Pizza tastes the best of any in Evergreen, but they consistently get orders wrong. No longer reliable. In desperate need of an adult manager. Run and managed entirely by kids.
Randy Sloman
Six out of eight of my last tries eating there have been horrible. From phone orders not placed to completely cold and inedible to go food. Employees are plenty nice but a little bit too relaxed in their approach to proper customer
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Dan Manson
This place has recently changed owners, and that made a world of difference. The service is fantastic, and the manager girl we talked to was amazing. We showed up shortly before closing and she had no problem making a pizza for us even though it was just a minute or two before they closed. Also, free video games!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ennis Cruz Gonzalez
I wasn't going to leave a comment but I tried to reach out twice to the manager and I still haven't gotten my money back. I was charged three times for cannolis when I only asked for an order of one and I received only one. I spoke to the manager twice for a refund and I was basically just told they don't know how to use the new system and they can't refund me. It was $9 on top of them tipping themselves without my consent almost $9. So my bill which would've been $45 including tip and tax for a takeout order, actually ended up being $60... The pizza was good, I'll give them that. But you gotta do better on customer service ?
Food: 3
Service: 2
Chad Bakken
Horrible pizza, only received half my wings. This was bad and I gave them another chance then got sick off the undercooked chicken wings. Don’t go there
Nadia Leunig
Wonderful pizza! Amazing customer service my server Kiran S. was wonderful and had great hospitality. Would recommend!
Rachel Baskin
Delicious white with mushrooms…amazing crust. Ceasar with proper big bites of romaine. Thanks!
Lin Browning
My son won't eat inside because he says it's too dirty. We got a thin crust pepperoni. So greasy. It went in the trash.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Naomi H.
Over the top customer service ..delicious pizza .. they are adding the most important ingredient in their food .. LOVE
Aaron Doyle Ong
The WORST pizza I have ever paid for, dinner totally ruined.Seriously, I could make the same pizza with a childs easy bake oven after drinking a 5th of whisky.How is this place still in business?
I ordered a pizza to be well done, with extra cheese, extra sauce, and mushrooms on 1/2. None of these things occurred. The bottom of the pizza was literally still white, and it was basically raw. There was no extra sauce, there was no extra cheese. And mushrooms were atop the entire thing. You’d be better off buying a Totino’s then going to this establishment. And I’m sorry if this is harsh. I almost never leave bad reviews. But that’s how bad this pizza was.
A C
I was so disappointed in Anthony’s! I’ve heard a lot of rave reviews lately so I placed an order one night and everything was awful. Ingredients were left off the pizza, the dough was straight up raw, way too much cheese. I even tried to cook the pizza more in my oven but there was no saving it. I’ll typically muscle through and eat something I’ve paid good money for but this went straight in the trash.
Mike Chamberlain
Prior to the new owners taking over, we made a pilgrimage to evergreen at least once a month just to get Anthony’s Pizza (they used to be better than the ones in Denver area).We came up today 3/14/23 and were just so disappointed, I felt compelled to write this review.The entire vibe of this place has changed. The folks behind the counter look miserable and definitely wear their emotions on their sleeves.Our pizza was so greasy we had to blot it with napkins. Our salad was missing its dressing. The drink machine was not functioning. The trash receptacle was overflowing onto the dirty floor. Bathroom was disgusting, toilet paper all over the floor and had no soap at the sink.It wasn’t just us either. Every single customer in there with us were having similar issues.This place has gone downhill over the past year and we are very saddened to say that we will not be back.I only gave them a second star because of the marinara sauce. It’s the only thing good that is left.
Rudolf Marusic
After a year or 2 hiatus Anthony’s is back! New owners are really killing it. Pizza was a solid 7.1 on the One Bite scale. I got mine with extra cheese and it did not disappoint. It’s New York style pizza full of flavor and deliciousness. I highly recommend Anthony’s if your in the area.
The D
Woah!!! I've been living in CO for 12yrs originally from New England. This is the best pizza I have had in YEARS! Exactly how I like it. So freakin good. Everyone there was super cool too. Next time I am in this area I am stopping in again. See that pic of the empty plate? I even ate my crusts!
Pizza tastes the best of any in Evergreen, but they consistently get orders wrong. No longer reliable. In desperate need of an adult manager. Run and managed entirely by kids.
Six out of eight of my last tries eating there have been horrible. From phone orders not placed to completely cold and inedible to go food. Employees are plenty nice but a little bit too relaxed in their approach to proper customer
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
This place has recently changed owners, and that made a world of difference. The service is fantastic, and the manager girl we talked to was amazing. We showed up shortly before closing and she had no problem making a pizza for us even though it was just a minute or two before they closed. Also, free video games!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wasn't going to leave a comment but I tried to reach out twice to the manager and I still haven't gotten my money back. I was charged three times for cannolis when I only asked for an order of one and I received only one. I spoke to the manager twice for a refund and I was basically just told they don't know how to use the new system and they can't refund me. It was $9 on top of them tipping themselves without my consent almost $9. So my bill which would've been $45 including tip and tax for a takeout order, actually ended up being $60... The pizza was good, I'll give them that. But you gotta do better on customer service ?
Food: 3
Service: 2
Horrible pizza, only received half my wings. This was bad and I gave them another chance then got sick off the undercooked chicken wings. Don’t go there
Wonderful pizza! Amazing customer service my server Kiran S. was wonderful and had great hospitality. Would recommend!
Delicious white with mushrooms…amazing crust. Ceasar with proper big bites of romaine. Thanks!
My son won't eat inside because he says it's too dirty. We got a thin crust pepperoni. So greasy. It went in the trash.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Over the top customer service ..delicious pizza .. they are adding the most important ingredient in their food .. LOVE
The WORST pizza I have ever paid for, dinner totally ruined.Seriously, I could make the same pizza with a childs easy bake oven after drinking a 5th of whisky.How is this place still in business?
Restaurantji Recommends
I ordered a pizza to be well done, with extra cheese, extra sauce, and mushrooms on 1/2. None of these things occurred. The bottom of the pizza was literally still white, and it was basically raw. There was no extra sauce, there was no extra cheese. And mushrooms were atop the entire thing. You’d be better off buying a Totino’s then going to this establishment. And I’m sorry if this is harsh. I almost never leave bad reviews. But that’s how bad this pizza was.
I was so disappointed in Anthony’s! I’ve heard a lot of rave reviews lately so I placed an order one night and everything was awful. Ingredients were left off the pizza, the dough was straight up raw, way too much cheese. I even tried to cook the pizza more in my oven but there was no saving it. I’ll typically muscle through and eat something I’ve paid good money for but this went straight in the trash.
Prior to the new owners taking over, we made a pilgrimage to evergreen at least once a month just to get Anthony’s Pizza (they used to be better than the ones in Denver area).We came up today 3/14/23 and were just so disappointed, I felt compelled to write this review.The entire vibe of this place has changed. The folks behind the counter look miserable and definitely wear their emotions on their sleeves.Our pizza was so greasy we had to blot it with napkins. Our salad was missing its dressing. The drink machine was not functioning. The trash receptacle was overflowing onto the dirty floor. Bathroom was disgusting, toilet paper all over the floor and had no soap at the sink.It wasn’t just us either. Every single customer in there with us were having similar issues.This place has gone downhill over the past year and we are very saddened to say that we will not be back.I only gave them a second star because of the marinara sauce. It’s the only thing good that is left.
After a year or 2 hiatus Anthony’s is back! New owners are really killing it. Pizza was a solid 7.1 on the One Bite scale. I got mine with extra cheese and it did not disappoint. It’s New York style pizza full of flavor and deliciousness. I highly recommend Anthony’s if your in the area.
Woah!!! I've been living in CO for 12yrs originally from New England. This is the best pizza I have had in YEARS! Exactly how I like it. So freakin good. Everyone there was super cool too. Next time I am in this area I am stopping in again. See that pic of the empty plate? I even ate my crusts!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5