Sweet Mustache

407 Broadway St, Eagle
(970) 432-1522

Recent Reviews

Atrévetee a Vivir S

My favorite place in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Danielle Huidekoper

Hands down the best apple pie I have ever eaten!!! Beyond that; great service, always very responsive and able to fill orders (even at that last minute). My go to in Eagle for sure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gabriela Resnicoff

Beautiful place and delicious pastries, I ordered a birthday cake plus cupckaes and everything was great ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicolette Buono

This place is the best! Every time I have been here the person who was working there was super nice and gave me and my friend each a free scoop of ice cream when the scoop of ice cream we each had had a little less than a normal scoop ( which we wouldn’t have noticed anyway). prices are great but bubble waffle cone took around 5 ish minutes to make but we didn’t mind. cake batter is the best ice cream I have ever had! raspberry sorbet was exceptional too. they also have plenty of gluten free options.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First Strike Veteran

Yummy sherbert and many other desserts. Owner is very nice and the price of the product is very reasonable.

Tyson Ivie

Yummy sherbert and many other desserts. Owner is very nice and the price of the product is very reasonable.

Monica Galindo

Everything is very rich

Lisa Wells

Delicious choices! My first time, wont be my last. Pastries, cakes, ice cream, tarts, etc.

Jenny Wurth

Hidden treasure! ❤️

Stephania Giraldo

This place is amazing!They do have a very limited amount of flavors for their ice cream BUT their desserts are something else. Great flavor, fresh and beautiful looking.Definitely worthy!!Also, did you know that they can make a cake for any special occasion? Yep!

Mark R.

Fantastic baked delights at a reasonable cost. Dolche de leche and strawberry pavlova were two favorites.

Alanis Páez

Mi pastelería favorita ❤️ Voy con mi familia todas las semanas sin falta ya sea para comer pasteles o un helado, también hemos encargado tortas dos veces y todo muy exquisito y con la mejor presentación. Por lejos uno de los mejores emprendimientos que he conocido: amables, puntuales y súper dedicadas. Lo recomiendo a ojos cerrados!

Jasmine Hermosillo Najera

I know one of the co-owners from her previous history as a Pastry Chef working at a restaurant up-valley. Amaya is an amazing baker and her work speaks for itself. I go there personally and loved it so much that I am using them for our future Eagle County Paramedic Services' sweet treat needs. Their communication is great and is worth the price. Homemade baked goods are pricey but hers are extra worth the extra dollars compared to what you would get at City Market. Support small businesses.

Joel Petrow

High-end pastery shop. It's not cheap, but worth it.

Samantha LoFaro

I visit every weekend and treat to myself to all sorts of delicious cookies and baked goods! Amazing bakery and owner...

Load More