Tariq the manager owner or whatever. Gave my son that worked as a delivery driver for this place over the summer to make some extra money for college. Tariq wrote my son a bad check for just under $1000.po. He still owes the young man hundreds in hours and tips not included in the hot check. Tariq laughed at me when confronted about the situation.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Chris River
Pizza was just ok the dough was not my style and the cheese was not pleasant, I was not craving
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Seth S.
Has canceled my order four times through online delivery apps. I understand if you come to a point where you can't take new orders, but it's horrible business to cancel already placed orders. I will not be ordering from this business again.
Jeff S.
WARNING - DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!!! Their food got my family food poisoning! Called the restaurant, the owner was being very rude and kept saying they are not responsible and even blocked my phone. This restaurant definitely has severe safety issues like a couple of people here have commented as well. We are reporting them to the Colorado Health Department.
Kadhem A.
I worked there for six months there was rats bugs everywhere and the guy was paying me under the table no one wears gloves, cutting the chicken, cleaning the dishes or making your food there was bugs in toppings for the pizza No one wears clothes they I would not eat here
Dina Katyr
These people walk around flying private property and when asked to leave they refuse and have major attitude. The number on the flyers does not even work and the food is absolute trash.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Amy White
The food has been going down for the last couple of years. I gave it one last shot but cause I'd loved their food now. It is sauceless and slattered and cheese to. I guess fool the parishioner no salt no garlic no pepper no sauce no. Spices the bread has went down to cheap cut in half-Italian loads. You can buy at the grocery store I am so disappointed. I will never spend another sixty five dollars 4 3 meals again.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Zackariah Farah
In all, I decided to give Papa Nicky's 4 stars. Not for the food or service or price but because they gave us a novel and stimulating dining experience. To be clear, our two "pizzas" arrived about 3 hours late, cost over $60 and could not exactly be described as delicious or even edible.We ordered at about 11:30 pm and called about an hour and a half later to check on the pizzas. We were told that the pizza was just then being put in the oven and that the chef had to "step out" which apparently was an explanation for why it took 1.5 hours to even put the pizzas in the oven. They assured us that it would take another 30 minutes max to get the pizza to our hotel room. About an hour later, the pizza still had not arrived and so we called again and were told the pizza was actually on its way this time. Eventually, the cold pizzas and chicken wings did arrive. We were very excited to start eating and the Hawaiian pizza was actually alright. Nothing to write home about but at least it was edible. The Supreme pizza however contained some kind of aged meat that was very hard and tough to chew. When dropped on a table, it made a clanking noise similar to a coin because it was so hard. I was concerned about hurting my teeth. We are still unsure about whether this was chicken or beef or some other animal.The chicken wings seemed fine at first but we soon discovered a hard, long object protruding from one of the chicken wings. We never determined if this was a piece of plastic or a feather left in the chicken and cooked.Hey at least they got the 2 liters of Dr. Pepper right. They did a good job with that :)Would recommend to the adventurous types searching for an interesting night full of laughs with Papa Nicky's. Disclaimer, be prepared to lose the next day(s) due to food poisoning.
I was a little bit hesitant to order from here after reading the reviews. But ubereats had a crazy 60% off deal so I couldn’t pass that up. I was honestly surprised how good the food I was. I order meat lovers calzone and pizza and the best part was it was halal.
Ryan Wilhelm
I ordered a chicken parm sub. 2 bites in and discovered the chicken was raw… Never
Food: 1
Melissa Johnson
This place is sometimes a miss but I love it. For the most part everything's great. Love the pizza, Mexican hamburger, Philly... take the time to try especially if it's a late night booze needed hunger
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Mahmood Aldulaimi
Disgusting, burnt pizza, undercooked burgers. This place should be shut down for health hazards. I have never put a bad review for a food place. But this place here… I do not know how they are in business.
Tya Ewers
Please DO NOT EAT HERE JUST OPENED THE BOX TO EAT my Calzone and this is what I found THIS IS ABSOLUTELY UNACCEPTABLE! I should not be finding bugs in my food I’m so grossed out this place needs to be shut down!
Not open
PERMANENTLY CLOSED
Tariq the manager owner or whatever. Gave my son that worked as a delivery driver for this place over the summer to make some extra money for college. Tariq wrote my son a bad check for just under $1000.po. He still owes the young man hundreds in hours and tips not included in the hot check. Tariq laughed at me when confronted about the situation.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Pizza was just ok the dough was not my style and the cheese was not pleasant, I was not craving
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Has canceled my order four times through online delivery apps. I understand if you come to a point where you can't take new orders, but it's horrible business to cancel already placed orders. I will not be ordering from this business again.
WARNING - DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!!! Their food got my family food poisoning! Called the restaurant, the owner was being very rude and kept saying they are not responsible and even blocked my phone. This restaurant definitely has severe safety issues like a couple of people here have commented as well. We are reporting them to the Colorado Health Department.
I worked there for six months there was rats bugs everywhere and the guy was paying me under the table no one wears gloves, cutting the chicken, cleaning the dishes or making your food there was bugs in toppings for the pizza No one wears clothes they I would not eat here
These people walk around flying private property and when asked to leave they refuse and have major attitude. The number on the flyers does not even work and the food is absolute trash.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The food has been going down for the last couple of years. I gave it one last shot but cause I'd loved their food now. It is sauceless and slattered and cheese to. I guess fool the parishioner no salt no garlic no pepper no sauce no. Spices the bread has went down to cheap cut in half-Italian loads. You can buy at the grocery store I am so disappointed. I will never spend another sixty five dollars 4 3 meals again.
Food: 2
Service: 2
In all, I decided to give Papa Nicky's 4 stars. Not for the food or service or price but because they gave us a novel and stimulating dining experience. To be clear, our two "pizzas" arrived about 3 hours late, cost over $60 and could not exactly be described as delicious or even edible.We ordered at about 11:30 pm and called about an hour and a half later to check on the pizzas. We were told that the pizza was just then being put in the oven and that the chef had to "step out" which apparently was an explanation for why it took 1.5 hours to even put the pizzas in the oven. They assured us that it would take another 30 minutes max to get the pizza to our hotel room. About an hour later, the pizza still had not arrived and so we called again and were told the pizza was actually on its way this time. Eventually, the cold pizzas and chicken wings did arrive. We were very excited to start eating and the Hawaiian pizza was actually alright. Nothing to write home about but at least it was edible. The Supreme pizza however contained some kind of aged meat that was very hard and tough to chew. When dropped on a table, it made a clanking noise similar to a coin because it was so hard. I was concerned about hurting my teeth. We are still unsure about whether this was chicken or beef or some other animal.The chicken wings seemed fine at first but we soon discovered a hard, long object protruding from one of the chicken wings. We never determined if this was a piece of plastic or a feather left in the chicken and cooked.Hey at least they got the 2 liters of Dr. Pepper right. They did a good job with that :)Would recommend to the adventurous types searching for an interesting night full of laughs with Papa Nicky's. Disclaimer, be prepared to lose the next day(s) due to food poisoning.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
I was a little bit hesitant to order from here after reading the reviews. But ubereats had a crazy 60% off deal so I couldn’t pass that up. I was honestly surprised how good the food I was. I order meat lovers calzone and pizza and the best part was it was halal.
I ordered a chicken parm sub. 2 bites in and discovered the chicken was raw… Never
Food: 1
This place is sometimes a miss but I love it. For the most part everything's great. Love the pizza, Mexican hamburger, Philly... take the time to try especially if it's a late night booze needed hunger
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Disgusting, burnt pizza, undercooked burgers. This place should be shut down for health hazards. I have never put a bad review for a food place. But this place here… I do not know how they are in business.
Please DO NOT EAT HERE JUST OPENED THE BOX TO EAT my Calzone and this is what I found THIS IS ABSOLUTELY UNACCEPTABLE! I should not be finding bugs in my food I’m so grossed out this place needs to be shut down!