even admit this, that we had so many separate checks, and how she handled that was unbelievable as well! I gave her a huge tip, I just hope my friends followed suit... Hopefully, this yelp review will give her some recognition that is well deserved! Thanks again, sweet girl!!
Yvette L.
Our first time here, after noticing MPS, was open for business, we pulled in. First, the lentil soup.. pretty darn good. The lasanga was a really amazing, tasty, super flavorful, beautiful, authentic treat. The chicken parm and fettuccine.. Oh, wee. This spot and these entrées are going to become our faves to frequent. This is the salad nicely plated but came out warm, no chill or crunch, but the dressing made it ok~ish. Our next date night out here will be with MPS. Our waitress and her service were great she was very, sweet, and patient in helping us decide and recommending entrées.
Leslie Manzone
Love Mary’s Pizza ❤️?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt R.
Decided to give these guys a second chance because I know how good their pizza can be when it's on. My mom and I split a medium Toto combination. It was quite delicious. Definitely cooked a little longer than the previous one we had tried.
Dawna M.
I have been eating at Mary's Pizza Shack well over 30 years, the food has always been pretty good. I decided to order a pizza & a salad for pick up. I called them, placed my order & the girl taking my order said it would be ready in 20-30 minutes. I was already there in the parking lot, it was raining so I just hung out in my car for about 20 min. I went in, they were getting ready to close, I stood at the counter for a few minutes then I guy comes to the register, I say I have a pick up order, he rings me up $43.00 ????? Plus I tipped. When I placed my order I asked for my pizza to be crispy it was not it was soggy and gross. There was no flavor. Salad 95% lettuce very little topping. Medium pizza $30.00 Salad $8.95 + tax. I won't be back, over priced and the quality was not good. I waited another 15 minutes for my pizza, that I was told was still in the oven, yet when I get it it's not even hot warm at best & soggy.
Elijah G.
Great pizza after a wine tour , I love a family owned business , fresh ingredients , great service
Kennedy M.
Hit or miss pizza when ordering takeout. I just ordered a pizza, which was slightly undercooked. It's hard to tell but you'll notice there's no char around the pepperoni and every bite was slightly "doughy." Person taking the order over the phone also forgot my side order ranch dressing that I explicitly asked for when I arrived to pick up my order. Food is much better when dining in.
Lloyd Lucas
One of my favorite places.Love Mary's salad.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Crysta Tim
Atmosphere and service were excellent. The food is fairly good as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Josh Heide
Mary's reached out after my negative experience and made things right. I was offered a gift card so I could give them a second chance. I am happy to report that everything was perfect on this visit. The pizza was ready on time and brought out piping hot and it tasted good. When in the mood for this style of pizza, I'll be back.This could have been an excellent pizza if the service was better. I had ordered a pizza with carside delivery and after waiting 5 minutes past the designated time I went inside to check on my order. I waited several more minutes before I was helped despite many employees and no customers. Finally, I was helped and handed my pizza from a warmer that evidently doesn't work. By the time I got home, six blocks away, my pizza was cold. I can say the pizza reheated better than most. If it had been brought out fresh and hot from the oven, it would have been an excellent pizza. What I ended up with was diabolical and a complete waste of almost 25 dollars.
I stoped by for dinner on 12/12/23. Pizza was good, probably even better than before they closed for business earlier this year! Salad was great and fresh. We got a GREAT server (too bad it was this guy last day at this place) I am glad they open again. Ambiance was ok, place can use a few TVs.
Laura Bush
I've gone to Mary's Pizza since I was a kid. Ita the best pizza, pasta and Italian food.Good atmosphere and food! They let us bring the dog in to eat!♥️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dawna Monckton (Baby Love)
My family & I have been going to Mary’s for over 30 years. We really missed Mary’s when they decided to close the Napa location. So many good times there. Now they are back!!! THANK YOU MARY’S. We love the food. All of it! It’s always good. I can’t remember a time when it wasn’t. The service has always been pretty good. Usually when we go there is 10 - 12 of us. The staff are all very nice with happy faces. We also have Mary’s delivered & that is always good too. Mary’s is a family restaurant, casual & fun atmosphere.Vegetarian options: Well it is Italian food. There are vegetables & salads, pastas & pesto & pizzas.Parking: Mary’s gets pretty busy at times. Parking can get filled up. The parking is located behind the restaurant. There are handicapped parking spaces right up by the restaurant.Kid-friendliness: Kids are always there. They have menu’s for the kids to color & drinks come with lids & a straw. Kids are part of the Mary’s atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Dressing, Pepperoni Pizza, Meatball, Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo, Fresco Pesto Breadsticks, Pizza Slice, Penne with Italian Sausage, Cobb Salad, Mozzarella Garlic Bread, Brownie, Breadsticks, Bruschetta Napoletana, Not Just a Crispy Chicken Sandwich, Sandwich, Gigantic Chocolate Chunk Cookie, Tiramisu
Bobbie Ohalloran
Kid-friendliness: My 5 year old grandson had make your own pizza which he very much enjoyed!
Wow! Of course all the food here is incredible but this review is going to be about Evette... What an incredible server! We came here last Sunday with about 30 people! She handled all of us with such ease, grace and kindness...I wonder if anything ever rattles this girl! She was just so kind and patient which is just unbelievable for such a large group! I was embarrassed to even admit this, that we had so many separate checks, and how she handled that was unbelievable as well! I gave her a huge tip, I just hope my friends followed suit... Hopefully, this yelp review will give her some recognition that is well deserved! Thanks again, sweet girl!!
Our first time here, after noticing MPS, was open for business, we pulled in. First, the lentil soup.. pretty darn good. The lasanga was a really amazing, tasty, super flavorful, beautiful, authentic treat. The chicken parm and fettuccine.. Oh, wee. This spot and these entrées are going to become our faves to frequent. This is the salad nicely plated but came out warm, no chill or crunch, but the dressing made it ok~ish. Our next date night out here will be with MPS. Our waitress and her service were great she was very, sweet, and patient in helping us decide and recommending entrées.
Love Mary’s Pizza ❤️?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decided to give these guys a second chance because I know how good their pizza can be when it's on. My mom and I split a medium Toto combination. It was quite delicious. Definitely cooked a little longer than the previous one we had tried.
I have been eating at Mary's Pizza Shack well over 30 years, the food has always been pretty good. I decided to order a pizza & a salad for pick up. I called them, placed my order & the girl taking my order said it would be ready in 20-30 minutes. I was already there in the parking lot, it was raining so I just hung out in my car for about 20 min. I went in, they were getting ready to close, I stood at the counter for a few minutes then I guy comes to the register, I say I have a pick up order, he rings me up $43.00 ????? Plus I tipped. When I placed my order I asked for my pizza to be crispy it was not it was soggy and gross. There was no flavor. Salad 95% lettuce very little topping. Medium pizza $30.00 Salad $8.95 + tax. I won't be back, over priced and the quality was not good. I waited another 15 minutes for my pizza, that I was told was still in the oven, yet when I get it it's not even hot warm at best & soggy.
Great pizza after a wine tour , I love a family owned business , fresh ingredients , great service
Hit or miss pizza when ordering takeout. I just ordered a pizza, which was slightly undercooked. It's hard to tell but you'll notice there's no char around the pepperoni and every bite was slightly "doughy." Person taking the order over the phone also forgot my side order ranch dressing that I explicitly asked for when I arrived to pick up my order. Food is much better when dining in.
One of my favorite places.Love Mary's salad.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Atmosphere and service were excellent. The food is fairly good as well.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mary's reached out after my negative experience and made things right. I was offered a gift card so I could give them a second chance. I am happy to report that everything was perfect on this visit. The pizza was ready on time and brought out piping hot and it tasted good. When in the mood for this style of pizza, I'll be back.This could have been an excellent pizza if the service was better. I had ordered a pizza with carside delivery and after waiting 5 minutes past the designated time I went inside to check on my order. I waited several more minutes before I was helped despite many employees and no customers. Finally, I was helped and handed my pizza from a warmer that evidently doesn't work. By the time I got home, six blocks away, my pizza was cold. I can say the pizza reheated better than most. If it had been brought out fresh and hot from the oven, it would have been an excellent pizza. What I ended up with was diabolical and a complete waste of almost 25 dollars.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Bread was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I stoped by for dinner on 12/12/23. Pizza was good, probably even better than before they closed for business earlier this year! Salad was great and fresh. We got a GREAT server (too bad it was this guy last day at this place) I am glad they open again. Ambiance was ok, place can use a few TVs.
I've gone to Mary's Pizza since I was a kid. Ita the best pizza, pasta and Italian food.Good atmosphere and food! They let us bring the dog in to eat!♥️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My family & I have been going to Mary’s for over 30 years. We really missed Mary’s when they decided to close the Napa location. So many good times there. Now they are back!!! THANK YOU MARY’S. We love the food. All of it! It’s always good. I can’t remember a time when it wasn’t. The service has always been pretty good. Usually when we go there is 10 - 12 of us. The staff are all very nice with happy faces. We also have Mary’s delivered & that is always good too. Mary’s is a family restaurant, casual & fun atmosphere.Vegetarian options: Well it is Italian food. There are vegetables & salads, pastas & pesto & pizzas.Parking: Mary’s gets pretty busy at times. Parking can get filled up. The parking is located behind the restaurant. There are handicapped parking spaces right up by the restaurant.Kid-friendliness: Kids are always there. They have menu’s for the kids to color & drinks come with lids & a straw. Kids are part of the Mary’s atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Dressing, Pepperoni Pizza, Meatball, Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo, Fresco Pesto Breadsticks, Pizza Slice, Penne with Italian Sausage, Cobb Salad, Mozzarella Garlic Bread, Brownie, Breadsticks, Bruschetta Napoletana, Not Just a Crispy Chicken Sandwich, Sandwich, Gigantic Chocolate Chunk Cookie, Tiramisu
Kid-friendliness: My 5 year old grandson had make your own pizza which he very much enjoyed!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo