Pickup's Pizza Company
$$ • Pizza, American, Salad
Hours:
422 McIntire St, Eagle
(970) 328-3388
Customers' Favorites
Pickup's Pizza Company Reviews
We stopped on our way back home because it had good reviews and had parking for our trailer. So glad we did! Amazing pizza. Crispy browned cheesy edges and yummy sauce. The cheese bread was great. Friendly staff and very reasonable prices. For all the Denverites, it's better than Blue Pan. We will be back on our next trek west. Highly recommend stopping here!Parking: Happy we found a spot for a 170 sprinter towing snowmobiles.Kid-friendliness: Kiddo loved the pepperoni mushroom...read full review
Came across this gem of a pizza joint while pet sitting nearby for a friend. IMHO the pan pizza is 10/10. Coming from Chicago and Denver, I've certainly had my fair share of delicious pizza, but for Colorado, this takes the #1 spot. No joke. This is legit pan (almost Detroit style) pizza with perfectly standard sauce, solid cheese, amazing Italian sausage, and a delightfully crispy crust all around. Dare I say this beats Blue Pan [insert shrug emoji]
Ratings
Menu
Hours
Monday | 4 - 9PM |
Tuesday | 4 - 9PM |
Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
Friday | 4 - 9PM |
Saturday | 4 - 9PM |
Sunday | 4 - 9PM |
Hands down the best pizza in the valley. An absolute amazing product and not overpriced for quality. Everyone I have try it falls in love. Every pizza I have had is better than the next, but the lasagna is top-notch! Definitely the crowd pleaser in my family! If you have leftovers somehow, this is simply the best reheated pizza EVER! 4 mins in the air fryer and your back in heaven. It's nice to get East Coast flavor out here in colorado.. It's not a thin New York slice, but it's...read full review