Amazing New York style pizza ... but do yourself a favor and mix it up and order the cheeseburger. Best in town!! It gets a little crowded at busy times but just come at off hours and don't hate them for being popular. Nerds do that.
Blaze Spiker
Really like the pizza and all the toppings you can choose, i just wish i could get chicken on it. Ordered a bloody mary and garlic bread, both very yummy.
Miya J.
Online ordering was easy. Parking on Friday evening was difficult but was able to find a spot. The pizza was ready upon pickup. Order a variety of different pizzas and everyone agrees it taste just like a slice you'd grab if you were in NYC.
LaNesha Mitchell
The pizza was horrible. I asked for light sauce and too much sauce. I mean who still puts cornmeal on the bottom of the pizza? Eww...
Lexi Garapola
My life changed for the better when I ate the garlic knots. I highly recommend you have them. The pizza was also great!!
chelsea gadiano
Best pizza ever! Probably good for 4-5 people depending on how much you eat! Perfect pizza!
Leana Rivero
Bummed cause it was too early to ger a slice... Like SERIOUSLY?!? You GOTTTA start serving them pizzapiepieces earlier than 11...just sayin Beam & Cokes & the service were enough for me to give a review
Josh Rosema
We stopped by here for our first time to get some slices after hearing how good it is and I’m not sure what all the fuss is about. The slices were huge and smelled good, but after a few bites I was disappointed. Nothing stood out, flavor-wise. It was just bland tasting pizza, even with pepperoni and sausage. The crust was the real bummer. It was so bland we didn’t finish it. Our go-to NYC pizza place has a nice sour note in the crust that makes it so good. I guess we should have gone there. I wouldn’t recommend this spot if you’re looking for great pizza.
Droop Reyes
I have been searching for the perfect single slice pizza place I seen reviews that this was it but I have to say it's good fresh but the crust is a little to thin it rips to easy.
Daniel Alcala
This place is delicious! We had a huge 26-inch pizza, I believe. I had one slice if I was really hungry or drunk, maybe 2 slices lol. The garlic knots were tasty, and the sauces complimented everything perfectly. The service was friendly and on point(thank you, Logan). Great pizza that won't break the bank. I'm definitely coming back again and soon.
We ordered the loaded breadsticks, double smash burger, and Sully's fries. Everything was delicious! Our waiter was knowledgeable and friendly. We will be back!
Brandy Davis
One size option - too big. One flavor option - way too much for a solid pizza (for reference, I like NY pizza… save your money and have it from Sexy Pizza or Cosmos or Anthony’s). One price point - too much. Dark walkway to pick up on the street on colfax. Just not a good pie… I didn’t think bad pizza existed until now.
Lance B.
Biggest, best pizza i've ever had. For such a good price. Just the right amount of crunch and droop ratio you want. Also best garlic knots i've ever had. I drive from Aurora to come here...
Charles S.
Big slices of pizza pie. Super delicious. But do want to warn you these slices are NY style and are huge not these little mom and pop slices.
Celeste R.
Went to eat at 10:30 PM yesterday with my fiancé & son & was automatically greeted with a bad attitude server. Ordered the loaded knots & was told they are only serving slices & salad as their menu changes at 10 PM. We were bummed but continued to order 5 slices. 3 slices were so burnt, my 5 year old gagged & spit out his pizza. Asked the server for some napkins which she forgot about, so after 10 minutes of waiting for a napkin, finally got some. We see our server, Logan, bring out a full pie to the table behind us, & wondered why couldn't we order a full pie. At this point, I got up to speak with the manager, Hannah, who was amazing & apologized greatly & continued to let me know that the full menu stops at 11. Hannah took care of our entire check which was not what we were expecting, so we were very thankful. Our server Logan stopped at the table as we were getting our jackets on, & basically told us to leave because we didn't have to pay anything. Such a rude disrespectful server. If you get Logan as your server, ask for someone else.
Amazing New York style pizza ... but do yourself a favor and mix it up and order the cheeseburger. Best in town!! It gets a little crowded at busy times but just come at off hours and don't hate them for being popular. Nerds do that.
Really like the pizza and all the toppings you can choose, i just wish i could get chicken on it. Ordered a bloody mary and garlic bread, both very yummy.
Online ordering was easy. Parking on Friday evening was difficult but was able to find a spot. The pizza was ready upon pickup. Order a variety of different pizzas and everyone agrees it taste just like a slice you'd grab if you were in NYC.
The pizza was horrible. I asked for light sauce and too much sauce. I mean who still puts cornmeal on the bottom of the pizza? Eww...
My life changed for the better when I ate the garlic knots. I highly recommend you have them. The pizza was also great!!
Best pizza ever! Probably good for 4-5 people depending on how much you eat! Perfect pizza!
Bummed cause it was too early to ger a slice... Like SERIOUSLY?!? You GOTTTA start serving them pizzapiepieces earlier than 11...just sayin Beam & Cokes & the service were enough for me to give a review
We stopped by here for our first time to get some slices after hearing how good it is and I’m not sure what all the fuss is about. The slices were huge and smelled good, but after a few bites I was disappointed. Nothing stood out, flavor-wise. It was just bland tasting pizza, even with pepperoni and sausage. The crust was the real bummer. It was so bland we didn’t finish it. Our go-to NYC pizza place has a nice sour note in the crust that makes it so good. I guess we should have gone there. I wouldn’t recommend this spot if you’re looking for great pizza.
I have been searching for the perfect single slice pizza place I seen reviews that this was it but I have to say it's good fresh but the crust is a little to thin it rips to easy.
This place is delicious! We had a huge 26-inch pizza, I believe. I had one slice if I was really hungry or drunk, maybe 2 slices lol. The garlic knots were tasty, and the sauces complimented everything perfectly. The service was friendly and on point(thank you, Logan). Great pizza that won't break the bank. I'm definitely coming back again and soon.
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered the loaded breadsticks, double smash burger, and Sully's fries. Everything was delicious! Our waiter was knowledgeable and friendly. We will be back!
One size option - too big. One flavor option - way too much for a solid pizza (for reference, I like NY pizza… save your money and have it from Sexy Pizza or Cosmos or Anthony’s). One price point - too much. Dark walkway to pick up on the street on colfax. Just not a good pie… I didn’t think bad pizza existed until now.
Biggest, best pizza i've ever had. For such a good price. Just the right amount of crunch and droop ratio you want. Also best garlic knots i've ever had. I drive from Aurora to come here...
Big slices of pizza pie. Super delicious. But do want to warn you these slices are NY style and are huge not these little mom and pop slices.
Went to eat at 10:30 PM yesterday with my fiancé & son & was automatically greeted with a bad attitude server. Ordered the loaded knots & was told they are only serving slices & salad as their menu changes at 10 PM. We were bummed but continued to order 5 slices. 3 slices were so burnt, my 5 year old gagged & spit out his pizza. Asked the server for some napkins which she forgot about, so after 10 minutes of waiting for a napkin, finally got some. We see our server, Logan, bring out a full pie to the table behind us, & wondered why couldn't we order a full pie. At this point, I got up to speak with the manager, Hannah, who was amazing & apologized greatly & continued to let me know that the full menu stops at 11. Hannah took care of our entire check which was not what we were expecting, so we were very thankful. Our server Logan stopped at the table as we were getting our jackets on, & basically told us to leave because we didn't have to pay anything. Such a rude disrespectful server. If you get Logan as your server, ask for someone else.