Pizza was great 8/10 Service was amazing 10/10 Ambiance was amazing! Good vibes 9/10 Would eat again
Scotch M.
Pizza was good. It's little smaller than what we were expecting. Love the Parmesan cheese they put on the crust. 8/10 definitely worth trying
Danielle H.
Came here on a random Monday for a date night. The pizza and salad were awesome. Never disappoints and it a good shareable size. The only thing that seems a little stingy is the price of the side, sweet chili and ranch. Should be like 50 cents not a dollar or more! They have a front house and back experience which is fun and lively. The food takes a few minutes to come out, maybe more depending on the day and time that you go. We only tried the NY style so next time we are going to go for the Sicilian. A good pizza spot with the pizza being priced well. But everything else including the sauces and drinks are a bit much. Two pizza slices, two sauces, one salad and two drinks should not be $50. Overall 4/5 stars
Jason D.
Been going here since it opened. Used to be hands down the best pizza in Denver. Last 3 times, almost un edible. One thing to be greasy. Me and my partner only had one slice. Swimming in grease. The ricotta is sitting in puddles. Pretty bummed, because it used to be the cream of the crop.
Sydney M.
Had had the standard and pepperoni in the past (both are amazing) but wanted to switch it up and try something new. I couldn't find any reviews or pictures of this pie on yelp (here ya go) so I had to just try it myself. It did not disappoint. Almost wish the bacon was pancetta, I feel like it would have went better with the peas, but all in all 10/10 with all of their pies. Great structure, cook and flavor!
Jared P.
By far one of my favorite places to eat in Denver. The BEST pizza I've ever had, and I love pizza. Also try the sandwiches and salads which are next level!
h c.
Meh. Not bad but definitely not good. Got a classic- pictures shown with basil and didn't realize I had to check a box to add basil. Which is lame but that's on me. Redeemer is definitely NOT NY style pizza, and they claim to be "ny 2.0". , it's wayy too thick and fluffy. Not a thin crispy slice that ny is known for. Any place claiming to even come close to nyc food in Denver is going to get laughed at by me, especially when it comes to pizza. It's like Chelsea from love is blind with the Meghan fox comment, why even put it out there. You're gonna get shamed. Stay. In. Your. Lane. Love that redeemer uses local ingredients but the pizza didn't pack punch and I won't be back.
Steve K.
I had Philly-style tomato pie and I literally wiped the 16" masterpiece in 2 hours. My gosh man, well-done, I felt like I was back in Norristown...
Alana Yeomans
Love the takeout window. My husband ordered a pizza to go and he literally ate the whole thing I was
I'm not sure if their Winter Squash pizza is still available, but if it is, you should get it before the special goes away!I got takeout from here and the pizza was fantastic both fresh and leftover. I'd love to come back and try other pizzas they have.
Food: 5
Jacqueline T.
I'm not sure if their Winter Squash pizza is still available, but if it is, you should get it before the special goes away! I got takeout from here and the pizza was fantastic both fresh and leftover. I'd love to come back and try other pizzas they have.
Maria Rogers
Best pizza in Denver, can’t go wrong with that sourdough crust?? Do yourself a favor and also get the garlic knots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Standard Pizza, Garlic Knots
Carter D.
Redeemer is kick ass. Sat down at the bar and had the best Sicilian Slice ive ever had and a top notch beer. Service was friendly and welcoming, the restaurant itself is comfortable and fun to dine in. If you're in Denver, Redeemer is a Must stop for a quick slice and a beer. Do not skip this one
Nameless Name
Honestly the food is wonderful the service is absolutely awful. Waited over an hour to pick up my pizza this time around. This is the third time I have waited over 30 minutes from the pickup time to pickup a pizza. I will not be back anymore and will find another pizza joint to eat at with my family.
Pizza was great 8/10 Service was amazing 10/10 Ambiance was amazing! Good vibes 9/10 Would eat again
Pizza was good. It's little smaller than what we were expecting. Love the Parmesan cheese they put on the crust. 8/10 definitely worth trying
Came here on a random Monday for a date night. The pizza and salad were awesome. Never disappoints and it a good shareable size. The only thing that seems a little stingy is the price of the side, sweet chili and ranch. Should be like 50 cents not a dollar or more! They have a front house and back experience which is fun and lively. The food takes a few minutes to come out, maybe more depending on the day and time that you go. We only tried the NY style so next time we are going to go for the Sicilian. A good pizza spot with the pizza being priced well. But everything else including the sauces and drinks are a bit much. Two pizza slices, two sauces, one salad and two drinks should not be $50. Overall 4/5 stars
Been going here since it opened. Used to be hands down the best pizza in Denver. Last 3 times, almost un edible. One thing to be greasy. Me and my partner only had one slice. Swimming in grease. The ricotta is sitting in puddles. Pretty bummed, because it used to be the cream of the crop.
Had had the standard and pepperoni in the past (both are amazing) but wanted to switch it up and try something new. I couldn't find any reviews or pictures of this pie on yelp (here ya go) so I had to just try it myself. It did not disappoint. Almost wish the bacon was pancetta, I feel like it would have went better with the peas, but all in all 10/10 with all of their pies. Great structure, cook and flavor!
By far one of my favorite places to eat in Denver. The BEST pizza I've ever had, and I love pizza. Also try the sandwiches and salads which are next level!
Meh. Not bad but definitely not good. Got a classic- pictures shown with basil and didn't realize I had to check a box to add basil. Which is lame but that's on me. Redeemer is definitely NOT NY style pizza, and they claim to be "ny 2.0". , it's wayy too thick and fluffy. Not a thin crispy slice that ny is known for. Any place claiming to even come close to nyc food in Denver is going to get laughed at by me, especially when it comes to pizza. It's like Chelsea from love is blind with the Meghan fox comment, why even put it out there. You're gonna get shamed. Stay. In. Your. Lane. Love that redeemer uses local ingredients but the pizza didn't pack punch and I won't be back.
I had Philly-style tomato pie and I literally wiped the 16" masterpiece in 2 hours. My gosh man, well-done, I felt like I was back in Norristown...
Love the takeout window. My husband ordered a pizza to go and he literally ate the whole thing I was
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Standard
Nice pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
I'm not sure if their Winter Squash pizza is still available, but if it is, you should get it before the special goes away!I got takeout from here and the pizza was fantastic both fresh and leftover. I'd love to come back and try other pizzas they have.
Food: 5
I'm not sure if their Winter Squash pizza is still available, but if it is, you should get it before the special goes away! I got takeout from here and the pizza was fantastic both fresh and leftover. I'd love to come back and try other pizzas they have.
Best pizza in Denver, can’t go wrong with that sourdough crust?? Do yourself a favor and also get the garlic knots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Standard Pizza, Garlic Knots
Redeemer is kick ass. Sat down at the bar and had the best Sicilian Slice ive ever had and a top notch beer. Service was friendly and welcoming, the restaurant itself is comfortable and fun to dine in. If you're in Denver, Redeemer is a Must stop for a quick slice and a beer. Do not skip this one
Honestly the food is wonderful the service is absolutely awful. Waited over an hour to pick up my pizza this time around. This is the third time I have waited over 30 minutes from the pickup time to pickup a pizza. I will not be back anymore and will find another pizza joint to eat at with my family.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1