It’s very unfortunate that this place has good pizza because there is nothing else good about GPC. I have never had good service, every time I go they are out of something, whether it’s the wings or several of the beers, not to mention bathrooms are dirty with no hand washing soap. I can understand on certain occasions these things happen, but when it is repetitious it’s a problem. Not to mention when you order for a family of 4 and you wait 30 minutes or more between your meals… it’s just unacceptable in my eyes. I have it 3 strikes and I will not be going back. Best of luck in the future GPC. Hope you can make changes.
Kevin Abell
Double triple wasn't deep dish, barely any sauce. And the blackend wings -they forgot the 2 sauces i ordered. Flavor on pizza wasn't great either. Plus they didn't give a reciept which I needed for my upside app.
Anson Cordeiro
Too small, the food selection is among the worst in Greeley for a sports bar and slowly diminished over time. A lot of the food I have ordered has been burned in their brick oven, and they still continue to serve it. The beer wall is a cool idea, the alcohol is priced very well, if your tap works and does not poor more foam than
Bethany Crandall
Disappointed in my experience here. I really wanted to like it because I love brick oven pizzas and supporting local businesses.The largest pizza they have is only 14in and costs $30. When we payed $30 we expected a more filling pizza. When we received our pizza it was smaller than 14in and they were very skimpy with the toppings.We also ordered wings, but several of our wings were pink and bloody on the inside. When we told our server she responded with a clearly rehearsed answer about the wings being cooked to temperature twice (whatever that means) so it has clearly happened several times before.After the very small amount of pizza and picking what meat I could out of the wings, I looked to the celery to fill me up. But alas, even the celery was wilted. In the end I had to go get a second dinner.I see lots of other positive reviews on here so perhaps we just went on a bad day. The food we got did taste good, and the servers were nice, there were just lots of problems. Or maybe it is easy to overlook these problems if you partake of the restaurants beer wall. I hope others have a better experience here.
Jaime
I love the concept of pouring your own beer/cocktail/wine/cider!! Pizza was also delicious and service was excellent!!
Aspen Jade
I didn't eat here but i was picking up an order here. The owner i believe is who it was, was super friendly and had a great vibe the food looked and smelled amazing. The pricing was super good. They forgot to make 1 pizza but had it done super quick! Overall i can't wait to go back and actually try the food this time!
Rick Yerby
So this was our first time to visit GPC. We started with the garlic parmesan bread sticks. They did come a bit underdone but the waitress took them back and when she brought them back they were very good. We shared a buffalo chicken bacon and a Leonardo. Both are excellent and we will definitely be back! Thanks Rhiannon!
Kaylin McBride
We loved this place! Great food, great service and just a fun atmosphere! We popped in yesterday on a whim and ended up having one of the best experiences! The beer wall is such a fun idea, the staff was more than welcoming. I highly recommend!
tim jones
Super friendly staff. The wings were absolutely amazing. The garlic cheesey bread was super greasy but had good flavor. The pizzas were just a little above mediocre as the sauce was barely noticeable and the cheese over powered the flavor profile. Will definitely be back to try other items that are available and hope to be surprised. I recommend giving them a try if you are in the area as the staff are some of the most friendly folks I have ever met. I intend to dine in on my next visit to see if the travel time effected the quality of the pizzas at all. The churro pie had me hopeful but the flavor was really hit or miss. There were dark spots on the churro pie that were lovely bursts of flavor but then another bite was just dough for flavor. The cinnamon roll twists were definitely better and the frosting was buttery goodness. Last observation is the pizzas seemed to cook unevenly, one slice would be perfectly crisp while another would be burnt and yet another would be under done. I look forward to my next visit and the friendly conversation with the staff.
Kenneth
I got on here to write a review, and I got intrigued and read the other reviews first . I was baffled by a lot of the Karens who posted below. My experience, with my kids was incredible. Honestly, Im not a review guy; this might be my second I have ever written, but I believe my experience was worthy of a solid review. I am always looking for great local places to take my kids for special occasions. I am also a pizza snob. I absolutely loved the quality of pizza, the crispy crust, the tang of the sauce and the perfect temp that it came out at. I appreciated the beer wall and the chance to try lots of different beers at a fraction of the price I normally would have to pay. The service was five stars. The woman who served us was the most kind woman I have ever met. It basically felt like we went to a church that served freaking awesome pizza. The Greeley Pizza Company is a business the city of Greeley should be proud of and should rally behind. Thanks so much for a great experience for for taking care of us so well. We really appreciate you!
Love this place! The owner is the best guy you'll ever meet. New manager is terrific. They've made some fantastic changes to their menu, adding more specialty pizzas and toppings such as fresh mozarella, fresh basil, fresh garlic, and others. Great location to watch a game while sampling beer from their vast self-service lineup. Perfect on a fall afternoon, with the fresh air blowing through. Favorite local pizza spot!
cyndy cyndy1951
My husband and I just spent the evening at Greeley Pizza Company and loved it. The Pizza was tasty and the beer and drink wall fun. I had a raspberry vodka with lemonade that was a very pleasant drink. Not too sweet. My husband tried a few different beers. A fun experience. Our waitress, Tawny walked us through it all. If you haven't been before, give it a try. We will definitely be back. Thanks!
Janae Vee
Where is the zero star option? First of all, we heard about the all you can eat pizza and salad bar for $16. So I brought my husband, 1 year old and 2 year old. When you hear "all you can eat" you think of buffet style with multiple pizza options, salad bar, and usually dessert. We walk in and there is not anything of this sort. We sat down and were told one pizza at a time with only option being sausage and pep. We thought one whole pizza at a time?.. When we sat down, drink cups were already at the table. We figured those must have been included in the buffet price. We got our fountain drinks sat down and our first pizza SLICE was brought out. Then once we were finished we asked for a second slice. We asked for sausage, but pep was the only option. Okay? So we finished up and received a bill for $61.99!!! We had a total of 4 pizza slices.. 2 salads..and drinks that we thought were included (since the cups were at the table) and that was it.....my 1 year old and 2 year old were charged $7 each?? This is so ridiculous as we could have gotten a better deal ordering a large pizza and 2 salads with 2 drinks and maybe paid half that seeing as how my 1 and 2 year old don't eat anything more than a few bites. We have been to an Italian buffet in Denver and paid $50. This is our second bad experience with this place. The first one was before the name change. We thought maybe things would be different. No. I do want to note the server was friendly.
Clay Calkins
Ordered once from Doordash, a pizza and order of sticky rolls. Both arrived burned. The pizza was fine but not great, the rolls were charred beyond edibility.Attempted to give this place a second chance by dining in with a friend. Was told to have a seat. Sat for 20+ minutes, no service whatsoever. Also the live music was so loud in this space that it was unbearable. We ended up just leaving.
Stewart Farris
The pizza was great and it’s an awesome atmosphere! I encourage everyone to check this restaurant out!
It’s very unfortunate that this place has good pizza because there is nothing else good about GPC. I have never had good service, every time I go they are out of something, whether it’s the wings or several of the beers, not to mention bathrooms are dirty with no hand washing soap. I can understand on certain occasions these things happen, but when it is repetitious it’s a problem. Not to mention when you order for a family of 4 and you wait 30 minutes or more between your meals… it’s just unacceptable in my eyes. I have it 3 strikes and I will not be going back. Best of luck in the future GPC. Hope you can make changes.
Double triple wasn't deep dish, barely any sauce. And the blackend wings -they forgot the 2 sauces i ordered. Flavor on pizza wasn't great either. Plus they didn't give a reciept which I needed for my upside app.
Too small, the food selection is among the worst in Greeley for a sports bar and slowly diminished over time. A lot of the food I have ordered has been burned in their brick oven, and they still continue to serve it. The beer wall is a cool idea, the alcohol is priced very well, if your tap works and does not poor more foam than
Disappointed in my experience here. I really wanted to like it because I love brick oven pizzas and supporting local businesses.The largest pizza they have is only 14in and costs $30. When we payed $30 we expected a more filling pizza. When we received our pizza it was smaller than 14in and they were very skimpy with the toppings.We also ordered wings, but several of our wings were pink and bloody on the inside. When we told our server she responded with a clearly rehearsed answer about the wings being cooked to temperature twice (whatever that means) so it has clearly happened several times before.After the very small amount of pizza and picking what meat I could out of the wings, I looked to the celery to fill me up. But alas, even the celery was wilted. In the end I had to go get a second dinner.I see lots of other positive reviews on here so perhaps we just went on a bad day. The food we got did taste good, and the servers were nice, there were just lots of problems. Or maybe it is easy to overlook these problems if you partake of the restaurants beer wall. I hope others have a better experience here.
I love the concept of pouring your own beer/cocktail/wine/cider!! Pizza was also delicious and service was excellent!!
I didn't eat here but i was picking up an order here. The owner i believe is who it was, was super friendly and had a great vibe the food looked and smelled amazing. The pricing was super good. They forgot to make 1 pizza but had it done super quick! Overall i can't wait to go back and actually try the food this time!
So this was our first time to visit GPC. We started with the garlic parmesan bread sticks. They did come a bit underdone but the waitress took them back and when she brought them back they were very good. We shared a buffalo chicken bacon and a Leonardo. Both are excellent and we will definitely be back! Thanks Rhiannon!
We loved this place! Great food, great service and just a fun atmosphere! We popped in yesterday on a whim and ended up having one of the best experiences! The beer wall is such a fun idea, the staff was more than welcoming. I highly recommend!
Super friendly staff. The wings were absolutely amazing. The garlic cheesey bread was super greasy but had good flavor. The pizzas were just a little above mediocre as the sauce was barely noticeable and the cheese over powered the flavor profile. Will definitely be back to try other items that are available and hope to be surprised. I recommend giving them a try if you are in the area as the staff are some of the most friendly folks I have ever met. I intend to dine in on my next visit to see if the travel time effected the quality of the pizzas at all. The churro pie had me hopeful but the flavor was really hit or miss. There were dark spots on the churro pie that were lovely bursts of flavor but then another bite was just dough for flavor. The cinnamon roll twists were definitely better and the frosting was buttery goodness. Last observation is the pizzas seemed to cook unevenly, one slice would be perfectly crisp while another would be burnt and yet another would be under done. I look forward to my next visit and the friendly conversation with the staff.
I got on here to write a review, and I got intrigued and read the other reviews first . I was baffled by a lot of the Karens who posted below. My experience, with my kids was incredible. Honestly, Im not a review guy; this might be my second I have ever written, but I believe my experience was worthy of a solid review. I am always looking for great local places to take my kids for special occasions. I am also a pizza snob. I absolutely loved the quality of pizza, the crispy crust, the tang of the sauce and the perfect temp that it came out at. I appreciated the beer wall and the chance to try lots of different beers at a fraction of the price I normally would have to pay. The service was five stars. The woman who served us was the most kind woman I have ever met. It basically felt like we went to a church that served freaking awesome pizza. The Greeley Pizza Company is a business the city of Greeley should be proud of and should rally behind. Thanks so much for a great experience for for taking care of us so well. We really appreciate you!
Restaurantji Recommends
Love this place! The owner is the best guy you'll ever meet. New manager is terrific. They've made some fantastic changes to their menu, adding more specialty pizzas and toppings such as fresh mozarella, fresh basil, fresh garlic, and others. Great location to watch a game while sampling beer from their vast self-service lineup. Perfect on a fall afternoon, with the fresh air blowing through. Favorite local pizza spot!
My husband and I just spent the evening at Greeley Pizza Company and loved it. The Pizza was tasty and the beer and drink wall fun. I had a raspberry vodka with lemonade that was a very pleasant drink. Not too sweet. My husband tried a few different beers. A fun experience. Our waitress, Tawny walked us through it all. If you haven't been before, give it a try. We will definitely be back. Thanks!
Where is the zero star option? First of all, we heard about the all you can eat pizza and salad bar for $16. So I brought my husband, 1 year old and 2 year old. When you hear "all you can eat" you think of buffet style with multiple pizza options, salad bar, and usually dessert. We walk in and there is not anything of this sort. We sat down and were told one pizza at a time with only option being sausage and pep. We thought one whole pizza at a time?.. When we sat down, drink cups were already at the table. We figured those must have been included in the buffet price. We got our fountain drinks sat down and our first pizza SLICE was brought out. Then once we were finished we asked for a second slice. We asked for sausage, but pep was the only option. Okay? So we finished up and received a bill for $61.99!!! We had a total of 4 pizza slices.. 2 salads..and drinks that we thought were included (since the cups were at the table) and that was it.....my 1 year old and 2 year old were charged $7 each?? This is so ridiculous as we could have gotten a better deal ordering a large pizza and 2 salads with 2 drinks and maybe paid half that seeing as how my 1 and 2 year old don't eat anything more than a few bites. We have been to an Italian buffet in Denver and paid $50. This is our second bad experience with this place. The first one was before the name change. We thought maybe things would be different. No. I do want to note the server was friendly.
Ordered once from Doordash, a pizza and order of sticky rolls. Both arrived burned. The pizza was fine but not great, the rolls were charred beyond edibility.Attempted to give this place a second chance by dining in with a friend. Was told to have a seat. Sat for 20+ minutes, no service whatsoever. Also the live music was so loud in this space that it was unbearable. We ended up just leaving.
The pizza was great and it’s an awesome atmosphere! I encourage everyone to check this restaurant out!