My Baking Creations (Cake Shop Bakery)

1800 23rd Ave, San Francisco
(415) 568-8060

Recent Reviews

Anna N.

Yana is absolutely amazing at her baking creations! My one year old received the most beautiful cookie arrangement for his birthday; it was well thought out and absolutely perfect for my fall baby THANK YOU!

Kristen B.

My Baking Creations did a wonderful job on a custom cake. Yana was responsive, flexible and talented. The cake came out amazing. Looking forward to using their services again!

Virginia W.

Um, wow. This cake was unbelievable. The chocolate cake itself was delicious and the design was really something to behold. My son wanted a Mario Cake with Bowser on it and oh boy did he get that! The Bowser even had reptile skin! So much detail. It really was just amazing. And it tasted delicious!

Amanda L.

The team at My Baking Creations did an amazing job with my order. I put in a request for a client's event and they were able to get me options for printed or hand piped designs on a cookie very quickly. All the options looked amazing! It was nice having the various options to see what would work with my budget. And the cookies were delicious!! I had wished there were a few extra, but they went quick! George and team did an amazing job and I look forward to working with them again!

Georgie Chand

10 stars if it were possible!Highly recommended! Make sure to order a few weeks in advance so that you can order your cookies to your likings!We wanted to surprise our closest friends with cookies announcing our pregnancy and we’re looking for a local custom cookie maker. George from My Baking Creations was prompt with his response and even provided picture samples of what we had in mind! (One of the other places never responded and the other doesn’t currently take custom orders!)After requesting specific colors, getting a quote and feeling like an important customer we had no choice but to order 11 - 2 sets of cookies! George even went out of his way in providing a link for Amazon cookie boxes so that we could package ourselves at a lower cost!We were offered several flavors but went with the most popular, vanilla - all our friends said they were delicious!Thank you George and your team! We will definitely come back for future orders (probably try the orange vanilla this time) and recommend you to others!Cost:Calendar design, $5.75 eachOnesies, $6.25*50% deposit required once ordered!

Natalie Willis

We ordered my daughter’s 5th birthday cake from Yana and George and it was a hit! They were super responsive, accommodating and the cake turned out beautifully! We received so many compliments - it was beautiful and tasted great!

Gabby

I ordered some chocolate shark cake pops and they are beautiful and so good! They were punctual and very respectful. I recommend this to anyone wanting delicious and stunning sweets!

Aram Bagdasarov

I've used the services of My Baking Creations for several corporate parties now. The first time, they created custom cookies and cake pops with our company's logo. My boss was blown away by both the appearance, quality, and the taste!We have offices in a few cities around the country, and I am pleased to say that we have an ongoing relationship with My Baking Creations and have ordered now on 5 different occasions. And yes, BTW, they ship nationwide!!!Couldn't be happier with their service and the quality of their custom cookies and cake pops.

irena e.

I've used Yana's services for several company parties now. The first time, she created custom cookies and cake pops based on our company logo. I was blown away both by the appearance and the taste! We have offices in a few cities around the country, and we all got custom baked goods with our logo for this particular party, and our cookies and cake pops were far and away the best looking ones!I simply had to return for our holiday party, and a co-worker who missed the cake pops the first time around had this to say: "Those cake pops, by the way, are CRAZY good. I had low expectations as I normally don't like them, but wanted to give a fair shot given the hype. They lived up to it!"Great communication, great collaboration, and great cookies!

Meegan B.

Another bakery canceled our order three days before we needed cookies (in December--peak season), and it was impossible to find someone to fill our order last minute. Until we found My Baking Creations! The cookies were tasty and beautiful, and George even delivered them secretly for me to help facilitate a surprise. They were beautifully wrapped in a gift box with a ribbon. Would definitely use them again.

Melody A.

They did my Babyshower cake & cakepops, I was so happy with the results! They really executed the image I wanted & the flavors were very tasty. Will definitely be working with them again in the near future!

Sami W

Big thank you to the folks from My Baking Creations. Not only did they save the day but did so under my budget. I reached out to them for customized cake for my girlfriends birthday. It was a surprise birthday and we had a "I love 80s" theme. What surprised me first was the level of professionalism on their end. Like I was at a luxury high-end boutique bakery. George quickly drafted a sketch design for the cake which was amazing. We went a little back and forth on the design and made some changes. George was very patient and courteous with me even after the 4th revision - sorry George. But he told me that the point of the sketch was to get my cake just right - no exceptions. Then once the design, flavor and all the other details were finalized, it was time for the baker - Yana - to work her magic. And boy did she deliver. Not only was the cake exactly as sketched by George but most importantly, it was super delicious. We went with the Strawberry vanilla flavor which I recommend to everyone. Again, thanks a million guys and I rest assured I am coming back with my next project in February. Can't wait!!!

Arman Simonyan

Yana and George went above and beyond as always. This is my second time ordering from them for my son’s birthday. I love how I only need to tell George what the theme is and he does his magic and creates sketch designs of the cake for me to choose from. No hassle at all. Not to mention the final product. Not only the cake looks amazing but also tastes delicious. Will be returning next year and the year after that and so on to eternity. Couldn't be happier to have found you guys.

Alla S.

I needed a custom cake for my son's 10 birthday. I did a quick yelp search and found My Baking Creations(Yana). She was super easy to work with, professional, and an incredible baker and cake decorator. I had a quick turnaround time for the cake but Yana fit us into her schedule with no problems. The kids, adults, everyone loved the cake and could not get over the incredible level of detail. I highly recommend My Baking Creations for all of your cake needs. Thank you Yana for making our sons 10th so memorable.

Krizia R.

Amazing service and people. I knew a week for 2 dozecustom cake pops would be a risk but they were able to accommodate in the design I wanted. It is a little extra because the design is not your typical cake pop you see. I was talking to George through emails and he would reply very quickly and they were able to come up with a sketch with exactly what I was looking for. Upon pickup it went smoothly and I believe I met with Yana who was very kind and the cake pops were packaged very nicely and secured. The design was clean and exactly like the picture. I would order from them anytime for any custom creations.

Load More

My Baking Creations (Cake Shop Bakery)

1800 23rd Ave, San Francisco, CA 94122
(415) 568-8060