Awful delivery changed my time from 8:24 to 9:27 to 9:42 . Showed up at 10:14. I ordered at 7:52.
Service: 1
Cheeseman Ghoul
I don’t know who is in control of the music here, but it’s like- the hottest club in town! vibes were magnificent.Service was awesome. I’ve lived so close to this place for so long, and never realized where it was because it’s easy to miss.It’s definitely pretty cramped in there. I wouldn’t sit down and have a meal. But perfect for after the bars . it’s not the best pizza /wings i’ve ever had but it’s not the worst, either. i went for a slice and 6 wings. i didn’t really care for the buffalo sauce, though.Parking: it’s cap hill, and parking is tough depending on the time of day.Wheelchair accessibility: There’s no step to get in, but it’s pretty tiny in there and probably, would be hard to maneuver around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Andrew Shaffer
Literally ripped me off I ordered a pizza on their website on Sunday February 11th at 6:15. It was around $30.00 with 20% tip for delivery. By 8:15pm the pizza never showed up. I called and they stated that it would be another 50 mins and they haven’t even made it yet. I canceled the order expecting a refund. It’s now February 13 and I have called the establishment 3 times and they said they can’t refund me until the manager comes to the store. They basically took my money and are refusing to refund me
Chandler Biloff
Hands down best pizza on this planet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kyle
Garbage pizza. Nothing like NYC style. Way too salty. Very bland. Soggy dough and crust.
Food: 1
Justin Rennolds
This place has been garbage lately. The staff is rude and often times are stoned out of their minds, the slices are poorly prepared and, the overall taste borders on "sour". The red sauce they use is metallic.Benny's used to be an incredible spot that operated with high standards. Ever since the young skater dude (possible owner?) passed away, this place has steadily declined in quality. Sad. I have been frequenting Benny's for almost 20 years now...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Salt Forever
I've been here several times since moving into the hood.Never disappoints!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chad Butler
Great Bronx style pizzas. The people are great too. Shout out to Mike and the team.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Whole Pizzas
Michael B.
The food is ok at best. The 90 minute-2 hour wait EVERY time definitely not worth it. Basic dough and sauce, but they charge you a ton for light toppings. 6 pepperoni for a big up charge. Not worth the wait or price.
Jake B.
"New York style" pizza it ain't. Honestly, Dominos and Blackjack are better. Crust was partially baked, still raw dough on top. Sauce was decent, but there was almost none on this pizza past an inch from the edges. Not sure what kinda "cheese" this is, but very unlike the mozarella at other places. Zero stretch, no flavor, just waxy globs. Very stingy with the low quality toppings. Ordered "meatballs" and got some unidentifiable tasteless greasy meatlike crumbles that looked like sausage but tasted like cardboard. Their "pizza" is a war crime. I had better pizza in a public school cafeteria. Amazed this place has been in business so long.
Best slice of NY style pizza in Denver. Pepperoni slice folds in half just like in NY. Highly recommend. Eccentric location and decor that adds to the experience.
Spencer Barringer
I bought a cheese pizza, as that is always the first thing I order to see if the pizza is any good. The crust is super thin and very salty. Not much sauce, and the cheese isn't amazing. There isn't any crust. I think they took a recipe from NY and tried to make it in CO with the dry climate and altitude. It doesn't translate well. I had a lot of pizza in Brooklyn and Manhattan when I lived there, never in the Bronx. But I can't imagine this is a good slice in the Bronx either. Maybe I ordered on a bad night but It really shouldn't be like this ever at a respectable pizza parlour.
Food: 2
Service: 4
Karl Parker
I absolutely love this place!!! Great lunch special, and the za is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Weber
Always good!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Justin L.
Amazing by the slice, thin, decent crisp and great for the price. My favorite pizza in denver easily hands down
Awful delivery changed my time from 8:24 to 9:27 to 9:42 . Showed up at 10:14. I ordered at 7:52.
Service: 1
I don’t know who is in control of the music here, but it’s like- the hottest club in town! vibes were magnificent.Service was awesome. I’ve lived so close to this place for so long, and never realized where it was because it’s easy to miss.It’s definitely pretty cramped in there. I wouldn’t sit down and have a meal. But perfect for after the bars . it’s not the best pizza /wings i’ve ever had but it’s not the worst, either. i went for a slice and 6 wings. i didn’t really care for the buffalo sauce, though.Parking: it’s cap hill, and parking is tough depending on the time of day.Wheelchair accessibility: There’s no step to get in, but it’s pretty tiny in there and probably, would be hard to maneuver around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Literally ripped me off I ordered a pizza on their website on Sunday February 11th at 6:15. It was around $30.00 with 20% tip for delivery. By 8:15pm the pizza never showed up. I called and they stated that it would be another 50 mins and they haven’t even made it yet. I canceled the order expecting a refund. It’s now February 13 and I have called the establishment 3 times and they said they can’t refund me until the manager comes to the store. They basically took my money and are refusing to refund me
Hands down best pizza on this planet.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Garbage pizza. Nothing like NYC style. Way too salty. Very bland. Soggy dough and crust.
Food: 1
This place has been garbage lately. The staff is rude and often times are stoned out of their minds, the slices are poorly prepared and, the overall taste borders on "sour". The red sauce they use is metallic.Benny's used to be an incredible spot that operated with high standards. Ever since the young skater dude (possible owner?) passed away, this place has steadily declined in quality. Sad. I have been frequenting Benny's for almost 20 years now...
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
I've been here several times since moving into the hood.Never disappoints!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Bronx style pizzas. The people are great too. Shout out to Mike and the team.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza by the Slice, Whole Pizzas
The food is ok at best. The 90 minute-2 hour wait EVERY time definitely not worth it. Basic dough and sauce, but they charge you a ton for light toppings. 6 pepperoni for a big up charge. Not worth the wait or price.
"New York style" pizza it ain't. Honestly, Dominos and Blackjack are better. Crust was partially baked, still raw dough on top. Sauce was decent, but there was almost none on this pizza past an inch from the edges. Not sure what kinda "cheese" this is, but very unlike the mozarella at other places. Zero stretch, no flavor, just waxy globs. Very stingy with the low quality toppings. Ordered "meatballs" and got some unidentifiable tasteless greasy meatlike crumbles that looked like sausage but tasted like cardboard. Their "pizza" is a war crime. I had better pizza in a public school cafeteria. Amazed this place has been in business so long.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best slice of NY style pizza in Denver. Pepperoni slice folds in half just like in NY. Highly recommend. Eccentric location and decor that adds to the experience.
I bought a cheese pizza, as that is always the first thing I order to see if the pizza is any good. The crust is super thin and very salty. Not much sauce, and the cheese isn't amazing. There isn't any crust. I think they took a recipe from NY and tried to make it in CO with the dry climate and altitude. It doesn't translate well. I had a lot of pizza in Brooklyn and Manhattan when I lived there, never in the Bronx. But I can't imagine this is a good slice in the Bronx either. Maybe I ordered on a bad night but It really shouldn't be like this ever at a respectable pizza parlour.
Food: 2
Service: 4
I absolutely love this place!!! Great lunch special, and the za is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always good!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Amazing by the slice, thin, decent crisp and great for the price. My favorite pizza in denver easily hands down