I tried almost everything here. Nice fusion mix of seafood and classic American dishes. I tried half the Aphrodite grilled cheese sandwich (shrimp and bacon grilled cheese), Siren garlic noodles (spicy garlic shrimp), cup of scallop bacon chowder, Triton fries (patagonia shrimp, baja shrimp, bay scallops, avocado ponzu, cheese sauce, scallions and garlic fries). My favorite was the Aphrodite Grilled Cheese Sandwich, amazing mix of all the ingredients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon and Scallop Chowder, Griffin Lobster Grilled Cheese Sandwich, Siren Sandwich, Triton Fries, Leviathan Lobster Roll
Giovanni G.
Unfortunately they are closed. Sign states will reopen mid January but it's February. Hopefully they reopen soon. Loved their triton fries
Gio G.
They are Closed! Not sure for how long as they posted they will reopen in January but it's February
pooja karande
This location is temporarily closed as on 29 jan 2024
Bin Chang
It is closed - not reflecting in google map. We came in vain
Yoko yun
plenty of seafood sandwichI would like to go again if I have a chance
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Rusty S.
Unfortunately I drove 20min to discover they're closed for half the month even though online says they're open. Hopefully they'll update their online calendars in the future as I saw others also disappointed.
Jeff L.
Eye eye captain! If you're into seafood on bread then shiver me timbers and look no further because X marks the spot on this hidden treasure chest. You walk in and it has the feel of a "no frills" brewery meets an artsy sandwich shop. We went for lunch and didn't get drinks so I won't be reviewing that portion of the menu. My problem was that I'm not very adventurous when it comes to seafood so I struggled a little bit with what to select. I ended up choosing The Encantado, which is a fried fish sandwich with aioli sauce. I had them put that on the side so I could dip my toe in the water. It was an excellent choice and I ended up wishing I had an extra portion of the sauce. Prices were fair and the atmosphere was cool. The food came out a little slow but not too bad. I would go here again, especially to try out some of their drinks as they had a pretty expansive list to choose from.
Berenice R.
I went there having great hopes. Horrible service, long line, long wait ñ. And when I get it to my desk to eat, it is %80 bread and I have yet to have claw and leg meat of a lobster. The only thing was their fries. This place is super overrated... and I ordered their chowder, can you say onion? All it had was flavor of onion and bland tasteless mush of croutons. Paid $40 for trash... definitely NOT WORTH IT!!! Never again!!!
Andrew D.
Super unique sandwiches. You can also turn into a rice or garlic noodle dish which is neat. A salad option would be great as well. Can't wait to return to try more of the menu!
We almost lost supernatural sandwiches. Over the last few years they've been closing most of their locations. This Miramar location did close for a little while while they figure things out. Luckily do we opened so that we can enjoy their awesome sandwiches. I've been coming here since they had to pop up at the Farmers market and I'm a still a fan to this day. My favorite is the classic siren sandwich and I also go with the trident. The shrimp and the siren is season perfectly and taste delicious and fresh. The balsamic tomato mixture that they put in it just perfectly compliments the sandwich. The bread is also very fresh and delicious. I also like the trident sandwich. Both are my favorites but I do try all their other sandwiches also and they are delicious. I probably tried like 80% of the sandwiches. They also have draft beer here so if that's something you'd like you can enjoy with your sandwich. Staff is awesome and parking is plentiful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yuna J.
The triton fries is the true star of the show. Worth the money and the hype. The reason my rating is 4 stars instead of 3. The sandwich is whatever. 3/5 for me. Not that garlic-y and not spicy, it tasted more tomatoe-y than anything. i felt like I was eating tomato soup in a sandwich.. but the bread is great haha.. would return for the fries and the fries only.
Angie M.
I'm glad that supernatural sandwich reopened. It was a little sad when they close for a while. We really thought they were not going to come back because they had clothes there are other locations before hand. To our surprise supernatural opened up again. I just love the siren sandwich and the lobster roll here. The siren is such a staple here that everybody I've known tried it. The shrimp is really fresh and tasty and cooked perfectly. The tomato balsamic mixture is also to die for. It perfectly complements the sandwich. The lobster roll was something that they added at a later time and it's quite delicious. They use fresh lobsters and it's cost in a light dressing and very tasty. It's a little bit under pressure side but that goes with the lobster territory. Even though these two are my favorite sandwiches I always venture out and try new ones from time to time. I think I've gone through 75% of the menu already. I'll certainly be back to try the rest. The staff here is always nice and patient with you when you are ordering. If you're like me I am very indecisive and sometimes it takes a little longer to put in my order. They also have draft beer here so if you want to sit down and have a beer with your sandwich you certainly can.
Sophia M.
Their ambiance is very cool. Scallop Bacon Chowder was awesome! Big chucks of scallops, veggies and bacon in the soup. Good sandwich. Big shrimps and the bread was delicious. Their fries were bomb! Crispy outside! The sauce came with the plate was so good! Creamy, slightly spicy and garlicky!
Caliesque C.
Excellent! The Griffin sandwich and Triton fries are delicious! I ordered the garlic fries well done. The portions are huge! Friendly service and cute atmosphere. Great place for coworkers.
I tried almost everything here. Nice fusion mix of seafood and classic American dishes. I tried half the Aphrodite grilled cheese sandwich (shrimp and bacon grilled cheese), Siren garlic noodles (spicy garlic shrimp), cup of scallop bacon chowder, Triton fries (patagonia shrimp, baja shrimp, bay scallops, avocado ponzu, cheese sauce, scallions and garlic fries). My favorite was the Aphrodite Grilled Cheese Sandwich, amazing mix of all the ingredients.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon and Scallop Chowder, Griffin Lobster Grilled Cheese Sandwich, Siren Sandwich, Triton Fries, Leviathan Lobster Roll
Unfortunately they are closed. Sign states will reopen mid January but it's February. Hopefully they reopen soon. Loved their triton fries
They are Closed! Not sure for how long as they posted they will reopen in January but it's February
This location is temporarily closed as on 29 jan 2024
It is closed - not reflecting in google map. We came in vain
plenty of seafood sandwichI would like to go again if I have a chance
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Unfortunately I drove 20min to discover they're closed for half the month even though online says they're open. Hopefully they'll update their online calendars in the future as I saw others also disappointed.
Eye eye captain! If you're into seafood on bread then shiver me timbers and look no further because X marks the spot on this hidden treasure chest. You walk in and it has the feel of a "no frills" brewery meets an artsy sandwich shop. We went for lunch and didn't get drinks so I won't be reviewing that portion of the menu. My problem was that I'm not very adventurous when it comes to seafood so I struggled a little bit with what to select. I ended up choosing The Encantado, which is a fried fish sandwich with aioli sauce. I had them put that on the side so I could dip my toe in the water. It was an excellent choice and I ended up wishing I had an extra portion of the sauce. Prices were fair and the atmosphere was cool. The food came out a little slow but not too bad. I would go here again, especially to try out some of their drinks as they had a pretty expansive list to choose from.
I went there having great hopes. Horrible service, long line, long wait ñ. And when I get it to my desk to eat, it is %80 bread and I have yet to have claw and leg meat of a lobster. The only thing was their fries. This place is super overrated... and I ordered their chowder, can you say onion? All it had was flavor of onion and bland tasteless mush of croutons. Paid $40 for trash... definitely NOT WORTH IT!!! Never again!!!
Super unique sandwiches. You can also turn into a rice or garlic noodle dish which is neat. A salad option would be great as well. Can't wait to return to try more of the menu!
Restaurantji Recommends
We almost lost supernatural sandwiches. Over the last few years they've been closing most of their locations. This Miramar location did close for a little while while they figure things out. Luckily do we opened so that we can enjoy their awesome sandwiches. I've been coming here since they had to pop up at the Farmers market and I'm a still a fan to this day. My favorite is the classic siren sandwich and I also go with the trident. The shrimp and the siren is season perfectly and taste delicious and fresh. The balsamic tomato mixture that they put in it just perfectly compliments the sandwich. The bread is also very fresh and delicious. I also like the trident sandwich. Both are my favorites but I do try all their other sandwiches also and they are delicious. I probably tried like 80% of the sandwiches. They also have draft beer here so if that's something you'd like you can enjoy with your sandwich. Staff is awesome and parking is plentiful.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The triton fries is the true star of the show. Worth the money and the hype. The reason my rating is 4 stars instead of 3. The sandwich is whatever. 3/5 for me. Not that garlic-y and not spicy, it tasted more tomatoe-y than anything. i felt like I was eating tomato soup in a sandwich.. but the bread is great haha.. would return for the fries and the fries only.
I'm glad that supernatural sandwich reopened. It was a little sad when they close for a while. We really thought they were not going to come back because they had clothes there are other locations before hand. To our surprise supernatural opened up again. I just love the siren sandwich and the lobster roll here. The siren is such a staple here that everybody I've known tried it. The shrimp is really fresh and tasty and cooked perfectly. The tomato balsamic mixture is also to die for. It perfectly complements the sandwich. The lobster roll was something that they added at a later time and it's quite delicious. They use fresh lobsters and it's cost in a light dressing and very tasty. It's a little bit under pressure side but that goes with the lobster territory. Even though these two are my favorite sandwiches I always venture out and try new ones from time to time. I think I've gone through 75% of the menu already. I'll certainly be back to try the rest. The staff here is always nice and patient with you when you are ordering. If you're like me I am very indecisive and sometimes it takes a little longer to put in my order. They also have draft beer here so if you want to sit down and have a beer with your sandwich you certainly can.
Their ambiance is very cool. Scallop Bacon Chowder was awesome! Big chucks of scallops, veggies and bacon in the soup. Good sandwich. Big shrimps and the bread was delicious. Their fries were bomb! Crispy outside! The sauce came with the plate was so good! Creamy, slightly spicy and garlicky!
Excellent! The Griffin sandwich and Triton fries are delicious! I ordered the garlic fries well done. The portions are huge! Friendly service and cute atmosphere. Great place for coworkers.