One of the best pies I ever had. As a former baker, you really need to buy two pies a person, my only regret. Also, the ladies working there were very nice and even offered to hold our pies if needed.
Susan S.
WOW. How bout a cheeseburger in a pie. Yes you heard me right, not only a hand pie with the savory taste of a cheeseburger all in one, make it grass fed beef too, yup you get the benefit of Omega 3's & other health benefits while downing that cheeseburger pie. Taylor, one of the new owners stopped me in my tracks when he told me about the best seller. It sounded unusual but I went ahead & tried it. It was like a cheeseburger but not like a cheeseburger cause it's a pie too. They pack the hand pie with lots of ground up local grass fed beef. It was delicious and filled me up. Go ahead and order that pie and any other scrumptious pie on the menu. They have fruit pies, big pies and hand pies. And wish Taylor & his mom his business partner the best. Gosh it's great to see a young, local Petaluma entrepreneur have a dream and act on it.
Megan Sanborn
Savory and sweet delicious pies!! Pear/ginger/cardamom was amazing and all flavors rotate through. Super friendly and kind staff. Excited to see what flavors surprise us during our next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
American Lover
Lemon, Banana Cream; The best bakery. The most delicious pies. Creative dream cooks: key lime, fruits, unbelievable, delicious pies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Monat G.
Wow the blueberry pie was awesome. Not too sweet, great crust. Looking forward to visiting again for more delicious pies!
Kyle Youngblood
It is national pie day and they closed early due to"low inventory." They didn't make enough pies.
Jeff Farnsworth
I only marked the atmosphere down because there’s no place to sit inside. Plenty of seating outside in the park and around the surrounding areas.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob T.
I used to really enjoy stopping by and getting a selection of pies to take home, Sometimes as many as 10 because all of them are absolutely delicious. It had been a few years since my last visit so I decided to stop by and get some pies... Wow! Not sure what happened but every pie is DOUBLE the price! They were generally priced at about $4.50/$5.50... Now they are $9.75! I could understand if they made them 30% larger but they are not, Same size, Twice the price. Not sure how the price could double. I understand the cost of doing business and the costs of goods needed to make the pies but when you look at this small 6" hand pie and try to justify spending $10 on it you'll perhaps think twice about visiting them. Lot's of other options in Petaluma for good food. Bummer for your employees on trying to making tips... I had my very final pie that day, Chicken Tinga, I paid with a $10 bill... Got $0.25 back... Which went in the tip jar. Good luck on your future with PPC... At prices like yours... there are alternatives that give you more food for the money. Absolutely delicious savory pies ridiculously overpriced.
Danielle Maldonado
Zero stars. Can’t rate what they didn’t have. What kind of pie company has no pies? Close at 6 and at 520 had 4 meat pies yuck and one mini apple pie left. We are not from here but went out of our way to support. Not good business practices if your goal is to sell out when pie refrigerates just fine, at least on the weekends. Overall disappointed and unimpressed. Shout out to Hand Made Ice Cream across the street. Creme Caramel Toffee sundae was awesome.
One of the best key lime pies we ever had! Taylor was an angel and walked us through the pie flavors they had available. Really kind fella who knows his pie stuff! We definitely recommend dropping by here if you're ever visiting Petaluma - we know we will!
Bryon S.
Pies were yummy. Bought 6 and all tasted delicious. Definitely a good place to check out.
Malinda R.
They never have any cream pies I've been going there for the past six months and there is never a single cream pie and I go at different times too and when I call they says they don't have any staff and they are short handed and I even called to to
Lynn R.
Their pies are delicious! I took a pecan, an apple, and a pear/ginger/cardamom to a Thanksgiving dinner and they were all a huge it!
Adrienne L.
Great pies!! Delicious sweet & savory, regular size and hand or mini size. Perfect for a quick lunch, dessert, anytime.
One of the best pies I ever had. As a former baker, you really need to buy two pies a person, my only regret. Also, the ladies working there were very nice and even offered to hold our pies if needed.
WOW. How bout a cheeseburger in a pie. Yes you heard me right, not only a hand pie with the savory taste of a cheeseburger all in one, make it grass fed beef too, yup you get the benefit of Omega 3's & other health benefits while downing that cheeseburger pie. Taylor, one of the new owners stopped me in my tracks when he told me about the best seller. It sounded unusual but I went ahead & tried it. It was like a cheeseburger but not like a cheeseburger cause it's a pie too. They pack the hand pie with lots of ground up local grass fed beef. It was delicious and filled me up. Go ahead and order that pie and any other scrumptious pie on the menu. They have fruit pies, big pies and hand pies. And wish Taylor & his mom his business partner the best. Gosh it's great to see a young, local Petaluma entrepreneur have a dream and act on it.
Savory and sweet delicious pies!! Pear/ginger/cardamom was amazing and all flavors rotate through. Super friendly and kind staff. Excited to see what flavors surprise us during our next visit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lemon, Banana Cream; The best bakery. The most delicious pies. Creative dream cooks: key lime, fruits, unbelievable, delicious pies.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow the blueberry pie was awesome. Not too sweet, great crust. Looking forward to visiting again for more delicious pies!
It is national pie day and they closed early due to"low inventory." They didn't make enough pies.
I only marked the atmosphere down because there’s no place to sit inside. Plenty of seating outside in the park and around the surrounding areas.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I used to really enjoy stopping by and getting a selection of pies to take home, Sometimes as many as 10 because all of them are absolutely delicious. It had been a few years since my last visit so I decided to stop by and get some pies... Wow! Not sure what happened but every pie is DOUBLE the price! They were generally priced at about $4.50/$5.50... Now they are $9.75! I could understand if they made them 30% larger but they are not, Same size, Twice the price. Not sure how the price could double. I understand the cost of doing business and the costs of goods needed to make the pies but when you look at this small 6" hand pie and try to justify spending $10 on it you'll perhaps think twice about visiting them. Lot's of other options in Petaluma for good food. Bummer for your employees on trying to making tips... I had my very final pie that day, Chicken Tinga, I paid with a $10 bill... Got $0.25 back... Which went in the tip jar. Good luck on your future with PPC... At prices like yours... there are alternatives that give you more food for the money. Absolutely delicious savory pies ridiculously overpriced.
Zero stars. Can’t rate what they didn’t have. What kind of pie company has no pies? Close at 6 and at 520 had 4 meat pies yuck and one mini apple pie left. We are not from here but went out of our way to support. Not good business practices if your goal is to sell out when pie refrigerates just fine, at least on the weekends. Overall disappointed and unimpressed. Shout out to Hand Made Ice Cream across the street. Creme Caramel Toffee sundae was awesome.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
One of the best key lime pies we ever had! Taylor was an angel and walked us through the pie flavors they had available. Really kind fella who knows his pie stuff! We definitely recommend dropping by here if you're ever visiting Petaluma - we know we will!
Pies were yummy. Bought 6 and all tasted delicious. Definitely a good place to check out.
They never have any cream pies I've been going there for the past six months and there is never a single cream pie and I go at different times too and when I call they says they don't have any staff and they are short handed and I even called to to
Their pies are delicious! I took a pecan, an apple, and a pear/ginger/cardamom to a Thanksgiving dinner and they were all a huge it!
Great pies!! Delicious sweet & savory, regular size and hand or mini size. Perfect for a quick lunch, dessert, anytime.