I always liked Anthonys pizza. It is the closest to NY style authentic pizza. Today however, my pizza was beyond terrible. I ordered it at 5:03...and I was at the restaurant for pickup at 5:15...and my order was already sitting on top of the pizza oven. No way that pizza was constructed, fully cooked, boxed and sliced in less than 12 minutes. It takes 15 minutes just to cook. Obviously it was not made fresh. The crust was limp, soaked wet and the pizza lukewarm at best. For $30...this is awful. I called the location and they offered me a 10% credit. $3 for a disgusting and thoroughly disappointing dinner. We threw away half of that $30 pizza. Keep your $3 and improve your food quality.(follow up) : I am appreciative that the ownership followed up so promptly. The measure of a good business is how they respond. I am hopeful the appropriate quality control will be put in place so I may not give up what has historically been a good experience at this restaurant.
Food: 1
A Hawken
The quality of food here is not even fair and the prices are totally outrageous I wouldn't recommend eating here at all you can buy better Pizza Frozen at Walmart !!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Alex Del Rio
I recently visited Anthony's Pizza with high hopes for a delicious calzone, but was met with disappointment. The calzones were far from the authentic Italian experience I anticipated. To make matters worse, the prices were exorbitantly high, which I could have overlooked if the quality had matched. But the most disheartening part was the marinara sauce—it was nothing more than spaghetti sauce, lacking the rich, herb-infused flavor that true marinara boasts. Sadly, this visit did not deliver the value or the taste that justifies the cost. I cannot recommend their calzones, and I hope Anthony's Pizza takes this feedback to heart and improves their recipes and pricing structure. *DISCLAIMER 2 PEPPERONI CALZONES WERE $40*
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brian Frawley
Food is double the price, 16.00 for a cheese calzone. And the food tastes like cardboard.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Michelle Jaramillo
Pizza too expensive and not cooked throughly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
David Seward
Ordered a large pizza for take out. We hadn't had pizza from Anthony's in a few years but happy to find out it's still awesome.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alexey Chausenko
Good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristy Z
My go to pizza place in Brighton.
Food: 5
Thomas Hudson
Good pasta salads are good but need more veggies. Pizzas are good . Friendly. Limoncello cake is good for dessert
The services in the daytime on the weekend is outstanding. I would recommend it...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Pasta
K M
Ordered a pizza at 6:35, was told 45 min to an hour for delivery, 7:04 got a text that the pizza was done and would be delivered shortly. 7:36 still no pizza. I called and she said it would be there any minute but the driver got stuck at the train. 7:55 I call again and she assures me any minute and it would still be hot when it got here. 8:22 finally got a cold pizza delivered to us. She offered 10% off and that was it. Made excuses about how they have no staff. Not my problem, don’t say 45 minutes to an hour if you know you can’t do that. Now we either eat cold pizza or wait some more to reheat in the oven. Terrible service.$38 pizza. One pizza.
Food: 2
Service: 1
David Moya
Better than most pizza places in town, a bit pricey but I think it's worth it. I'd recommend Anthony's Pizza. 5+Stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Craigtodhill Hill
Food was hot garbage! 75 bucks for pizza and wings you would think the crust would have better flavor than the box it came in. Slices were cut so oddly that not a single piece was the same size as another. Picking the slice up out of the box all the toppings slid off. And the whole pie was severely lacking in flavor. Now on to the "wings" these wings were obviously harvested from an anorexic chicken farm. They tasted as though they were cooked 2 times then dipped in water before covered in sauce. When the kid at the front desk recommends domino's over this place.. trust the kid! Unless you are trying to clear out your colon!
I always liked Anthonys pizza. It is the closest to NY style authentic pizza. Today however, my pizza was beyond terrible. I ordered it at 5:03...and I was at the restaurant for pickup at 5:15...and my order was already sitting on top of the pizza oven. No way that pizza was constructed, fully cooked, boxed and sliced in less than 12 minutes. It takes 15 minutes just to cook. Obviously it was not made fresh. The crust was limp, soaked wet and the pizza lukewarm at best. For $30...this is awful. I called the location and they offered me a 10% credit. $3 for a disgusting and thoroughly disappointing dinner. We threw away half of that $30 pizza. Keep your $3 and improve your food quality.(follow up) : I am appreciative that the ownership followed up so promptly. The measure of a good business is how they respond. I am hopeful the appropriate quality control will be put in place so I may not give up what has historically been a good experience at this restaurant.
Food: 1
The quality of food here is not even fair and the prices are totally outrageous I wouldn't recommend eating here at all you can buy better Pizza Frozen at Walmart !!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I recently visited Anthony's Pizza with high hopes for a delicious calzone, but was met with disappointment. The calzones were far from the authentic Italian experience I anticipated. To make matters worse, the prices were exorbitantly high, which I could have overlooked if the quality had matched. But the most disheartening part was the marinara sauce—it was nothing more than spaghetti sauce, lacking the rich, herb-infused flavor that true marinara boasts. Sadly, this visit did not deliver the value or the taste that justifies the cost. I cannot recommend their calzones, and I hope Anthony's Pizza takes this feedback to heart and improves their recipes and pricing structure. *DISCLAIMER 2 PEPPERONI CALZONES WERE $40*
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Food is double the price, 16.00 for a cheese calzone. And the food tastes like cardboard.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Pizza too expensive and not cooked throughly.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Ordered a large pizza for take out. We hadn't had pizza from Anthony's in a few years but happy to find out it's still awesome.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My go to pizza place in Brighton.
Food: 5
Good pasta salads are good but need more veggies. Pizzas are good . Friendly. Limoncello cake is good for dessert
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Fettuccine Alfredo, Pesto Pasta, Baked Ziti, Chicken Alfredo, Feed the Family, Salads
Probably the best Calzone that you can find in Brighton.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Jessica was very friendly. I appreciate that.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The services in the daytime on the weekend is outstanding. I would recommend it...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Pasta
Ordered a pizza at 6:35, was told 45 min to an hour for delivery, 7:04 got a text that the pizza was done and would be delivered shortly. 7:36 still no pizza. I called and she said it would be there any minute but the driver got stuck at the train. 7:55 I call again and she assures me any minute and it would still be hot when it got here. 8:22 finally got a cold pizza delivered to us. She offered 10% off and that was it. Made excuses about how they have no staff. Not my problem, don’t say 45 minutes to an hour if you know you can’t do that. Now we either eat cold pizza or wait some more to reheat in the oven. Terrible service.$38 pizza. One pizza.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Better than most pizza places in town, a bit pricey but I think it's worth it. I'd recommend Anthony's Pizza. 5+Stars.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was hot garbage! 75 bucks for pizza and wings you would think the crust would have better flavor than the box it came in. Slices were cut so oddly that not a single piece was the same size as another. Picking the slice up out of the box all the toppings slid off. And the whole pie was severely lacking in flavor. Now on to the "wings" these wings were obviously harvested from an anorexic chicken farm. They tasted as though they were cooked 2 times then dipped in water before covered in sauce. When the kid at the front desk recommends domino's over this place.. trust the kid! Unless you are trying to clear out your colon!
Food: 1