Wholly smokes! They've got some ginormous pizzas!! Ordered delivery and although pricey for pizza, they did not disappoint. Huge slices with a good amount of toppings. Quite delicious and would definitely order again.
Neil P.
Having lived in the neighborhood for a few months I had other places to visit considering I cook a lot, I visited for the third time (breakfast twice) and happy hour and found the service slow in the evening but reasonable considering wages only. Had three drinks and a burger with fries. Atmosphere was relaxed but not congenital having spent time in the South. The burger is UNDERPRICED. Good drinks, recommended strawberry variety drinks as they serve a superb Strawberry Shortcake at breakfast.
Sam F.
I know they are known for their pizza but babbyyyyy when I say that cheese burger is fire!!!!! It's huge and cheesy and so damn good. I had my homie jealous while I ate.
Brigitte M.
First of all this is the most amazing location to go to. Blake is the main bartender and he is really amazing and cares about making drinks that are exciting. Mathew is the bouncer and bar back, we love him so much. He does everything he can to make our experience amazing while also always asking if we are being safe. Our first time at atomic cowboy was a blowout due to Blake and Mathew
Sammy L.
One of my favorite pizza places. I order their Margherita , that's my favorite. It's always jucy & tasty. They can double cheese it, that's what I order.
Brent L.
I had been traveling for a while after picking up a friend from the airport and we decided to go to Fat Sully's. This was Friday night during our semi-weird late May wintry-mix - so pizza sounded tremendous. Our server, Justine, was friendly and attentive. We ordered right away, received our food in a timely manner, and were well taken care of. The pizza was great - It hit the spot - Justine was awesome.
Justin Neustadter
The garlic knots are delicious but the pizza is just okay. It's build your own pizza so you can get whatever you want. The pizza is absolutely enormous and expensive.The beer selection at Atomic Cowboy inside is great!
553mitche
The street-side walk-up window is a delight--always my stop after a show at the Bluebird. Very speedy service, and the pizza never disappoints.
Peter B.
3.5 stars is a crying shame for this place. I love pizza. I would eat if for every meal, and rest assured I've had my fair share of pizza, and not just Pizza Hut either. To be fair, I have not been to New York. But, that being said, this pizza was amazing. The bar staff is super chill and they have a solid selection of drinks. Atmosphere is nice and relaxed, at least on a Thursday afternoon. But the pizza, get the pizza!
Kayla V.
The pizza doesn't have the best flavor and something about the sauce has a very generic and underwhelming flavor, like a frozen DiGiorno pizza. On the other hand though, the chicken wings were awesome. Overall, the staff is friendly and chicken wings definitely deserve the chef's kiss.
This was the choice to eat at before our timed zoo entry for zoo lights. I had seen this place on the 5280 top Denver pizza places bracket from 2020. As a family we love NY style pizza as we can get a lot and in this case go half and half. The 26" is dine in only so if you want the big one keep that in mind. Overall I was satisfied with the pizza. I was not satisfied with the time it took for the pizza. We had set out 1.5 hours to eat this pizza before our timed entry and we arrived at the gates 10 minutes late even thought it was only 7 min drive. It wasn't overly busy in the restaurant and the 26" took almost 50 minutes to be done. If I were to return I would only order Togo and skip the stop in. Pros- Service was very friendly Restaurant was well maintained and clean Pizza was pretty good Cons- Parking is extremely scarce so be prepared for a trek Only get slices if in a hurry Pizza was greasy so if you have a sensitivity stay clear
Francesca M.
We ordered takeout and the pizza was delicious and warm. The slices are pretty big and filling.
Joseph Talavera
Pizza and Caesar salad is good. If you’re looking for some good pizza give them a shot. The only reason I give 3 stars is because I felt we were ignored because me and my girlfriend are not white. The guy who sat us served the family and other couple behind us before us. I tried just brushing it off but he actually never came to serve us. I had to ask an employee bussing the used tables if we are supposed to order at the bar for service even though it was apparent the other parties were receiving service that were sitting right next to us but I try to never assume it’s a racial thing. The bartender ended up coming to take our drink and food order after 20 minutes of waiting instead of the server who was serving the people who came in behind us. It was a weird experience but I appreciated the bartender taking care of us. The servers name on the tab was Philly and I just felt like I couldn’t leave a tip since I didn’t want it to go to the guy who ignored us the entire time but the girl at the bar who helped us was great.
Erika Colorado
Just like Jersey Shore pizza ? long, hold with 2 hands and yummy. Closest thing to NJ/NY pizza we can find in Denver. We ordered the half Pep/Cheese. 2 slices had very little cheese, ordered thru doordash. Next visit, we will definitely get the same but extra cheese to experiment with topping quantity. Yeah Sully!!!
Richie Cook
Been in Colorado now for 2 years and haven’t found a single pizza joint that was even close to good—until now! This is the closest you’ll get to NY/NJ pizza anywhere and in fact, better than some of the pizza back home. It’s definitely pricey but f me, they have no competition. 10/10!
Wholly smokes! They've got some ginormous pizzas!! Ordered delivery and although pricey for pizza, they did not disappoint. Huge slices with a good amount of toppings. Quite delicious and would definitely order again.
Having lived in the neighborhood for a few months I had other places to visit considering I cook a lot, I visited for the third time (breakfast twice) and happy hour and found the service slow in the evening but reasonable considering wages only. Had three drinks and a burger with fries. Atmosphere was relaxed but not congenital having spent time in the South. The burger is UNDERPRICED. Good drinks, recommended strawberry variety drinks as they serve a superb Strawberry Shortcake at breakfast.
I know they are known for their pizza but babbyyyyy when I say that cheese burger is fire!!!!! It's huge and cheesy and so damn good. I had my homie jealous while I ate.
First of all this is the most amazing location to go to. Blake is the main bartender and he is really amazing and cares about making drinks that are exciting. Mathew is the bouncer and bar back, we love him so much. He does everything he can to make our experience amazing while also always asking if we are being safe. Our first time at atomic cowboy was a blowout due to Blake and Mathew
One of my favorite pizza places. I order their Margherita , that's my favorite. It's always jucy & tasty. They can double cheese it, that's what I order.
I had been traveling for a while after picking up a friend from the airport and we decided to go to Fat Sully's. This was Friday night during our semi-weird late May wintry-mix - so pizza sounded tremendous. Our server, Justine, was friendly and attentive. We ordered right away, received our food in a timely manner, and were well taken care of. The pizza was great - It hit the spot - Justine was awesome.
The garlic knots are delicious but the pizza is just okay. It's build your own pizza so you can get whatever you want. The pizza is absolutely enormous and expensive.The beer selection at Atomic Cowboy inside is great!
The street-side walk-up window is a delight--always my stop after a show at the Bluebird. Very speedy service, and the pizza never disappoints.
3.5 stars is a crying shame for this place. I love pizza. I would eat if for every meal, and rest assured I've had my fair share of pizza, and not just Pizza Hut either. To be fair, I have not been to New York. But, that being said, this pizza was amazing. The bar staff is super chill and they have a solid selection of drinks. Atmosphere is nice and relaxed, at least on a Thursday afternoon. But the pizza, get the pizza!
The pizza doesn't have the best flavor and something about the sauce has a very generic and underwhelming flavor, like a frozen DiGiorno pizza. On the other hand though, the chicken wings were awesome. Overall, the staff is friendly and chicken wings definitely deserve the chef's kiss.
Restaurantji Recommends
This was the choice to eat at before our timed zoo entry for zoo lights. I had seen this place on the 5280 top Denver pizza places bracket from 2020. As a family we love NY style pizza as we can get a lot and in this case go half and half. The 26" is dine in only so if you want the big one keep that in mind. Overall I was satisfied with the pizza. I was not satisfied with the time it took for the pizza. We had set out 1.5 hours to eat this pizza before our timed entry and we arrived at the gates 10 minutes late even thought it was only 7 min drive. It wasn't overly busy in the restaurant and the 26" took almost 50 minutes to be done. If I were to return I would only order Togo and skip the stop in. Pros- Service was very friendly Restaurant was well maintained and clean Pizza was pretty good Cons- Parking is extremely scarce so be prepared for a trek Only get slices if in a hurry Pizza was greasy so if you have a sensitivity stay clear
We ordered takeout and the pizza was delicious and warm. The slices are pretty big and filling.
Pizza and Caesar salad is good. If you’re looking for some good pizza give them a shot. The only reason I give 3 stars is because I felt we were ignored because me and my girlfriend are not white. The guy who sat us served the family and other couple behind us before us. I tried just brushing it off but he actually never came to serve us. I had to ask an employee bussing the used tables if we are supposed to order at the bar for service even though it was apparent the other parties were receiving service that were sitting right next to us but I try to never assume it’s a racial thing. The bartender ended up coming to take our drink and food order after 20 minutes of waiting instead of the server who was serving the people who came in behind us. It was a weird experience but I appreciated the bartender taking care of us. The servers name on the tab was Philly and I just felt like I couldn’t leave a tip since I didn’t want it to go to the guy who ignored us the entire time but the girl at the bar who helped us was great.
Just like Jersey Shore pizza ? long, hold with 2 hands and yummy. Closest thing to NJ/NY pizza we can find in Denver. We ordered the half Pep/Cheese. 2 slices had very little cheese, ordered thru doordash. Next visit, we will definitely get the same but extra cheese to experiment with topping quantity. Yeah Sully!!!
Been in Colorado now for 2 years and haven’t found a single pizza joint that was even close to good—until now! This is the closest you’ll get to NY/NJ pizza anywhere and in fact, better than some of the pizza back home. It’s definitely pricey but f me, they have no competition. 10/10!