Mountain Mike's Pizza

5333 Thornton Ave, Newark
(510) 494-8177

Recent Reviews

Gertrudes Nepacena

Price on the hard copy menu different from what I was charge. Clerk said price had gone up. Unfriendly clerk too. Tipping is not worth it.

Charitha Sumeet

Ordered the veggie pizza. Literally a blast. Amazing !Vegetarian options: Impressed with veg options. They taste fab too!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crusts

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Everest Pizza

Nitin Sharma

I ordered a veggie pizza from them and ther delivered me a pizza and i never knew there was chicken in there i don’t recommend this store anymore please don’t come here being a pure vegetarian i will always regret visiting this store ( worst pizza store ever)

Sam Nichols

I regret coming here.To begin, the guy I talked to on the phone had the quietest voice and mumbled the whole time. I found it incredibly rude. It was nearly impossible to understand him and I had to ask him to repeat himself quite a few times. When I arrived at the store, I had the misfortune of speaking to the same man. Once more, he barely opened his mouth when he spoke so I was forced to ask him to say the same thing over and over.The pizzas are cut weirdly. It looks like a classroom hit some goal so all the elementary school kids get 1/3 of a slice. The sauce tastes cheap, like you would get in a cafeteria. To be fair, the pepperonis were really crispy and tasty. But it certainly wasn't enough to save a horrible pizza.The pizza's quality made me feel bad, but the high price made me feel worse. I did not receive anything close to the quality I paid for.All in all, I would not recommend it nor return.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Lynne Wright

This particular Mountain Mikes is a jewel. The all you can eat adult lunch is $12.99. The food was fresh and hot and a good selection. The salad bar is fresh. They overheard that I am not eating meat and they made a cheese pizza just for me without asking. The place is clean, the service is amazing!Vegetarian options: Salad bar, veggie, cheese or cinnamon pizzaDietary restrictions: Salad bar for vegan or healthy option. Cheese orv vegan pizza for vegetarian.Parking: More than enough parking.Kid-friendliness: Kids love pizza, they have two high chairs, large screen TV and a gumball machine section.Wheelchair accessibility: Front door has accessible parking and ramp. Wide isles around tables.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Half Dome Sandwich, Cinnamon Dessert Pizza, Pepperoni-Mountain

Anthony Lopez

This place is so clean friendly staff and fast. Moved here 1year ago and have been ordering from here for every party I have.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Everest Pizza, Garlic Sticks with Cheese-Medium, Pepperoni-Large, Pepperoni-Mountain

Vincent Orender

They delivered to wrong address and I spent 15 minutes on the phone trying to get a replacement or refund only to have them consistently pass the phone around back and forth between the delivery driver and cashier and refused to be given to a manager while they themselves argued with each other. Eventually they just hung up on me refusing any assistance. The staff is very argumentative and unprofessional would not recommend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Vince O.

They delivered to wrong address and I spent 15 minutes on the phone trying to get a replacement or refund only to have them consistently pass the phone around back and forth between the delivery driver and cashier and refused to be given to a manager while they themselves argued with each other. Eventually they just hung up on me refusing any assistance. The staff is very argumentative and unprofessional would not recommend.

Lori Leal Parker

Pizza was good, just a bit greasy for me. Next time I will ask for it to be cooked a couple minutes longer.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Vee C.

Terrible service, the old timer taking phone orders was rude & unprofessional. When I went in to pick up my order more of the same poor attitude only this time it was directed at the customer ahead of me. So there it wasn't just me He is rude to what appears to all customers!

Eddie Knox

If you are a fan of Mountain Mike's, well this one is special. You won't know it by the appearance of the place, but it's the best Mike's I have ever had .They know how to make pizza.Vegetarian options: If you want it, they'll make it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Perla Z.

Placed an online order for (8) mountain pizzas, then ordered an additional (1) separately, with the 2nd order I added 30 ranches and it did NOT give me the option to do sides of JALAPEÑOS. I looked under extras AND sides. I get there, off the bat you could tell the guy (who I assume is the owner) is in a bad mood. He's being rude to 2 Mexican guys trying to place an order. My turn comes up, I tell him I have 2 online orders; "let's deal with one at a time first." Rudely. Gives me my receipts, then starts bringing the boxes. I tell him, it didn't let me add sides of jalapeños online but if I can have some. He says "it should've." I said "it literally didn't", "it should've." I have no reason to lie, we spent $450 for pizzas and $30 alone in ranch! I don't care if jalapeños cost extra! Whatever, he gets me a measly (5) small sides of jalapeños. He only brings out (8) pizzas. I tell him I have 9 pizzas. He's like they're all there, I'm like no, this is only 8. He goes to the back and comes back with my final pizza and says oh it's because you have 2 orders(which I already told you?!) I used to work in a pizza place and we got large orders all the time, but if a customer is NOT being rude to you, there is no need to be rude. How do you expect people to want to come back? 3 stars because the pizza was still delicious. I love mountain mikes but man, that older gentleman needs to work on his people skills.

Manny

Great pizza place, one of the best looking ones where I live. The only downsid to this place is that the owner always looks at you when you're trying to enjoy your food. He gives you these "I'm watching you Wasauski, always watchin'" type vibes.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 4

Caleb Owens

Very very good. Staff was kind. Pizza was suprising. Good dining area, bathroom was clean too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Claudia Latisniere

Delicious pizza, and the size of wings are huge,

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More