Pie Dreams

5855 Jarvis Ave D, Newark

Recent Reviews

Jelly2 Tasty

Open special hours for holidays such as Pi Day, St. Patrick's Day, and Easter. Will update stars after tasting.

Mary X.

We regularly come here for our pie fix. To be honest, before Pie Dreams I wasn't the biggest pie person. But the butter pie crust here is sooo good. I also love that that rotate flavors pretty regularly which is a good reason to come back and try something new. We've probably tried almost all the flavors already. Our favorites are the hand pies - anything with apple honestly. Recently they've got the blackberry apple which is a delicious combo of tart and sweet flavors. I've also gotten their savory pies and more recently got the Mama Lo's Mechado to bake-at-home. I will say the price was a bit steep, but I enjoy supporting local businesses and their flavors are good. In the future I'd probably just stick with their usual sweet pies though. My favorite regular pie is probably the French silk pie or caramel apple pie. The owner's kids are often handling the register and they're friendly. There are some tables indoors so you can enjoy your pie immediately if you'd like. It'd be nice if they offered in house drinks in the future, I think it'd up the ambiance a bit more. Will continue to support either way!

A. C.

The summer fruit pies are amazing! They make a great all butter crust. Coffee chess is flavorful. I'm not a fan of the chocolate silk pie (too sugary and not enough chocolate flavor), but I think I was expecting something more like Sweet Adeline Bakery's chocolate cream pie. Friendly service. I'm a repeat customer.

Vicki L.

Got a slices of every pie: salted caramel apple, purple potato , salted coffee chess, dark chocolate raspberry. The crust is really flaky and delicious. Almost best crust I've ever had. The apple and dark chocolate raspberry were my favs. I didn't get to taste the coffee chess. Was surprised that the purple pie was decent as I'm not a fan of the purple potato. Appreciated that all the pies had just the right amount of sweetness but not too sweet. Service was great! There was even a kid running the register. She must have been maybe 10 years old. She knew everything about the pies and was so mature and professional. I appreciate local businesses and even those that have children help out. If this place was closer, it would be dangerous but totally worth the 25 min drive.

Janina V.

I have been meaning to try pie dreams for the longest time. But it's hard to go since the opening days are just limited in a week and I heard they sell out fast too. I got lucky that there were some left over pies on a Sunday and I got to reserve some pies through dm'ing the shop through there Instagram stories. I tried the key lime, raspberry chocolate and apple pie. All the fillings were so good! My favorite part is the crust, it reminded me of a buttery croissant. Hopefully I can try more of there pies in the future!

K L

Best pies in the South Bay. I’ve been making pies for 25 years and this is one of the few places that makes better pies than me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

YooBin K.

I finally had the chance to try PIE DREAMS and my GAHT... We rank it : #1 blueberry lemon hand pie : the sugar toppings add a splendid crisp BITE and you will find whole blueberries for the filling inside and it's super flavorful and the crust reminds me of a fancy cousin of the elephant ear pastry. Delicious would go back for their hand pies #2 coffee custard they provide a small packet of salt for you to sprinkle on top so adorable and the custard is so creamy and cold and pleasant! My bf said it reminded him of viet coffee while it made me think of the golden Korean instant coffee from Maxim HAHA I feel like there's enough caffeine to keep you going in this one slice of pie #3 key lime pie: lovely presentation but the custard was too sweet for our liking but eating each bite with the cream dollops on top balanced the flavors out a bit ANYWAYS DEF GOING BACKKKKKK

Isabel H.

Had the pleasure of trying the pumpkin pie on thanksgiving day. Simply amazing!!! I will definitely make the trip from San Jose to try the rest of the pies.

Alena N.

My favorite go tos are the Keylime Pie and French Silk! This is a cute family owned business, they have their kids helping run the front. Wonderful service by all. Deliciously made pies

Tuong H.

Really wholesome spot, the owner is really nice and knowledgeable about pies. Had a good little seasonal selection ended up getting one of each pie because they all sounded good. Devoured all of them in one sitting only regret is not buying more!

Helen M.

Best pie in Bay area! We brought it to potluck, everyone loves it. Better come early as pie sold out fast.

Rica ..

Warning this place with spoil you for any other pie. We loved the Santa pie for the holidays. Service was quick and we were lucky enough to buy a whole pie at the holidays without pre-ordering. Looking forward to coming back to try other pies in the future. This place is small so not really a place to sit and eat, but decor is cute and we will definitely be back again. Ricky knows how to make pie.

Mykola Dzyuba

The store doesn't update its hours on Google Maps. The Google Maps says the store is open however it is closed till 1/19. The store doesn't post its phone number on Google Maps. So, there is no way to call and check if they are open.

Service: 2

Vincent H.

Great Pies! Absolutely great Pies. Not overly sweet, or overly heavy. Hand pies are great as well. We don't live close but will happily make the trip.

Juan M.

Amazing tasting pies, but difficult to catch them open and even more difficult to catch the French silk pie. Really delicious pie. It looks like they're open weekends, but even then I've seen a few times where it was unavailable. The pies are good enough though to keep trying.

Load More