Bonello's New York Pizza

806 S Gaffey St #3613, San Pedro
(310) 832-7544

Recent Reviews

Jennifer P.

I think this pizza is the best I've ever had!! The crust perfect, the sauce amazing, the service is with a smile. No frills pizza joint, coming back again!!!

WIlliam SIlva

Very good New York style pizza.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

graselita delatorre

I live in Orange County my husband is a longshoremen at the waterfront. He happen to stop by this place to grab a sandwich. He gets home later that day with his other half which was still a great size. I shared that half with a friend . Omg! This is the best sandwich I have ever had!!! It was still so fresh after driving 45 minutes back home to the OC the bread so fresh and yummy! At any rate, my hubby will be there once again, to buy me another. Or I might just take a drive for this delicious sandwich! It would definitely be worth the drive!

Food: 5

Joshua Sherwood

Honestly the best pizza iv ever had. I drove 2 hrs just to eat at

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Warren Wade

It's pizza a New Yorkers will eatWheelchair accessibility: Sidewalk level entrance no steps

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Happy Roll, Torpedo, Pepperoni Pizza New York, Antipasto, Salad

paulina g.

Honestly they deserve 5 stars! Greeted upon arrival, so much to choose from on the menu. So many options from pizza pasta and sandwiches oh and salad! So many topping options and Can I just say it's nice to be able to get a slice of pizza sometimes when you don't want a whole one. I will say it is a small space but there are about 5 tables. Let's get down to the order- Pepperoni Happy Roll Torpedo Pepperoni slice Cute little spot and very clean, you can tell they take pride in their restaurant. Be advised it is CASH ONLY, but don't let that stop you from trying the amazing food and come prepared. Parking behind building. I was overall so satisfied with the taste and quality of each piece, even the salad was so fresh and the cheese was so delicious and can taste it was some good premium cheese from the size of the pieces. The happy roll truly makes you the happiest it's just that good and the dough is perfection. It is huge and can def be shared if your appetite isn't so big. Good classic pepperoni pizza. The torpedo was just so good with all the flavors combined perfectly I can't even describe it just order it! Order it all like me to try a little of everything, you truly won't be disappointed. Might have to trek out again pretty soon, I have added it to my fave list! Can I also add the two guys there were just overall friendly and attentive. Great spot!

Lynn R.

Drove into town from 2 hours away. Toured the battleship and when it was time for lunch we headed to Bonello's since my son chose pizza. Fresh out the oven, they did not disappoint. The sauce was refreshing and the crust the right amount of soft and crunchy. Definitely gotta say they don't make pizza like this where I'm from. It'll be a stop the next time I'm back in the area.

Lala R

I grew up eating here my whole life I’m 40 and my kids love it here so do my grandparents and my mom an dad by far the best Italian food this is my happy place n my family’s too . We love the ppl best in town your missing out im not playing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Judy V.

Good pizza. Plenty of mushrooms and the pieces of sausage are good (much better than the crumbly stuff) The sauce is GOOD. I would try a thicker crust next time time

Cindee Z.

Bonello's pizza was great! I especially love their Happy rolls. The service was great, very friendly workers. Food was delicious. Dm We will be going to eat there again Cindee & Ben

Paul Farbman

The only place in Southern California for GENUINE NYC pizza!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Toni S.

Pizza is awesome! People are wonderful! Super busy tonight and people are working hard! Appreciate the authenticity and the feel of the place! Highly recommend!!

Cesar Ramirez

Very good food, I'm from back east and the pizza is pretty damn good and so is the torpedo sandwich. Happy roll is also a house specialty. Their version of the calzone. If your in the area and u love pizza you need to stop by, you will really enjoy the food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Happy Roll, Torpedo, Pepperoni Pizza New York, 2 Slice Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Bread, Cheese Pizza, Salad

Albert Maestro

great place and great food , only down fall is that they dont always answer their phones and you cannot order online which means you have to order in person and wait , its hard when you are on a time constraint during lunch , I tried calling my order in since 11am and no answer which makes it seem that they have enough business they can handle, makes me sad for I love their food but unfortunately for many of us we do not have the time to order in person and sit and wait with the lunch crowd.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

Justin

They make the best pizza anywhere in SoCal, also I could not more highly recommend the meatball happy roll. They make with chicken also if meatballs aren't your think. The only about them, is they are highly addictive lol. Be prepared to crave them often after trying one.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More