Upper Crust Bagel Co

197 Sound Beach Ave, Old Greenwich
(203) 698-0079

Recent Reviews

Clyde Williams

If you want a cracked egg? Look elsewhere, egg was made in a microwave. Self serve coffee. You're better off at Dunkins down the street.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Bacon Egg and Cheese

Sonii B

I was walking around the area and needed to eat something. I wasn’t sure due to other reviews and it was about an hour before closing. I was pleasantly surprised with the service and my order. The bagel tasted fresh and the sandwich was amply filled. I decided to eat in as there were plenty of tables and it was very clean. If you go earlier in the day, there’s an excellent selection to choose from. Thank you.Parking: It’s within a very short walk to Metro North… they also have parking in the commuter rail station.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sandwiches

Devin A.

Ordered a rainbow bagel and received a plain bagel instead. The egg is cheap microwaved egg and the bacon was stone cold, not worth spending the money on a breakfast here when you can go across the street to Dunkin and get better breakfast. Service was okay but not great.

Shaun Fedrick

Awesome bagels highly recommend it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kurt Studer

Best bagels in the

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Jennifer J.

Ordered a chicken wrap, it wasn't good & was the smallest wrap I've ever been served. Ordered a bagel with egg & cheese, the egg is microwaved... not good overall, wouldn't return.

Andy Sikou

Great local place for coffee , bagels, salad etc , good food and quick

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Nicole A.

I LOVE LOVE LOVE THEIR BAGELS. coming from a NY-er this is a huge compliment as we are a picky crew for bagels. Their bagels are lightly crispy on the outside and somewhat soft and gooey on the inside. Always fresh. The deducted star is for the fact that people come in here early hours and they run out of egg and multigrain everything's SO FAST. They're so good. At this point they should be making more. Either way, I'll continue to go here because the bagels are amazing. Egg salad was fresh but a bit bland, cream cheese is fine. This is primarily for their bagels which are delish

Sammi F.

This is really unreal. When I say unreal I mean UNREAL. I ordered and it looked like plastic food from a children's store.

Evan Brois

A lot of times when people say a restaurant has the worst food they’ve ever eaten usually isn’t true, and they tend to have recency bias. I took my time before coming here and writing this review and I can genuinely say this is the most disgusting bagel place I’ve ever come across in all my years of existence. the eggs taste like plastic dipped in wax. They microwave their eggs ( I called and confirmed this with an employee) they also microwave their bacon. The effort they put into making their food is so lackluster you could not only taste it, but you can see it.the food is genuinely not edible. If you were on an abandoned island and had nothing to eat, you would probably be better off eating sand and dirt than eating from this establishment.I doubt many people will see this but if I can save one person from stepping into this establishment and giving them a penny of your hard earned money then its a success.

Food: 1

Nina L.

The BLT on a plain bagel was incredible! The bagel was perfectly toasted and soft in the middle. The bacon was crisp to perfection and lettuce was crunchy. Just a great sandwich. I also go an iced cappuccino and an almond croissant that was superb as well!

Brian Krasik

Bagels are fine, slowest service I’ve seen from a bagel shop. Poor experience overall. Not to mention, employees using their bare hands to grab the bagels.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 1

Nicole Kurzbard Roach

Careful if you order online. Food wasn’t there, two employees rolled their eyes at me and both said they made it and it “must have been taken off the shelves.” They refused to pull up the online order and stalled until I asked either for a refund or for them to remake it. They begrudgingly remade it and stuffed four sandwiches into a tiny bag (smaller than all of the other big bags on the takeout shelves) that of course ripped before we made it out the door. No idea if the food is any good. The service is just terrible.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Gretchen Bowen

It must be the most popular place in town! They are busy. Bagels are outstanding!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sarah

They don’t answer the phone and every time we go there to order our order is wrong.

Load More