I really want to like this place. But the delivery takes forever. Like 1.5+ hours for a pizza. I stopped ordering awhile back because the pizza would always arrive super late and lukewarm. Then I recently tried again, but still the same problem. They use Door Dash so maybe that adds time? Anyway, I'm going to have to abandon this place again. I have littles and can't always jet out to pick up my pizza. Besides, if you have a delivery service I would think you would want to be competitive here. Instead, you are losing a customer.
Ryan B.
Know its just a kid they got workin the register bit I dont remember the last time I was met with such attitude for trying to buy a pizza by the slice lmaoI will not be coming back, easiest decision anyones ever made for me.
JTheCreator
Just visiting and decides to try this place out and to my surprise the pizza is really good. Will definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Combo Pizza
Robert R.
My wife and I ordered a gluten-free pepperoni pizza last night and delivered to Crooked Goat Brewery which is one of our favorite new places in Petaluma. The sauce, cheese, and pepperoni were excellent but the crust was burnt and chewy. Like eating a piece of beef jerky. We called the restaurant and spoke with an employee who told us that is the way it's supposed to be. That pizza has to stay in longer to melt the cheese but that results in the crust being burnt. I was like, Really! We asked to maybe get a credit for another pizza down the road since it was pretty horrible and wanted to give it a second chance and they said "NO". Because we ordered it through the Brewery they can't help us and we need to talk with the manager at the Brewery about any credit etc. It's pretty common now to order food into these pubs so if that is the policy I would suggest you remember this before you order a $37.00 14" pizza from Stefano's or anyone else when delivering in. I honestly don't believe that would be the policy for most establishments but apparently, it is at Stefano's. Have a nice day .
Vane Alins
Bless your heart Pricilla I think that was your name. Sorry if wrong. but You’re a sweet heart we Amazon drivers appreciate you so much. keep being an amazing person. :)
Cristhian Montiel
The food was good, and the servers were friendly. I saw one of the servers get hit with the door tho. Hope the homie ok. Was funny tho ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Callie B.
BEST PIZZAAAAA!!! Have been getting this pizza forever. It is so good. Always good fresh but if you take some to go and cook it extra well done in a toaster over it is the best! Definitely give it a try. Also this is the best location they always put the perfect amount of cheese.
Debra Lopez
First time here. Tasty pizza, pesto sauce was good.nNice deals on pizza combos.A little crowded & noisy at 5:30 pm on Friday with the young crowd, but plan to return on another day.
Jeff tanner
Best pizza. My wife and I both love it for take out. It truly is in my opinion the very best take out pizza. Sometimes we have to crisp up the crust but it is so tasty. And the sauce... is excellent. There are always coupons so it makes it worth it. And it will fill you up unlike other pizza places.
Stefano's Pizza is a great place for lunch, dinner, or any time you need a snack throughout the day! They have a slice and soda deal for a delicious large slice and fountain drink of your choice, and sports games on tv for those who are looking to keep up with who's playing. The food is great, and the tables are always clean, no doubt due to the excellent service!
Ron H.
I gotta give this spot some major love. They really came through with a super tasty pie and gave me a doordash driver discount. That thing was a piece of art and was so Delicious. Check my pics
Cynthia L.
Hospitality - A++Calzone with chicken and garlic sauce A++Stopped in for a pizza and ended up getting calzone. They were close to closing. They were so nice not to rush us out. We hurried anyway. Spinach Salad A++The calzone was delicious and so was the spinach salad. We enjoyed our meal. During the daytime they sell slices of pizza. We missed it, but will be returning.
Kevin Moore
Pizza was really good. (I had the garlic chicken) and had plenty of meat on it. Beer selection was only 3
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jake H.
Staying in a nearby hotel and looking for just that great bite of pizza. This place delivers. Awesome crust, tangy and sweet sauce, lots of great mozzarella. I eat way more pizza than I should, and a lot of it is garbage. This place is the real deal. Love it!
Over priced, so so pizza.
Food: 3
Service: 5
I really want to like this place. But the delivery takes forever. Like 1.5+ hours for a pizza. I stopped ordering awhile back because the pizza would always arrive super late and lukewarm. Then I recently tried again, but still the same problem. They use Door Dash so maybe that adds time? Anyway, I'm going to have to abandon this place again. I have littles and can't always jet out to pick up my pizza. Besides, if you have a delivery service I would think you would want to be competitive here. Instead, you are losing a customer.
Know its just a kid they got workin the register bit I dont remember the last time I was met with such attitude for trying to buy a pizza by the slice lmaoI will not be coming back, easiest decision anyones ever made for me.
Just visiting and decides to try this place out and to my surprise the pizza is really good. Will definitely come back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers Combo Pizza
My wife and I ordered a gluten-free pepperoni pizza last night and delivered to Crooked Goat Brewery which is one of our favorite new places in Petaluma. The sauce, cheese, and pepperoni were excellent but the crust was burnt and chewy. Like eating a piece of beef jerky. We called the restaurant and spoke with an employee who told us that is the way it's supposed to be. That pizza has to stay in longer to melt the cheese but that results in the crust being burnt. I was like, Really! We asked to maybe get a credit for another pizza down the road since it was pretty horrible and wanted to give it a second chance and they said "NO". Because we ordered it through the Brewery they can't help us and we need to talk with the manager at the Brewery about any credit etc. It's pretty common now to order food into these pubs so if that is the policy I would suggest you remember this before you order a $37.00 14" pizza from Stefano's or anyone else when delivering in. I honestly don't believe that would be the policy for most establishments but apparently, it is at Stefano's. Have a nice day .
Bless your heart Pricilla I think that was your name. Sorry if wrong. but You’re a sweet heart we Amazon drivers appreciate you so much. keep being an amazing person. :)
The food was good, and the servers were friendly. I saw one of the servers get hit with the door tho. Hope the homie ok. Was funny tho ?
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
BEST PIZZAAAAA!!! Have been getting this pizza forever. It is so good. Always good fresh but if you take some to go and cook it extra well done in a toaster over it is the best! Definitely give it a try. Also this is the best location they always put the perfect amount of cheese.
First time here. Tasty pizza, pesto sauce was good.nNice deals on pizza combos.A little crowded & noisy at 5:30 pm on Friday with the young crowd, but plan to return on another day.
Best pizza. My wife and I both love it for take out. It truly is in my opinion the very best take out pizza. Sometimes we have to crisp up the crust but it is so tasty. And the sauce... is excellent. There are always coupons so it makes it worth it. And it will fill you up unlike other pizza places.
Restaurantji Recommends
Stefano's Pizza is a great place for lunch, dinner, or any time you need a snack throughout the day! They have a slice and soda deal for a delicious large slice and fountain drink of your choice, and sports games on tv for those who are looking to keep up with who's playing. The food is great, and the tables are always clean, no doubt due to the excellent service!
I gotta give this spot some major love. They really came through with a super tasty pie and gave me a doordash driver discount. That thing was a piece of art and was so Delicious. Check my pics
Hospitality - A++Calzone with chicken and garlic sauce A++Stopped in for a pizza and ended up getting calzone. They were close to closing. They were so nice not to rush us out. We hurried anyway. Spinach Salad A++The calzone was delicious and so was the spinach salad. We enjoyed our meal. During the daytime they sell slices of pizza. We missed it, but will be returning.
Pizza was really good. (I had the garlic chicken) and had plenty of meat on it. Beer selection was only 3
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Staying in a nearby hotel and looking for just that great bite of pizza. This place delivers. Awesome crust, tangy and sweet sauce, lots of great mozzarella. I eat way more pizza than I should, and a lot of it is garbage. This place is the real deal. Love it!