Went here for the first time last week to meet up with some friends and we were all so impressed with the pizza selections - each pizza pie was so delicious! Being from NYC, I am always on the hunt for a good pizza slice on the west coast, so I am happy I found this awesome spot! The crust is perfection (my favorite part) - firm and crispy, yet light with a nice oily/garlicky touch! We tried the Margherita, BBQ Chicken, Pineapple, and the White Pizza - all were great. Will def be back! Owners are so nice and it feels cozy, mom & pops style (just like back home :) Give Puzzle Pizza a try, you'll be back for more!Kid-friendliness: Great spot for kids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Puzzle Pie
Armen Nazaryan
Came here with the family and we all loved it. Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious. The employees were kind and professional. We will definitely recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Javier Leal
First time there and it lived up to the hype. It was recommended to me by a family friend. We tried a few pies with my kids and they loved it.I really enjoyed the wings and the fact that they are baked and not fried made me feel less guilty ??Plenty of options to choose from, we got the classic cheese and classic pepperoni on the puzzle pizza and the hawaiian bbq chicken on thin.Almost forgot to mention, it is a small business so even more important to support our community and our small business!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Javier L.
First time there and it lived up to the hype. It was recommended to me by a family friend. We tried a few pies with my kids and they loved it. I really enjoyed the wings and the fact that they are baked and not fried made me feel less guilty Plenty of options to choose from, we got the classic cheese and classic pepperoni on the puzzle pizza and the hawaiian bbq chicken on thin. Almost forgot to mention, it is a small business so even more important to support our community and our small business!!!
Mike N.
Went here today and had the spicy pepperoni and ricotta pizza was amazing. I purchased one slice and ended up getting more because it was so good. They make pizzas by the slice which is very hard to find for square pizzas and they allow you customize your order hints the name puzzle pizza. Prices are amazing. In LA you can't get a slice for less than 10 bucks. I went to quarter sheets recently and this is very comparable fraction of the cost and no wait. I will definitely go back.
Mary S.
Come here for the pizza since there isn't much of an ambiance. Limited sitting area available inside and outside. Now for the important stuff, the pizza. I'd say 1 to 2 slices will suffice for 1 adult so the price tag of $4.50 - $5.95 per slice isn't so bad. Family of three ordered 16 slices not knowing how heavily loaded each square was. We ordered smash avocado, buffalo chicken, spicy honey pep, fennel & mushroom, and Chicago dip. Family favorites were the spicy honey pep and smashed avocados. We also ordered the truffle spicy honey wings. Everything we ordered was delicious. Pizza dough was cooked perfectly, with good ratio between the cheese and the toppings. The sauce on the chicken wing was fire. We will definitely come again but only order 8 slices next time. Oh they also offer lunch specials which I think is pretty fair. I hope y'all try this place. Very yummy.
Desiree C.
After seeing the video with DoKnow and aD from FIGGMUNITY WORLD I knew I had to come... Was not disappointed, love that you can have four different options for each slice, and love how fresh the pizza was, its something different! Really enjoyed eating here can't wait to come back!
Adrian B.
10/10 service, and the food was very good, was so easy to pick what to get and the options all sounded good
Ijascode Hands Off Marketing
You have to try the bbq chicken! OMG! They pour a small portion of actual bbq sauce on it. So, so good! The pieces are really thick so just one piece really fills me up. The customer service is really nice and the actual place is very clean, great lighting, ect.....This pizza is no joke.....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle R.
I ordered through Grubhub and got 2 pepperoni squares and 2 cheese squares with the banana dessert. The pepperoni pizza wasn't that bad but the cheese, yeah no. It was so bland that I only ate the crust. I gave the other 2 slices to my roommate who didn't like the cheese and he said the pepperoni wasn't all that great. This puzzle pizza is a cool idea buy when you order through an app you can't add or create your own pizza, it would have been nice to add sausage to the pepperoni pizza
Ok pizza...first time very good ,sauce fresh,second time not so much a little pricey too! And the wings are really small plus no phone orders for pick up kinda suck ..
Nicole M.
Tried this out while in town and loved the pizza...delish. So thick and chewy and the toppings are so interesting. Pickles on pizza?? Yes please! My kids loved the food too and service was great :)
Chad C.
I love the concept, and it was totally fun. My wife and I went and did the Puzzle Pizza (Spicy Pepperoni, Veggie Deluxe, Hawaiian, and Baratta Margherita) and the Banana Tiramisu Pudding . We cut each piece in half so we each got to try all four (so awesome)! Most of the slices had the crunchy burnt cheese on the edges (so delicious).
Jennie Kozinich
Amazing pizza - love the concept. Easy to try different flavors all in one box! Must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Puzzle Pie
Alexsandra Kaykov
If you like a thicker, crispy crust you'll love this place. The concept is so fun. Perfect to share with someone if you like deferent flavors, or sample multiple flavors all by yourself. Why choose just one when you can try up to four flavors at once? My favorite is the Spicy Honey Pepperoni, hands down! And the Burrata Margherita was a close second.
Went here for the first time last week to meet up with some friends and we were all so impressed with the pizza selections - each pizza pie was so delicious! Being from NYC, I am always on the hunt for a good pizza slice on the west coast, so I am happy I found this awesome spot! The crust is perfection (my favorite part) - firm and crispy, yet light with a nice oily/garlicky touch! We tried the Margherita, BBQ Chicken, Pineapple, and the White Pizza - all were great. Will def be back! Owners are so nice and it feels cozy, mom & pops style (just like back home :) Give Puzzle Pizza a try, you'll be back for more!Kid-friendliness: Great spot for kids!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Puzzle Pie
Came here with the family and we all loved it. Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious. The employees were kind and professional. We will definitely recommend this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time there and it lived up to the hype. It was recommended to me by a family friend. We tried a few pies with my kids and they loved it.I really enjoyed the wings and the fact that they are baked and not fried made me feel less guilty ??Plenty of options to choose from, we got the classic cheese and classic pepperoni on the puzzle pizza and the hawaiian bbq chicken on thin.Almost forgot to mention, it is a small business so even more important to support our community and our small business!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time there and it lived up to the hype. It was recommended to me by a family friend. We tried a few pies with my kids and they loved it. I really enjoyed the wings and the fact that they are baked and not fried made me feel less guilty Plenty of options to choose from, we got the classic cheese and classic pepperoni on the puzzle pizza and the hawaiian bbq chicken on thin. Almost forgot to mention, it is a small business so even more important to support our community and our small business!!!
Went here today and had the spicy pepperoni and ricotta pizza was amazing. I purchased one slice and ended up getting more because it was so good. They make pizzas by the slice which is very hard to find for square pizzas and they allow you customize your order hints the name puzzle pizza. Prices are amazing. In LA you can't get a slice for less than 10 bucks. I went to quarter sheets recently and this is very comparable fraction of the cost and no wait. I will definitely go back.
Come here for the pizza since there isn't much of an ambiance. Limited sitting area available inside and outside. Now for the important stuff, the pizza. I'd say 1 to 2 slices will suffice for 1 adult so the price tag of $4.50 - $5.95 per slice isn't so bad. Family of three ordered 16 slices not knowing how heavily loaded each square was. We ordered smash avocado, buffalo chicken, spicy honey pep, fennel & mushroom, and Chicago dip. Family favorites were the spicy honey pep and smashed avocados. We also ordered the truffle spicy honey wings. Everything we ordered was delicious. Pizza dough was cooked perfectly, with good ratio between the cheese and the toppings. The sauce on the chicken wing was fire. We will definitely come again but only order 8 slices next time. Oh they also offer lunch specials which I think is pretty fair. I hope y'all try this place. Very yummy.
After seeing the video with DoKnow and aD from FIGGMUNITY WORLD I knew I had to come... Was not disappointed, love that you can have four different options for each slice, and love how fresh the pizza was, its something different! Really enjoyed eating here can't wait to come back!
10/10 service, and the food was very good, was so easy to pick what to get and the options all sounded good
You have to try the bbq chicken! OMG! They pour a small portion of actual bbq sauce on it. So, so good! The pieces are really thick so just one piece really fills me up. The customer service is really nice and the actual place is very clean, great lighting, ect.....This pizza is no joke.....
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered through Grubhub and got 2 pepperoni squares and 2 cheese squares with the banana dessert. The pepperoni pizza wasn't that bad but the cheese, yeah no. It was so bland that I only ate the crust. I gave the other 2 slices to my roommate who didn't like the cheese and he said the pepperoni wasn't all that great. This puzzle pizza is a cool idea buy when you order through an app you can't add or create your own pizza, it would have been nice to add sausage to the pepperoni pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Ok pizza...first time very good ,sauce fresh,second time not so much a little pricey too! And the wings are really small plus no phone orders for pick up kinda suck ..
Tried this out while in town and loved the pizza...delish. So thick and chewy and the toppings are so interesting. Pickles on pizza?? Yes please! My kids loved the food too and service was great :)
I love the concept, and it was totally fun. My wife and I went and did the Puzzle Pizza (Spicy Pepperoni, Veggie Deluxe, Hawaiian, and Baratta Margherita) and the Banana Tiramisu Pudding . We cut each piece in half so we each got to try all four (so awesome)! Most of the slices had the crunchy burnt cheese on the edges (so delicious).
Amazing pizza - love the concept. Easy to try different flavors all in one box! Must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Puzzle Pie
If you like a thicker, crispy crust you'll love this place. The concept is so fun. Perfect to share with someone if you like deferent flavors, or sample multiple flavors all by yourself. Why choose just one when you can try up to four flavors at once? My favorite is the Spicy Honey Pepperoni, hands down! And the Burrata Margherita was a close second.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Honey