The food was fine but the bathroom was disgusting. Who knows what the kitchen is like.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
Ibis- -Cloudie
All that garlic really turned my stomach into a knot. Truth be told… I’m actually a vampire ?. Unfortunately I was cursed with child and I am experiencing multitudes of strange pregnancy symptoms such as peculiar food cravings. One of these cravings just so happened to be Italian cuisine which does predominantly contain garlic. Boy oh boy my baby really has a talent for causing me great pain! I probably would have died if the great master vampire didn’t put a garlic safety spell on me and my pregnant belly. Anyways, would highly recommend if you want to end the life of one of your dark mystic castle roommates in the deep woods. From one pregnant vampire to the general human public, thank you… ? ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Downie
This place use to be a great pizza place that I’d always recommend. Those days are gone.Past 3-4 times I’ve come here. The quality of the pizza has declined significantly and it’s just bad. I can’t recommend this place anymore, it’s too embarrassing.But what is the worse than the low quality pizza is the terrible and worthless customer service. For example, I paid with cash, the person took all my change and dumped into his tip jar. I was like… dude, can I have my change please …. His response was “oh you wanted that?”They don’t serve your pizza with plates if you dine in. The dine in area was so dirty and no one lifted a finger to clean it as they were using those fingers the whole time I was there to mess around on their phones.It’s too bad because it never use to be like this.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Maria R.
Our favorite restaurant in town! They have tons of gluten free and vegetarian options. The kids at the counter are always sweet and the food is always DELICIOUS. Recommend for everybody.
Emma Forbes
The food tastes really good. I got a thick pan pizza (I forgot what it was called). It just wasn't my taste, it was very saucy with very little cheese and I personally prefer it the other way around. I love the garlic knots and highly reccomend them. The staff was super nice and friendly. I also found out that we went to the original restaurant (from my research, I could be wrong) which I thought was super cool!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizza and lots of other non-meat optionsDietary restrictions: Gluten-free pizza optionWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair ramp
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza Toppings
Sandy J.
Been going here for years. Definitely the best New York pizza in Co. Staff is always super nice and the food never disappoints. 10/10
Leilaa g.
I've been going to this location for a long time now. This weekend we had to put in a huge order last minute. They weren't only accommodating, they were happy to do it! Pizza was reasonably priced and came out quick. I definitely recommend ordering for to-go. Pizza was delicious!! Will definitely bringing the kiddos back here.
Suzie K.
Amazing NY Style Pizza!. GRANDMAS , SICLIAN, CALZONES, they have it all! Reminds me of a place i used to eat at in Park Slope Brooklyn! This place is a must..
Petey Helm
Love this place! Pizza and mozz garlic knots are incredible. Nice small town feel. Will be back
Virginia Herzberg
Got dinner delivered, the service was great. Our delivery guy was very polite & sociable, even when our dog got out front to greet him.Food was hot & delicious, we got a nice variety of sandwiches, pasta and pizza. Loved that the marinara wasn't super sweet and that the dough didn't feel heavy or over flavored. Will def order again.
Food was tasty! Only disappointment was asking for dry wings, with teriyaki on the side and receiving soy sauce instead!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Lynne Rerucha
The food was yummy as always-the only trouble was the online ordering gave me no clue as to when to pick it up.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Ken K
They didn't follow directions... bought two meals, one without the optional jalapeños. The box is unchecked by default.I got a meal loaded with jalapeños. $14 down the drain. Boo.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Ryan Shook
Not Great. I got a small pepperoni pizza & 5 ct Garlic knot with marinara sauce. Total cost $18.90. Pizza sauce was tasty but the crust was floppy. Very greasy. The restaurant namesake Garlic Knots were embarrassing bad. Hard, stale knots with no flavor at all. I picked up my order but from what I could see the kitchen was very messy with an entire raw pizza dough getting stepped on by the staff. +1 star for the sauce but honestly really disappointing since this is so close to my home. Very unlikely I will order from here again.
The food was fine but the bathroom was disgusting. Who knows what the kitchen is like.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 2
All that garlic really turned my stomach into a knot. Truth be told… I’m actually a vampire ?. Unfortunately I was cursed with child and I am experiencing multitudes of strange pregnancy symptoms such as peculiar food cravings. One of these cravings just so happened to be Italian cuisine which does predominantly contain garlic. Boy oh boy my baby really has a talent for causing me great pain! I probably would have died if the great master vampire didn’t put a garlic safety spell on me and my pregnant belly. Anyways, would highly recommend if you want to end the life of one of your dark mystic castle roommates in the deep woods. From one pregnant vampire to the general human public, thank you… ? ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place use to be a great pizza place that I’d always recommend. Those days are gone.Past 3-4 times I’ve come here. The quality of the pizza has declined significantly and it’s just bad. I can’t recommend this place anymore, it’s too embarrassing.But what is the worse than the low quality pizza is the terrible and worthless customer service. For example, I paid with cash, the person took all my change and dumped into his tip jar. I was like… dude, can I have my change please …. His response was “oh you wanted that?”They don’t serve your pizza with plates if you dine in. The dine in area was so dirty and no one lifted a finger to clean it as they were using those fingers the whole time I was there to mess around on their phones.It’s too bad because it never use to be like this.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Our favorite restaurant in town! They have tons of gluten free and vegetarian options. The kids at the counter are always sweet and the food is always DELICIOUS. Recommend for everybody.
The food tastes really good. I got a thick pan pizza (I forgot what it was called). It just wasn't my taste, it was very saucy with very little cheese and I personally prefer it the other way around. I love the garlic knots and highly reccomend them. The staff was super nice and friendly. I also found out that we went to the original restaurant (from my research, I could be wrong) which I thought was super cool!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian pizza and lots of other non-meat optionsDietary restrictions: Gluten-free pizza optionWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair ramp
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Pizza Toppings
Been going here for years. Definitely the best New York pizza in Co. Staff is always super nice and the food never disappoints. 10/10
I've been going to this location for a long time now. This weekend we had to put in a huge order last minute. They weren't only accommodating, they were happy to do it! Pizza was reasonably priced and came out quick. I definitely recommend ordering for to-go. Pizza was delicious!! Will definitely bringing the kiddos back here.
Amazing NY Style Pizza!. GRANDMAS , SICLIAN, CALZONES, they have it all! Reminds me of a place i used to eat at in Park Slope Brooklyn! This place is a must..
Love this place! Pizza and mozz garlic knots are incredible. Nice small town feel. Will be back
Got dinner delivered, the service was great. Our delivery guy was very polite & sociable, even when our dog got out front to greet him.Food was hot & delicious, we got a nice variety of sandwiches, pasta and pizza. Loved that the marinara wasn't super sweet and that the dough didn't feel heavy or over flavored. Will def order again.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was tasty! Only disappointment was asking for dry wings, with teriyaki on the side and receiving soy sauce instead!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The food was yummy as always-the only trouble was the online ordering gave me no clue as to when to pick it up.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
They didn't follow directions... bought two meals, one without the optional jalapeños. The box is unchecked by default.I got a meal loaded with jalapeños. $14 down the drain. Boo.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Not Great. I got a small pepperoni pizza & 5 ct Garlic knot with marinara sauce. Total cost $18.90. Pizza sauce was tasty but the crust was floppy. Very greasy. The restaurant namesake Garlic Knots were embarrassing bad. Hard, stale knots with no flavor at all. I picked up my order but from what I could see the kitchen was very messy with an entire raw pizza dough getting stepped on by the staff. +1 star for the sauce but honestly really disappointing since this is so close to my home. Very unlikely I will order from here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3
Grandma pizza and garlic knots always delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5