Very large slices. We both ate 2 each. Not cheap but very good. Great outdoor seating area. Great service. Recommend eating here.
scjjmm
Walked into Denver Biscuit Company/ Atomic Cowboys/ Fat Sully’s. By evening the restaurant is Fat Sully’s. I ordered a “Big A** Slice” and the name is fitting. It’s a build your toppings slice and it was very good. Slice was bigger than my hand with a crispy crust and toppings to order. Price was reasonable, service was great. They have a full bar and several beers on tap. I would come back for another “Big A** Slice” and a cold beer.
Chapman1111
The NY style pizza was incredibly good and the cocktails were spot-on on this hot day. We loved the outdoor eatery and highly recommend it!
tammyhN4661HT
Pizza was very good. We ordered a big a** pizza with pepperoni and white sauce and extra cheese. We ordered garlic knots. They were bad. They were burned up. Our waitress was not that great she would fly by everything okay and kept running by. But awesome pizza.
Derrick G.
I decided to try Fat Sally's pizza after many people told me how good it was. Overall, it was a decent experience. The customer service was very good but the New York style pizza was average. It's a very large slice/portion of pizza, you can add your own toppings. I thought the pizza was a little stale and didn't have a lot of flavor, but overall it tasted pretty good.
derrickwg36
I decided to try Fat Sally’s pizza after many people told me how good it was. Overall, it was a decent experience. The customer service was very good but the New York style pizza was average. It’s a very large slice/portion of pizza, you can add your own toppings. I thought the pizza was a little stale and didn’t have a lot of flavor, but overall it tasted pretty good.
John R.
Hella good pizza, a little greasy but to be expected when the pizza is that big. Definitely going again in the future
Hallea M.
Ok this place is SOO GOOD!! If you're debating, GO! The pizza slices are huge and the wings.... The wings are AMAZING! I'm from the south where we like our wings crispy and wet. Trust me this place surprised us and is now our spot! Also special shout out to our server Ashley. Ashley was super helpful and even excited for us to try every for the first time. 10/10 recommend this place!!
Ben F.
Ordered a pizza online and showed up and checked in with about 10 minutes left. As I was sitting there waiting, I watched a man walk away with a box with my name on it. The man at the counter confirmed he gave my order to someone else so I then had to wait for another pie. Less than ideal takeout situation. Tastes good though.
George R.
Ordered their huge pizza and it greatly disappointed me. It was very thin! I asked for three toppings including tomatoes and onions. It had hardly any tomatoes or onions. They filled the pizza with the cheaper third ingredient. It also lacked cheese. Fat Sully cheated me!
This is some of the best pizza I've ever had. Definitely go with the big a** pizza (26 inch!). Our server Charlie was super friendly and chill. Will return next time we're in CO!
Omniscient “Chewy” Eye
Ginormous pizza!! Definitely qualifies as New York style pizza, but waaaaaaaay too overpriced, $3.25 a topping! The sandwiches look dinky, and I had the pot pie; which was okay, not worth $15. The wings were small, and coated with breading, must be pre packaged. The servers are great, and the atmosphere is pretty cool. Just a fair warning if you've never been here before.
Martin Keuchkerian (My_FoodieVerse)
Fantastic pizza spot! I rarely eat pizza myself, but this place was definitely worth it.The garlic Parmesan knots were an amazing appetizer. They were soft, fluffy and airy. They weren’t overly oily, which is a common complaint of mine for appetizers like this. The accompanying dipping sauce were also fantastic and kept the taste profile varied.The pizza itself was also great. I have a big appetite, and even for me 1 slice was more than enough. You can customize the toppings for all the slices which allow you to make the slice to your exact liking. The crust is thin, perfectly baked, and again, not overly oily.Overall, a great pizza spot to share a slice with a friend! I want to come back to try their biscuit dishes tho.For more reviews follow my insta @my_foodieverse
Crinklybottom
we took a friend here that is from NY so picky about pizza. He ordered three slices in all and just wanted more! He said its the first time outside of NY that the pizza had the correct crust for folding the way you are supposed to!
Tim Pearse Chalcraft
The staff were all ridiculously amazing and so was the pizza!
Very large slices. We both ate 2 each. Not cheap but very good. Great outdoor seating area. Great service. Recommend eating here.
Walked into Denver Biscuit Company/ Atomic Cowboys/ Fat Sully’s. By evening the restaurant is Fat Sully’s. I ordered a “Big A** Slice” and the name is fitting. It’s a build your toppings slice and it was very good. Slice was bigger than my hand with a crispy crust and toppings to order. Price was reasonable, service was great. They have a full bar and several beers on tap. I would come back for another “Big A** Slice” and a cold beer.
The NY style pizza was incredibly good and the cocktails were spot-on on this hot day. We loved the outdoor eatery and highly recommend it!
Pizza was very good. We ordered a big a** pizza with pepperoni and white sauce and extra cheese. We ordered garlic knots. They were bad. They were burned up. Our waitress was not that great she would fly by everything okay and kept running by. But awesome pizza.
I decided to try Fat Sally's pizza after many people told me how good it was. Overall, it was a decent experience. The customer service was very good but the New York style pizza was average. It's a very large slice/portion of pizza, you can add your own toppings. I thought the pizza was a little stale and didn't have a lot of flavor, but overall it tasted pretty good.
I decided to try Fat Sally’s pizza after many people told me how good it was. Overall, it was a decent experience. The customer service was very good but the New York style pizza was average. It’s a very large slice/portion of pizza, you can add your own toppings. I thought the pizza was a little stale and didn’t have a lot of flavor, but overall it tasted pretty good.
Hella good pizza, a little greasy but to be expected when the pizza is that big. Definitely going again in the future
Ok this place is SOO GOOD!! If you're debating, GO! The pizza slices are huge and the wings.... The wings are AMAZING! I'm from the south where we like our wings crispy and wet. Trust me this place surprised us and is now our spot! Also special shout out to our server Ashley. Ashley was super helpful and even excited for us to try every for the first time. 10/10 recommend this place!!
Ordered a pizza online and showed up and checked in with about 10 minutes left. As I was sitting there waiting, I watched a man walk away with a box with my name on it. The man at the counter confirmed he gave my order to someone else so I then had to wait for another pie. Less than ideal takeout situation. Tastes good though.
Ordered their huge pizza and it greatly disappointed me. It was very thin! I asked for three toppings including tomatoes and onions. It had hardly any tomatoes or onions. They filled the pizza with the cheaper third ingredient. It also lacked cheese. Fat Sully cheated me!
Restaurantji Recommends
This is some of the best pizza I've ever had. Definitely go with the big a** pizza (26 inch!). Our server Charlie was super friendly and chill. Will return next time we're in CO!
Ginormous pizza!! Definitely qualifies as New York style pizza, but waaaaaaaay too overpriced, $3.25 a topping! The sandwiches look dinky, and I had the pot pie; which was okay, not worth $15. The wings were small, and coated with breading, must be pre packaged. The servers are great, and the atmosphere is pretty cool. Just a fair warning if you've never been here before.
Fantastic pizza spot! I rarely eat pizza myself, but this place was definitely worth it.The garlic Parmesan knots were an amazing appetizer. They were soft, fluffy and airy. They weren’t overly oily, which is a common complaint of mine for appetizers like this. The accompanying dipping sauce were also fantastic and kept the taste profile varied.The pizza itself was also great. I have a big appetite, and even for me 1 slice was more than enough. You can customize the toppings for all the slices which allow you to make the slice to your exact liking. The crust is thin, perfectly baked, and again, not overly oily.Overall, a great pizza spot to share a slice with a friend! I want to come back to try their biscuit dishes tho.For more reviews follow my insta @my_foodieverse
we took a friend here that is from NY so picky about pizza. He ordered three slices in all and just wanted more! He said its the first time outside of NY that the pizza had the correct crust for folding the way you are supposed to!
The staff were all ridiculously amazing and so was the pizza!