Sugar Sisters Bakery

34 E Allen St Suite 300, Castle Rock
(303) 688-2253

Recent Reviews

Rose G.

So sad to hear they are closing 10/10!! Support local and come here before they are no more. Absolutely the best cookies and cupcakes this side of the mountains! Devine cookies, cupcakes and cakes with a twist to the traditional recipes; it's like the old school chocolate cookies my grandma use to make, but I'd sneak it during my sandwich and chips lunch. The taste of sweet cookies and salty potatoes chips is one that only the SSB could recreate from childhood. So glad I was able to find them before they close shop.

Lisa Wright

Overrated, everything we’ve bought wasn’t good and one item in particular was so disgusting we threw the rest of it out which was a pie that they heavily promoted. Not worth the price and could probably get better delicious desserts from our local grocery store. Customer service is awful.

Mike S

Holy sweet tooth! We are not crazy for these, like the other reviewers. I would request a larger cake base, to go with all the sugar toppings. Unfortunately, for us, the overall taste gets lost by the amount of sugar. They do look good though.

Kristina L.

What a dangerously good place! We stopped here to get some cupcakes to celebrate a birthday and we were not disappointed.

Kaitlyn Vance

After discovering them on Tik Tok, I just had to try them! Very friendly staff and a unique bakery all around!

Ashley N.

These cookies are out of this world!! The most delicious cookies I've ever tasted. We had the s'mores and caramel stuffed snickerdoodle one!

Cindy M

My granddaughter has dairy allergies are very bad. We have always gotten cupcakes from them before they changed their name. Apparently they changed the recipe also - they now make everything with soybean oil. If you have any soy allergies you may not want to eat at this bakery. I was very saddened by this because most people that have acute allergies to food will be allergic to soy as well. If you’re not allergic to soy they are delicious -my granddaughter was sick for two hours last night because I did not realize the recipe had changed. Also for those of you that have peanut allergies like me you will also developed or have soy allergies as well. Peanuts and soy beans are from the same family

Milehigh Horses

These are sooo yummy. Delicious and moist and large!

Christopher K.

I thought that I would be more impressed with the baked goods based upon the price I paid. The ice cream was good but the cupcakes and cookies were ordinary. In any case, waaaay too much to spend on ordinary baked goods.

Samantha J.

Stopped by today for cookies and they were AMAZING! Soft, full of flavor and too big to eat the whole cookie.

Beth A.

Cute shop with wonderful, sugary treats. Even a few for dogs!

Rohin S.

Had some of these cupcakes picked up for a celebration and split them all: overall my favorite was the cookies and cream one, followed by the chocolate cupcake. All of the flavors of the cupcakes were on point, not extremely moist and the frosting was flavorful but a bit too sweet for my groups liking.

Jeannette H

This place is amazing! They have cookies, brownies, and cupcakes in so many yummy flavors, it's hard to decide! These ladies are so creative, especially around the holidays! We can't help but stop in every time we're in town!

Chris Albert

Awesome place. Unique decor and signs/flags up to let everyone know they are inclusive. Everyone is welcome! Their treats are great and they also sell Little Man Ice Cream

Susan B.

Hands down the BEST local bakery in Colorado! These ladies give back to the community and they are so very nice. EVERYTHING is amazing.

Load More