Made a day trip to visit SB and eat at Rustys. Hyped Rustys up to my wife and sister in law telling them how good it is. Ordered garlic breadsticks with our pizza. They served us ice cold marinara sauce for dipping. Sauce was so cold and hard that you could not actually dip the bread in it without practically smashing the stick in it. I went in to ask if the sauce is supposed to be ice cold and they if they can warm it up for me. Guy told me its supposed to be ice cold and that he wont warm it up for me since it will melt the plastic container. I dont know if ice cold marinara is a Rustys thing or a Santa Barbara thing but I consider that heresy and Rustys is no longer my #1 pizza place.
Brenden Reis
Cute place good location but food is terrible pretty sure they put cheese wiz on there sand witches and meats are the super processed cheap lunch meatsCheap food in an expressive areasso can’t expect
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Yesenia Mendoza
Great service ! Thank
Service: 5
Vee V.
Just like old times! Was at the sacred space today in Summerland and found Rusty's down the way, WOW so delicious! Small pizza place with outdoor seating. Service was great! The food was really really good. The buffalo wings were spicy and juicy. The pizza was crispy with a thin crust. When we were little we would frequent Rusty's a lot and it brought back sweet childhood memories. Highly recommend if you're in the area and craving a slice of pizza / wings.
Montell Hall
Just brought my pizza home and it was ugly. Sparse toppings thrown right in the middle. $23, so not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
RX L.
A pure and friendly environment. The location I went to in Summerland was very small but was perfect for takeout pickup. Service was great, and food was always hot and delicious. I recommend the pepperoni pizza, and the wings are great as well. Overall a very nice little location of the A+ franchise that is Rusty's Pizza Parlor.
L B.
Rusty's is kinda a staple when I am in the area. We needed a small bite that we could share so we ordered a pizza. The webpage or google said "permanently closed" glad I ignored that! We ordered pick up and it was quick and easy!!!
Tejas Aralere
One of my fave spots in Summerland / SB area. Great food and mom-approved!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
alan daniel
Best submarine sandwiches, pizza is fabulous. Everything is good ?.Excellent service, quick and easy, friendly people throughout this beautiful city of Montiscito, California.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ismael legorreta
Had to go back because they forgot to give me some items I had order
Had the wings, pepperoni pizza, and garlic bread. Everything was delicious! Delivery that was timely and easy.
Evelyn H.
We ordered pizzas for a party my in-laws were hosting and came to pick up. Despite the fact that we've walked by this place many times during our visits to Summerland, this was the first time we ever tried Rusty's food... and it delivered! We used to visit this place back in the day when it was Stacky's Seaside and the transformation from that to Rusty's is night and day. The patio is nice and updated, the inside is roomy and clean as well. The people were nice. The pizza was delicious. No complaints! Give them a visit the next time you are craving pizza in Summerland!
D Davis
My last visit for takeout. Pizza was burnt. Not sure what the issue
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Narsoysauce _
Parking: Was lucky enough to get parking.Wheelchair accessibility: Had a specific door for wheelchair accessing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill H.
1/6/2023.. It is always sad to report on businesses that traditionally are pretty good and consistent. Tonight was not one of those nights at Rusty's in Summerland. We placed an order to pick up of a pizza and two sandwiches. As we waited for our order at the store, after a 20 minute drive, we were handed an order and departed. When we got home, we discovered the order was not ours.We called the main order line for Rusty's and the "supervisor" handled the concern with care and regard. The order would be remade and we could have it delivered or pick it up again, with her apologies. When we returned to the Summerland Rusty's, they tried to hand us the old order, which was over 60 minutes cold. When I requested a fresh bake, the supervisor was rude and took an intolerant attitude. She did make the pizza again but tried to hand me the cold hot sandwiches we ordered from the original order. So again, I waited for the sandwiches to be remade and finally departed. Errors will be made..that is not my concern here.It is the extremely poor customer concern about an error resolution and the supervisors attitude and arrogance that will cost Rusty's my business. There is no excuse for this type of management and lack of basic customer regard. If there was a " no star" option, I would use it!
Made a day trip to visit SB and eat at Rustys. Hyped Rustys up to my wife and sister in law telling them how good it is. Ordered garlic breadsticks with our pizza. They served us ice cold marinara sauce for dipping. Sauce was so cold and hard that you could not actually dip the bread in it without practically smashing the stick in it. I went in to ask if the sauce is supposed to be ice cold and they if they can warm it up for me. Guy told me its supposed to be ice cold and that he wont warm it up for me since it will melt the plastic container. I dont know if ice cold marinara is a Rustys thing or a Santa Barbara thing but I consider that heresy and Rustys is no longer my #1 pizza place.
Cute place good location but food is terrible pretty sure they put cheese wiz on there sand witches and meats are the super processed cheap lunch meatsCheap food in an expressive areasso can’t expect
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Great service ! Thank
Service: 5
Just like old times! Was at the sacred space today in Summerland and found Rusty's down the way, WOW so delicious! Small pizza place with outdoor seating. Service was great! The food was really really good. The buffalo wings were spicy and juicy. The pizza was crispy with a thin crust. When we were little we would frequent Rusty's a lot and it brought back sweet childhood memories. Highly recommend if you're in the area and craving a slice of pizza / wings.
Just brought my pizza home and it was ugly. Sparse toppings thrown right in the middle. $23, so not worth it.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
A pure and friendly environment. The location I went to in Summerland was very small but was perfect for takeout pickup. Service was great, and food was always hot and delicious. I recommend the pepperoni pizza, and the wings are great as well. Overall a very nice little location of the A+ franchise that is Rusty's Pizza Parlor.
Rusty's is kinda a staple when I am in the area. We needed a small bite that we could share so we ordered a pizza. The webpage or google said "permanently closed" glad I ignored that! We ordered pick up and it was quick and easy!!!
One of my fave spots in Summerland / SB area. Great food and mom-approved!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best submarine sandwiches, pizza is fabulous. Everything is good ?.Excellent service, quick and easy, friendly people throughout this beautiful city of Montiscito, California.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had to go back because they forgot to give me some items I had order
Restaurantji Recommends
Had the wings, pepperoni pizza, and garlic bread. Everything was delicious! Delivery that was timely and easy.
We ordered pizzas for a party my in-laws were hosting and came to pick up. Despite the fact that we've walked by this place many times during our visits to Summerland, this was the first time we ever tried Rusty's food... and it delivered! We used to visit this place back in the day when it was Stacky's Seaside and the transformation from that to Rusty's is night and day. The patio is nice and updated, the inside is roomy and clean as well. The people were nice. The pizza was delicious. No complaints! Give them a visit the next time you are craving pizza in Summerland!
My last visit for takeout. Pizza was burnt. Not sure what the issue
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Parking: Was lucky enough to get parking.Wheelchair accessibility: Had a specific door for wheelchair accessing
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
1/6/2023.. It is always sad to report on businesses that traditionally are pretty good and consistent. Tonight was not one of those nights at Rusty's in Summerland. We placed an order to pick up of a pizza and two sandwiches. As we waited for our order at the store, after a 20 minute drive, we were handed an order and departed. When we got home, we discovered the order was not ours.We called the main order line for Rusty's and the "supervisor" handled the concern with care and regard. The order would be remade and we could have it delivered or pick it up again, with her apologies. When we returned to the Summerland Rusty's, they tried to hand us the old order, which was over 60 minutes cold. When I requested a fresh bake, the supervisor was rude and took an intolerant attitude. She did make the pizza again but tried to hand me the cold hot sandwiches we ordered from the original order. So again, I waited for the sandwiches to be remade and finally departed. Errors will be made..that is not my concern here.It is the extremely poor customer concern about an error resolution and the supervisors attitude and arrogance that will cost Rusty's my business. There is no excuse for this type of management and lack of basic customer regard. If there was a " no star" option, I would use it!