New York Bagel & Sandwiches

10929 Olson Dr, Rancho Cordova
(916) 631-9509

Recent Reviews

Shana Mamulski

We love their breakfast bagel sandwiches! The bagels are baked fresh daily. I do think they could use some new updated tables & chairs inside for dine in.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Bagels

Miguel Paduani

Great bagels and quick service every time I visit I feel like I am back in Brooklyn getting a morning bagel. Most of the time it's not the morning but still anytime of day is great when the bagels are fresh like they are here. I never had a stale bagel and the sandwiches are good as well even though I feel that a little more meat may make a better sandwich it is prepared nicely and always fresh as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwich, Lox, Bagels, Smoke Salmon Cream Cheese

Rod D.

Fantastic bagel sandwiches eggwiches Bagels are soft chewy tasty Sandwiches are amazing Service is fast and efficient Love to support local businesses like this!!

Ts D.

They put peanut butter on the onion bagel, and regular shmear on the chocolate chip bagel (their mistake). When I sent it back, they began just scraping the shmear off each to re-swap. Disgusting and poor customer service. Who knows what other corners they are cutting a when people aren't watching.

Eugene L.

Great bagels and I have been coming for years to pick up a dozen bagels. The owner is incredibly nice and courteous.

Seth H.

We really enjoyed, this Cafe's Bagels and Service. Looked a bit shabby from the outside, but once we entered, the look came together. The coffee was great as well. I ordered the Americano, that I normally order from Starbucks. This Americano was better! Next time we are in the area we will stop by again.

Jasmin M.

Wanted to like this but place sucks , wanted a cinnamon bagel with strawberry cream cheese , there was clearly chunks of onion in there (probably used same knife to smear) and when I asked if I can change it or get it remade he goes "that's exactly what they gave you". Their hot chocolate is chalky and waste of money. Costumer service is mediocre as well and food. Go to Noah's.

Shelley Pratt

Skip Noah’s and Panera’s. Think hole-in-the-wall perfection. We ordered the ham and Swiss croissant this time. The owner also let us try a new pastry, too. Yum!The restaurant is clean, organized, has a large variety, and generous portions. The owners are so kind, too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ham & Cheese

Laura D.

This place is absolutely DELICIOUS, I love a mom & pop shop that provides fresh & quality ingredients!! Customer service is great, always friendly & helpful, never rush you when you are indecisive about what to order! My whole family loves this little spot (: Do yourself a favor a try them out I don't think you will regret it !! Pic is of my bacon, egg & cheese and it looks like this EVERY SINGLE TIME we come in !

Tyler M.

Their bagels are decent. I like to support a local business versus a chain. I ordered a garlic bagel with scallion cream cheese. W ordered an onion bagel with scallion cream cheese on one side and garlic/herb on the other. When he rang it up it came to $11.08. For two bagels with cream cheese. Since the "receipt" (via square) simply says "custom amount" I can only assume that means each bagel was $5.54. That is pretty steep for an average bagel. As much as I like to avoid the aforementioned chain stores, for less than a dollar more I could have gotten half a dozen bagels and smear had I gone there. Strangely, it is also $.55 per bagel more than their breakfast sandwiches which include egg and meat on a bagel which are $4.99. We're all impacted by inflation but $5.54 for a bagel!?! No thanks.

Colby B.

We really do love Bagel Cafe! They are so sweet and their bagels and croissants are the best! It just stinks when they run out or don't have their croissants, and they don't disclose it.

J T.

Disappointing... ate first half of bagel and it made me sick. 2 other bagels were ordered along with this one and they all had the same weird colored blackish brown egg. make sure to check because it wasn't visible until egg was cut open! Really disappointed because the bagels here are usually good.

Carl O'Neil

Always try to stop by when in the area. Love their breakfast sandwiches. Perfect bagels! Grabbed a couple bagel dogs to go for later. They were also awesome. The Jalapeño cheddar is my jam!

Nga L.

Fresh bagels and breakfast sandwiches made to order. Welcoming little corner bagel spot hits the spot. Our first time here. W Ordered: Onion bagel with bacon, cheese, and add cream cheese. I like my bagel a little more toasted but overall, solid and yummy sandwich. The flavors go great together. Jalapeño bagel with bacon, cheese, add cream cheese. Jalapeños were spicy and perfect! Another great breakfast bagel. Plenty of parking out front seating inside with one or two tables outside.

Bruce Banner

I cant stop putting their turkey, cheese, and avocado sandwich in my mouth.

Load More