I’ve always loved this place and I’m so happy to see the new owners breathing life into this old Redlands favorite! Most importantly the recipes have stayed the same too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brian M.
Jerseys is a no nonsense pizza shop. You are going to get thick crust, super cheesy, and a dense crust. The ingredients are fresh and the sauce is made on site. It's real good pizza. They will also make you a thin crust pizza if that's what you prefer. It's small, can be loud, and they have a small bar. Pizza is a little pricey, but what isn't nowadays? Give it try, it's better than most in the IE.
Michelle M.
It has been over 10 years since we ate at Jersey's. We really enjoyed it. We came with a large party of 12 and they were very accommodating. The pizza was delish. I was worried because I saw some reviews about overcooked crust but ours were perfectly cooked! Will definitely be back.
Mel Mel
Extreme late
Matt B.
Not sure what happened. This was the favorite pizza place in Redlands. Yesterday I picked up two pies. The pizzas were cooked but the cheese was like plastic. Possibly a lower quality cheese. It wasn't melted and remained shredded even after putting it back into the oven at home to try and get the cheese to melt. The texture & taste of the cheese was horrible. When we called about the pizzas, they said they think they may have gotten a bad batch of cheese and said they have gotten calls all day about it. Why continue to use the cheese? We've been diehards of Jerseys. Was able to get a refund. I believe there are new owners and changes have been made.
jose luis zamora jr
been a loyal customer with the calzone for seven years+. things have changed including the "recipe" . this used to be a beutiful pastry type fluffy dough. its so flat and empty now. not to mention the new owner was berating the staff so disrepectfully. .i will not bole coming back . this is their second chance with this new guy btw. used to come once a month at least. never again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Hailey K.
Use to be a big fan until the new managers came. So unfortunate that they are no good!
Delanie C.
If I could put a 0 star I would. First off, the older Jerseys was way better, I don't know who these new managers are but they are running g the place into the ground. The work environment in the kitchen even seems hostile, I've been in while the workers were being cussed out. Ridiculous. This is supposed to be a family friendly establishment we take our kids to. Not anymore. Food is overpriced for the poor quality aswell. Only really went there for the atmosphere.
Tippi Q.
I think they're closed, I've been several times in the last 2 months and the closed sign is up, it's dark and the door is locked. I sure hope not, I love their pizza.
Juli Spiller
Cleaned up by new owners, Great pizza and salad as always. Same
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza, Jerseys Special, Antipasta Salad
Have the pizza family special on saturdays for $28 ( extra large pizza 2 toppings , family ceasar salad , pitcher of soda) we go half peppetoni and jalepenos the other half canadian bacon, pinapple with easy bbq sau e / easy marinara on the other half , choice of dressing .50 . Downtown Redlands . Many shopping centers . We love it . One pitcher of choice of beer for only $17
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Ly M.
I love this place. My first time going there and the vibe of everyone there was so friendly and welcoming that is a rarity in this day of age. The staff super friendly and patient. The patrons of different nationalities and ages who don’t know each other are all very friendly with each other. The food is incredible. Highly recommended. For families and friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jerseys Special Pizza, Chicken Pesto, Antipasta Salad
Annmarie
Delicious pizza, fresh salads, great beer on tap options, locally owned, welcoming feeling, friend staff. It’s our go to pizza!
pizza are good but the sauce very little and dries up when
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jerseys Special Pizza, Jersey Pizza, Garlic Bread, Cheese Bread, Meat Lovers
Jacob Moreno
We originally we’re going to another place a few doors down, but the wait was extremely long, so we opted for Jerseys and it was delicious! Hands down, a great pizza! We’ll definitely be back.
I’ve always loved this place and I’m so happy to see the new owners breathing life into this old Redlands favorite! Most importantly the recipes have stayed the same too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jerseys is a no nonsense pizza shop. You are going to get thick crust, super cheesy, and a dense crust. The ingredients are fresh and the sauce is made on site. It's real good pizza. They will also make you a thin crust pizza if that's what you prefer. It's small, can be loud, and they have a small bar. Pizza is a little pricey, but what isn't nowadays? Give it try, it's better than most in the IE.
It has been over 10 years since we ate at Jersey's. We really enjoyed it. We came with a large party of 12 and they were very accommodating. The pizza was delish. I was worried because I saw some reviews about overcooked crust but ours were perfectly cooked! Will definitely be back.
Extreme late
Not sure what happened. This was the favorite pizza place in Redlands. Yesterday I picked up two pies. The pizzas were cooked but the cheese was like plastic. Possibly a lower quality cheese. It wasn't melted and remained shredded even after putting it back into the oven at home to try and get the cheese to melt. The texture & taste of the cheese was horrible. When we called about the pizzas, they said they think they may have gotten a bad batch of cheese and said they have gotten calls all day about it. Why continue to use the cheese? We've been diehards of Jerseys. Was able to get a refund. I believe there are new owners and changes have been made.
been a loyal customer with the calzone for seven years+. things have changed including the "recipe" . this used to be a beutiful pastry type fluffy dough. its so flat and empty now. not to mention the new owner was berating the staff so disrepectfully. .i will not bole coming back . this is their second chance with this new guy btw. used to come once a month at least. never again
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Use to be a big fan until the new managers came. So unfortunate that they are no good!
If I could put a 0 star I would. First off, the older Jerseys was way better, I don't know who these new managers are but they are running g the place into the ground. The work environment in the kitchen even seems hostile, I've been in while the workers were being cussed out. Ridiculous. This is supposed to be a family friendly establishment we take our kids to. Not anymore. Food is overpriced for the poor quality aswell. Only really went there for the atmosphere.
I think they're closed, I've been several times in the last 2 months and the closed sign is up, it's dark and the door is locked. I sure hope not, I love their pizza.
Cleaned up by new owners, Great pizza and salad as always. Same
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza, Jerseys Special, Antipasta Salad
Restaurantji Recommends
Have the pizza family special on saturdays for $28 ( extra large pizza 2 toppings , family ceasar salad , pitcher of soda) we go half peppetoni and jalepenos the other half canadian bacon, pinapple with easy bbq sau e / easy marinara on the other half , choice of dressing .50 . Downtown Redlands . Many shopping centers . We love it . One pitcher of choice of beer for only $17
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I love this place. My first time going there and the vibe of everyone there was so friendly and welcoming that is a rarity in this day of age. The staff super friendly and patient. The patrons of different nationalities and ages who don’t know each other are all very friendly with each other. The food is incredible. Highly recommended. For families and friends.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jerseys Special Pizza, Chicken Pesto, Antipasta Salad
Delicious pizza, fresh salads, great beer on tap options, locally owned, welcoming feeling, friend staff. It’s our go to pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza, Dinner Salad, Cheese Bread, Hawaiian Pizza, Antipasta Salad, Veggie Pizza
pizza are good but the sauce very little and dries up when
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jerseys Special Pizza, Jersey Pizza, Garlic Bread, Cheese Bread, Meat Lovers
We originally we’re going to another place a few doors down, but the wait was extremely long, so we opted for Jerseys and it was delicious! Hands down, a great pizza! We’ll definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5