Delicious cookies and adorable frosting designs! Eileen's cookies are SO good. I've tried many of their different baked flavors as well as frosted cookies, and they are all amazing. The store owners are wonderful as well, I love supporting their business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
RamU 1016
The best cookies ever. When I was a young kid, one of my earliest memories was going to a local market with my mom back in the 1980s to get a yellow frosted sugar cookie with a blue smiley face on it. Those cookies were so good! It was always a special thing we did together. The first time I tried an Eileen's frosted sugar cookie, I was transported back to that place in time and those happy memories. I'm 40 now, and it's tradition now for my family and our 2 young boys to get Eileen's frosted sugar cookies for special treats and occassions. Thanks, Eileen's Cookies. Your dedication to your craft and friendly staff are simply the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies Put on a Tray, Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies
Angela jensen
The friggin cookie cake for my kiddos bday! Omgosh!!!I love that they didn’t miss the extra “N” in her name! So perfect and I simply just gave them open creation. They had it ready an hour early! LOVE. Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brooke Mason
I freaking love this place. Consistently delicious cookies!
Jewels Brewner
Ordered for Saturday but I went on Friday oops and the cookies were ready! Absolutely cute cookies for my grandbabys first birthday. Staff is fabulous and the cookies were so good. We even got some cookies for our ride home.
Debra Wilburn
My kids were huge fans of these cookies. My youngest keeps mentioning the texture ?
Noah L
The new owner got rid of most of the options for ice cream sandwiches. As soon as the new owner was in place, they decided to raise all the prices immediately which gives a bad look. The prices have increased every time I've came back to this store and I don't plan on going back since it just seems like the business plan for the new owner was to make the store more profitable by charging more and consistently raising prices. Not the old Eileen's anymore.
Jeremy M.
The best! Anytime I can get a cookie cake from here, I definitely will! Everything is delicious. They also have regular size cookies as well, but they're known for their cookie cakes.
Carolyn Lawrence
Made us an amazing Ender Dragon cake for my kid's birthday.
Casey Weeman
Disappointed! We have had Eileen’s Cookies many times over the last 3 years here in Colorado. We became hooked in Omaha eight years ago. We drive from Colorado Springs just to get a few dozen frosted sugar cookies and some special decorated for the kids. We haven’t been in a while and we won’t be back. The frosted cookies have increased to nearly $20 a dozen. You used to be able to get a decorated dozen for that price. The cookies I got were dry…. No! You can justify your increase in price, but your quality needs to stay remain. This was not the case. Your cookies are still beautifully decorated as my children got 4 decorated ones($2.35/piece). Their baseballs were fresh, but the Colorado and rainbow cookies were dry. You can’t sell dry cookies for nearly $20/dozen and think people will come back.
The most darling truck cookies for my son’s 2nd birthday. I contacted them only about a week before his party and they were able to accommodate and were very kind! They are delicious too!
Sherrie G.
Ordered a cookie cake over the phone and gave them very few guidelines, other than the wording and the requirement that Godzilla be on it. They did an absolutely amazing job. The birthday boy was thrilled.
T. T.
First visit and last one! I went in looking for SPD cookies, none. Ended up buying the large cookies, they had no bag to put them in! Putnthem in a bunch of small white cookie holders. Asked about the white boxes with bows, was told those were for decoration. Ended up buying a large rectangular box. I then asked a female working about the white boxes, and she immediately said they wouldn't work for the large cookies. What?!?! It was a very unwelcoming experience and not worth the drive or money spent.
Michael Nestlehut
First time here. I got the $3 M&M cookie. The cookie was just okay to me. The M&M's seem to taste a little bit off but it was soft and fresh. Just doesn't hold up to Crumbl or even Mrs Fields. Good cookies but not great on first impression.
Ana Smolnisky
Cookies are amazing. Staff is kind and knowledgeable. We love Eileen’s HR!
Delicious cookies and adorable frosting designs! Eileen's cookies are SO good. I've tried many of their different baked flavors as well as frosted cookies, and they are all amazing. The store owners are wonderful as well, I love supporting their business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best cookies ever. When I was a young kid, one of my earliest memories was going to a local market with my mom back in the 1980s to get a yellow frosted sugar cookie with a blue smiley face on it. Those cookies were so good! It was always a special thing we did together. The first time I tried an Eileen's frosted sugar cookie, I was transported back to that place in time and those happy memories. I'm 40 now, and it's tradition now for my family and our 2 young boys to get Eileen's frosted sugar cookies for special treats and occassions. Thanks, Eileen's Cookies. Your dedication to your craft and friendly staff are simply the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies Put on a Tray, Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies
The friggin cookie cake for my kiddos bday! Omgosh!!!I love that they didn’t miss the extra “N” in her name! So perfect and I simply just gave them open creation. They had it ready an hour early! LOVE. Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I freaking love this place. Consistently delicious cookies!
Ordered for Saturday but I went on Friday oops and the cookies were ready! Absolutely cute cookies for my grandbabys first birthday. Staff is fabulous and the cookies were so good. We even got some cookies for our ride home.
My kids were huge fans of these cookies. My youngest keeps mentioning the texture ?
The new owner got rid of most of the options for ice cream sandwiches. As soon as the new owner was in place, they decided to raise all the prices immediately which gives a bad look. The prices have increased every time I've came back to this store and I don't plan on going back since it just seems like the business plan for the new owner was to make the store more profitable by charging more and consistently raising prices. Not the old Eileen's anymore.
The best! Anytime I can get a cookie cake from here, I definitely will! Everything is delicious. They also have regular size cookies as well, but they're known for their cookie cakes.
Made us an amazing Ender Dragon cake for my kid's birthday.
Disappointed! We have had Eileen’s Cookies many times over the last 3 years here in Colorado. We became hooked in Omaha eight years ago. We drive from Colorado Springs just to get a few dozen frosted sugar cookies and some special decorated for the kids. We haven’t been in a while and we won’t be back. The frosted cookies have increased to nearly $20 a dozen. You used to be able to get a decorated dozen for that price. The cookies I got were dry…. No! You can justify your increase in price, but your quality needs to stay remain. This was not the case. Your cookies are still beautifully decorated as my children got 4 decorated ones($2.35/piece). Their baseballs were fresh, but the Colorado and rainbow cookies were dry. You can’t sell dry cookies for nearly $20/dozen and think people will come back.
Restaurantji Recommends
The most darling truck cookies for my son’s 2nd birthday. I contacted them only about a week before his party and they were able to accommodate and were very kind! They are delicious too!
Ordered a cookie cake over the phone and gave them very few guidelines, other than the wording and the requirement that Godzilla be on it. They did an absolutely amazing job. The birthday boy was thrilled.
First visit and last one! I went in looking for SPD cookies, none. Ended up buying the large cookies, they had no bag to put them in! Putnthem in a bunch of small white cookie holders. Asked about the white boxes with bows, was told those were for decoration. Ended up buying a large rectangular box. I then asked a female working about the white boxes, and she immediately said they wouldn't work for the large cookies. What?!?! It was a very unwelcoming experience and not worth the drive or money spent.
First time here. I got the $3 M&M cookie. The cookie was just okay to me. The M&M's seem to taste a little bit off but it was soft and fresh. Just doesn't hold up to Crumbl or even Mrs Fields. Good cookies but not great on first impression.
Cookies are amazing. Staff is kind and knowledgeable. We love Eileen’s HR!