Marcelinos New York Pizza

12910 Magnolia Blvd, Sherman Oaks
(818) 505-1111

Recent Reviews

Ted R.

The pizza is inconsistent which I can't quite understand. Sometimes quite good; other times not so much. Even though I tend to order the same thing each time. Curious... Has anyone else experienced this?

Lisa B.

I wish I could give a higher rating I recently ordered thru door dash I was surprised with huge portions and extremely reasonable pricing and my pesto past was great the same for meat sause and the garlic bread smelled great and was even better when eaten

Shirley Turner

Kid-friendliness: Ordered a large pepperoni pizza for dinner on a Tuesday evening service was fast pizza was delicious. Thanks

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael O.

We had these guys cater a small anniversary get together and everyone was very happy, festive and we did not have a platter left with anything in it! My wife and I have been ordering from here at least once a month. I would for sure use them again for a get together in the future.

A A.

Saw this place passing by and decided to give it a try after reading reviews. It definitely did not disappoint, pizza was good. It was easy to place an order online and pickup time was accurate. Staff was very welcoming and friendly.

Sarah S.

the chocolate chip cookies were delicious! the pizza was good and the owner/staff are very friendly

Evette M.

The food is delicious and the portions are large. They serve more garlic knots than other places and the marinara sauce is addicting. I have only ordered food here through door dash. The food is handled carefully and nothing is ever missing. I have only tried the chicken Parmesan dinner plate, spaghetti and meatballs and the garlic knots here. I definitely recommend eating here.

Ava F.

Yummy food and great portion sizes. I had to call directly to re-order my chicken Alfredo with garlic bread, salad and chocolate mousse cake after Uber eats did not deliver my order but instead canceled it . The customer service at this restaurant was very nice and explained to me that it happens to them all the time several times a week, where third-party delivery food services takes the food without delivering to customers. What a shame for people to do that. ‍ I recommend calling directly if you want to have it delivered and to definitely try it out

Sash А

favorite place ever, the employees are so friendly and the food is always so delicious, can never go wrong with marcelinos, they also bake the best cookies, definitely a must try

Cruz B.

Amazing Customer Service. Best Pizza in Valley Village!! Inside of the store is so chill as well as workers being great.

D R.

Ordered a mediterranean salad... they delivered a Cesar. I asked what they could do... they said If I don't touch the Cesar.. They will deliver the meditation in 1.5 hours!!! 13 bucks The Cesar was iceberg lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons and Cesar dressing... they said the mediterranean is the same... but has olives and onions....lol The pasta we ordered was trash also.. no flavor... bad service...

Edythe M.

This place has been around for DECADES and has yet to disappoint my family Their margherita pizza is phenomenal.! We've had everything from pizza to pasta and wings , always fresh hot and top quality ingredients

Reneh K.

I can't understand how this place has a 4 out of 5. This pizza is a 5!! Closest thing to NY style pizza in LA. Amazing. I'm actually about to call them and thank them. No joke.

Sam C.

One of the best Italian places ive been to in the valley, portion size, quality, and price all superb. Baked ziti and garlic bread delicious. Nicest chef and staff, highly recommend. Will be coming back

Dani P.

This place - a review is so complicated because boy is their food good going down. I was telling people this is the best pizza in LA for awhile. And it kind of is but...or should I say BUTT... ...every time me and my friends order here we get the bloated bubble guts and the runs the next day. And we all have different genetics so it's not like we have the same food allergy. This is different unrelated people needing to visit the bathroom 3x the next morning with butts of fire every single time we eat here. So we don't eat here anymore. I'm sad about it, but my butt is happier. But dude their pizza is amazing and those garlic knots are heaven. Just make sure you have pepto bismol and preparation h. This place is like a Tinder date gone wrong.

Load More