I placed a large order on behalf of the company I work for, it was over $1,400 and Pauly's Pizza did not disappoint! They delivered our order ahead of time. I also worked with Mona on this to get it coordinated and she was amazing as well. All of our employees loved the pizzas! They have vegan and vegetarian options and those were the first to go at our meeting. I would highly recommend them for small and large orders.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Godzuki26
New York style pizza. The pizza is great. The Italian sub and the chicken Parm sandwich is really a
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Anthony Park
Brings me and my wife back to NYC… didn’t expect much at the first visit but now we know we’ll be regulars here. Glad to find this joint :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
DIO mega
Asked for a meatball sub with Spinach and they insisted on making it a mini calzone roll instead. It was all cheese with the thinnest slices of meat inside. I paid $16 for something I didn't want.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Vince Hundley
So tasty and quick, 7 pizzas ready in 30 minutes
Dig D.
Pretty good pizza slices. Various flavors, lot more white sauce pizza slices than Regents. Bacon ranch pizza is pretty good Parking Plaza has tons of parking What could be improved * tiny signs to tell you what individual pizza slice is which. Currently all the individual slices are unlabeled * pricing per slice is unadvertised. It's $4.8 per slice in Feb 2024. * No public restrooms, but they sell beer?
Ben A.
if there was a zero, I would leave it. I scheduled a door dash 4 hours in advance, and when I noticed that the order wasn't even confirmed 3 hours later, I called and they said "sorry, we're closing early and cancelling your order". So now, here I am with 7 people at my house, trying to find another place last minute to order from. Awful service and will never order from them again.
Fred Campos
Great pizza place, Pauly Walnuts set up
lisa j.
I picked up a pizza and calzone on their app in the morning for dinner pick up. About 30-45 mins after placing the order, I received a call asking if I could come earlier because they wanted to close early. I was surprised and had to scramble to get someone to cover for me so I could pick up food about 2 hours earlier. When I arrived the cook was standing outside and hadn't even made my order! No apology. I had to wait 20 mins. Food was OK, too much dough. I like supporting small businesses, but sometimes adjusting my schedule to accommodate theirs makes it difficult. I would not recommend Pauly's, especially not if you plan ahead.
Jon H.
I Found this spot coming back from CBX. It was a little late for a Wed. night 8:30p so I can't speak to the ambiance, but the service was wonderful. Friendly staff, nice tables, chairs, and stools. Clean little place that looks like a perfect lunch spot! I ordered a Stromboli and paid. While I was waiting, I noticed a bottle of salsa in their condiment basket, low and behold STRAIGHT HABANERO SALSA molcajete style (a little chunky) it looked amazing and I just couldn't wait, I had to try it. I was immediately warned about the spicy level, but not gonna lie, I do scare some people with the level of heat I'll eat! I was told Niko hand makes this treasure on the weekends. I love Habanero salsa, It goes so well with so many foods, but I don't put that sh!t on everything, that's not what it's for! The Stromboli came looking so tempting that I really had to hold off to snap this picture! I've got to say, this is the right size, right weight, and F'n Delish! The salsa perfectly kicked it up. Really nice balanced flavors, not salty, not sweet, not heavy it was just right! I live in Costa Mesa and I most definitely will be back here when I come down this way!! Try it, it's PIZZA!
Great food! Prices change way too often and if you try to call and ask too many question on about how much a certain pizza is they get mad at you. Example Paulys walnuts which is delicious used to be $29 last year and went up to $37 this year. I wish they stayed at the old location and just kept better prices and better service.
116745650591
Best pizza i've ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nikhil U.
Good solid pizza option in the sorrento valley/miramar area. Tried the buffalo chicken. Tried the pepperoni. Was so good, went and got another slice. Cons: Parking can be a problem during lunch in this strip mall since there are other food places as well
Lizbeth Zatarain
I ordered catering for an event and they were very nice respecting my budget and working with me. Since it was networking event they made sure to provide everything I needed and variety of food, not just pizza. Everyone loved it and will definitely get food from here again in future events around the area:)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexander Barbiere
Best pizza in the area, thinner crust… brings me back to NYC. Try the Christmas pie or anything with ricotta. Too die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Pepperoni Pizza, Italian Sub
I placed a large order on behalf of the company I work for, it was over $1,400 and Pauly's Pizza did not disappoint! They delivered our order ahead of time. I also worked with Mona on this to get it coordinated and she was amazing as well. All of our employees loved the pizzas! They have vegan and vegetarian options and those were the first to go at our meeting. I would highly recommend them for small and large orders.
Food: 5
Service: 5
New York style pizza. The pizza is great. The Italian sub and the chicken Parm sandwich is really a
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Brings me and my wife back to NYC… didn’t expect much at the first visit but now we know we’ll be regulars here. Glad to find this joint :)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Asked for a meatball sub with Spinach and they insisted on making it a mini calzone roll instead. It was all cheese with the thinnest slices of meat inside. I paid $16 for something I didn't want.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
So tasty and quick, 7 pizzas ready in 30 minutes
Pretty good pizza slices. Various flavors, lot more white sauce pizza slices than Regents. Bacon ranch pizza is pretty good Parking Plaza has tons of parking What could be improved * tiny signs to tell you what individual pizza slice is which. Currently all the individual slices are unlabeled * pricing per slice is unadvertised. It's $4.8 per slice in Feb 2024. * No public restrooms, but they sell beer?
if there was a zero, I would leave it. I scheduled a door dash 4 hours in advance, and when I noticed that the order wasn't even confirmed 3 hours later, I called and they said "sorry, we're closing early and cancelling your order". So now, here I am with 7 people at my house, trying to find another place last minute to order from. Awful service and will never order from them again.
Great pizza place, Pauly Walnuts set up
I picked up a pizza and calzone on their app in the morning for dinner pick up. About 30-45 mins after placing the order, I received a call asking if I could come earlier because they wanted to close early. I was surprised and had to scramble to get someone to cover for me so I could pick up food about 2 hours earlier. When I arrived the cook was standing outside and hadn't even made my order! No apology. I had to wait 20 mins. Food was OK, too much dough. I like supporting small businesses, but sometimes adjusting my schedule to accommodate theirs makes it difficult. I would not recommend Pauly's, especially not if you plan ahead.
I Found this spot coming back from CBX. It was a little late for a Wed. night 8:30p so I can't speak to the ambiance, but the service was wonderful. Friendly staff, nice tables, chairs, and stools. Clean little place that looks like a perfect lunch spot! I ordered a Stromboli and paid. While I was waiting, I noticed a bottle of salsa in their condiment basket, low and behold STRAIGHT HABANERO SALSA molcajete style (a little chunky) it looked amazing and I just couldn't wait, I had to try it. I was immediately warned about the spicy level, but not gonna lie, I do scare some people with the level of heat I'll eat! I was told Niko hand makes this treasure on the weekends. I love Habanero salsa, It goes so well with so many foods, but I don't put that sh!t on everything, that's not what it's for! The Stromboli came looking so tempting that I really had to hold off to snap this picture! I've got to say, this is the right size, right weight, and F'n Delish! The salsa perfectly kicked it up. Really nice balanced flavors, not salty, not sweet, not heavy it was just right! I live in Costa Mesa and I most definitely will be back here when I come down this way!! Try it, it's PIZZA!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food! Prices change way too often and if you try to call and ask too many question on about how much a certain pizza is they get mad at you. Example Paulys walnuts which is delicious used to be $29 last year and went up to $37 this year. I wish they stayed at the old location and just kept better prices and better service.
Best pizza i've ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good solid pizza option in the sorrento valley/miramar area. Tried the buffalo chicken. Tried the pepperoni. Was so good, went and got another slice. Cons: Parking can be a problem during lunch in this strip mall since there are other food places as well
I ordered catering for an event and they were very nice respecting my budget and working with me. Since it was networking event they made sure to provide everything I needed and variety of food, not just pizza. Everyone loved it and will definitely get food from here again in future events around the area:)
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza in the area, thinner crust… brings me back to NYC. Try the Christmas pie or anything with ricotta. Too die for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Pepperoni Pizza, Italian Sub