Mediocre pizza. Its the kind thats really good if you eat there but rubbery by the time you get it home for the family. Poor service though. My credit card entered online didnt work. Bad expuration date or something so they rAn it when i arrived only to tell me they didnt start my pizza until they charged me so wasted another 30 minutes of my time waiting. Apparently there is no pay when picking up option like every other restaurant on the planet. With clIaims of "i tried to call you". Lies. No call text or email. They were just satisfied to let me come in knowing id be pissed. Charging my card BEFORE telling me they hadnt made it yet. Unacceptable, rude, and disrespectful
Bianca Connors
Angeline was an absolute doll, she gave us excellent customer service, her attitude ROCKED, and she was just SWEETER then an italian peach. Angeline's willingness to do whatever it took to make sure we were happy and satisfied was definitely noticed and appreciated. It's the little things that make all the difference. Not only does Anthony's Pizza have the best pizza and (CONNOLIS) in town, they also have a team that takes that extra step to ensure complete satisfaction for their customers! People it doesn't get any better than this lol for real! I also want to give a shout out to one of the pie makers and another member of the team that I unfortunately didn't get their names but THESE guys even came out from behind the kitchen to give us a warm goodbye. I love leaving a restaurant happy and full delicious food !!
Chris Gregorovic
This place has such good pizza! Best I’ve ever had! Reminds me of the big Apple! The manager Kyle is so nice and the cashier ladies were so sweet and helpful! I can’t wait to come back and get more pizza yum yum! Dominos, papa John’s, cosmos, blackjack; all trash compared to this place!
Emily Diana
bf and i always order from anthony’s on doordash when he’s staying out here (he lives in boulder currently) and we are ALWAYS completely happy with the food. they go above and beyond usually. my FAVORITE style of neopolitan pizza, the BEST cannoli’s, and their primo bread? DEVINE!!!!! 100/10 recommend
Cesar Quinones-Moreno
Food was great and very fast service. The tiramisu was the best part also
Ted Block
Order pizza every Friday Amazing service amazing staff Always delicious.TED
Aaron Wix
Really good pie at this place! Definitely remind me of the big apple.
Patricia Padilla
Door Dash delivered a partial and incorrect order. I called Anthony’s and they delivered a totally new order, no problems!
Micah Nelson
They've been on time and consistently delicious for years now. The crust is fantastic. Be sure to give your self-control a pep talk before your pizza(s) arrive!
Lily-Eve Rose
Mia was very helpful, and super friendly. She made the entire experience at Anthony’s 10x better
I have always enjoyed the food here at Anthony’s, but after this past experience not sure I trust them anymore. The amount shown on my credit card receipt and email receipt was less than what was deducted from our Bank Account as I used a debit card.I understand that businesses are struggling, however, they were not able to provide any necessary reason for taking more out of our bank account than what I authorized.I won’t go back, don’t like a place that I cannot trust.
Valerie Eastman
Pizza was done quite a bit later than promised (first world problem), but I am still giving five stars.A) Because the pizza was freaking delicious and perfect in every way when it did get to me, andB) The staff were so gracious and mature despite their youth. Way more mature than the handful of vocal customers 30+ yrs their senior trying to crowd at the register, being terrible over late pizza the first day of the reinstated stricter COVID rules. I hope that those abusive folks change their ways, and realize how unhelpful it is to treat kids poorly who are just trying their best during a Friday pizza rush. In a pandemic. During a stressful election.As for the staff, I hope they know there are customers who appreciate them. They did way better than I would. Well done, Anthony's! I will definitely be back!
Tiffanie Hutcheson
Super disappointed in the Sicilian crust. Good amount of cheese though. Not enough sauce. Check out arte in Loveland.
Andrew Savage
Placed a to-go order online. Showed up after 15 minutes and was told it would take another 5 minutes to be prepared. After 5 minutes I went back to the counter and was told it would be another 7 minutes so I decided to wait in my car. After 7 more minutes I went back inside and was informed nothing was ready and it would be at least 15 more minutes. At this point I told them to cancel my order and I went to eat someplace else. I worked in food service for over 12 years of my life and never once treated a customer like that. This was the most rediculous expierence in the realm of getting to-go food. Everyone in that place needs fired and replaced with some actual good employees.
Jaime White
I really like the pizza. I don’t love the customer service. We recently moved from Longmont to Niwot and have ordered pizza to be delivered on several occasions, including YESTERDAY. One of my boys wanted pizza again today and I was told “we don’t deliver to Niwot and we haven’t in a long time.” Sounds like someone just doesn’t want to deliver to Niwot tonight. Here’s a pic of the box from yesterday that’s still sitting on my counter!?
Mediocre pizza. Its the kind thats really good if you eat there but rubbery by the time you get it home for the family. Poor service though. My credit card entered online didnt work. Bad expuration date or something so they rAn it when i arrived only to tell me they didnt start my pizza until they charged me so wasted another 30 minutes of my time waiting. Apparently there is no pay when picking up option like every other restaurant on the planet. With clIaims of "i tried to call you". Lies. No call text or email. They were just satisfied to let me come in knowing id be pissed. Charging my card BEFORE telling me they hadnt made it yet. Unacceptable, rude, and disrespectful
Angeline was an absolute doll, she gave us excellent customer service, her attitude ROCKED, and she was just SWEETER then an italian peach. Angeline's willingness to do whatever it took to make sure we were happy and satisfied was definitely noticed and appreciated. It's the little things that make all the difference. Not only does Anthony's Pizza have the best pizza and (CONNOLIS) in town, they also have a team that takes that extra step to ensure complete satisfaction for their customers! People it doesn't get any better than this lol for real! I also want to give a shout out to one of the pie makers and another member of the team that I unfortunately didn't get their names but THESE guys even came out from behind the kitchen to give us a warm goodbye. I love leaving a restaurant happy and full delicious food !!
This place has such good pizza! Best I’ve ever had! Reminds me of the big Apple! The manager Kyle is so nice and the cashier ladies were so sweet and helpful! I can’t wait to come back and get more pizza yum yum! Dominos, papa John’s, cosmos, blackjack; all trash compared to this place!
bf and i always order from anthony’s on doordash when he’s staying out here (he lives in boulder currently) and we are ALWAYS completely happy with the food. they go above and beyond usually. my FAVORITE style of neopolitan pizza, the BEST cannoli’s, and their primo bread? DEVINE!!!!! 100/10 recommend
Food was great and very fast service. The tiramisu was the best part also
Order pizza every Friday Amazing service amazing staff Always delicious.TED
Really good pie at this place! Definitely remind me of the big apple.
Door Dash delivered a partial and incorrect order. I called Anthony’s and they delivered a totally new order, no problems!
They've been on time and consistently delicious for years now. The crust is fantastic. Be sure to give your self-control a pep talk before your pizza(s) arrive!
Mia was very helpful, and super friendly. She made the entire experience at Anthony’s 10x better
Restaurantji Recommends
I have always enjoyed the food here at Anthony’s, but after this past experience not sure I trust them anymore. The amount shown on my credit card receipt and email receipt was less than what was deducted from our Bank Account as I used a debit card.I understand that businesses are struggling, however, they were not able to provide any necessary reason for taking more out of our bank account than what I authorized.I won’t go back, don’t like a place that I cannot trust.
Pizza was done quite a bit later than promised (first world problem), but I am still giving five stars.A) Because the pizza was freaking delicious and perfect in every way when it did get to me, andB) The staff were so gracious and mature despite their youth. Way more mature than the handful of vocal customers 30+ yrs their senior trying to crowd at the register, being terrible over late pizza the first day of the reinstated stricter COVID rules. I hope that those abusive folks change their ways, and realize how unhelpful it is to treat kids poorly who are just trying their best during a Friday pizza rush. In a pandemic. During a stressful election.As for the staff, I hope they know there are customers who appreciate them. They did way better than I would. Well done, Anthony's! I will definitely be back!
Super disappointed in the Sicilian crust. Good amount of cheese though. Not enough sauce. Check out arte in Loveland.
Placed a to-go order online. Showed up after 15 minutes and was told it would take another 5 minutes to be prepared. After 5 minutes I went back to the counter and was told it would be another 7 minutes so I decided to wait in my car. After 7 more minutes I went back inside and was informed nothing was ready and it would be at least 15 more minutes. At this point I told them to cancel my order and I went to eat someplace else. I worked in food service for over 12 years of my life and never once treated a customer like that. This was the most rediculous expierence in the realm of getting to-go food. Everyone in that place needs fired and replaced with some actual good employees.
I really like the pizza. I don’t love the customer service. We recently moved from Longmont to Niwot and have ordered pizza to be delivered on several occasions, including YESTERDAY. One of my boys wanted pizza again today and I was told “we don’t deliver to Niwot and we haven’t in a long time.” Sounds like someone just doesn’t want to deliver to Niwot tonight. Here’s a pic of the box from yesterday that’s still sitting on my counter!?