great food and service. maybe a bit pricey but as expected.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael J.
Great Food and Drinks one of the best NY Strip steak i have ever had! a little pricey but worth it for a great dinner. Very friendly Staff!
Mark K.
We have been to Prime On whitfield two times and every time we got the tomahawk steak for two - delicious outstanding. There is one thing that I hope the chef will consider changing the presentation. Currently the stake is sliced, but the bone is just laid over the plate. We would prefer to have the steak sliced and then put back in to where it was cut from in the steak just a little bit better presentation.
Sengtawunh D.
Visited on a Friday night with a party of 5, while it was busy we were (thankfully) seated in an area where it was somewhat quiet and intimate. I liked the environment- very modern yet cozy. I forgot the name of the drink that I had (something with Ex Husband in the name) which was essentially a jalapeño margarita. It was good, definitely tasted the jalapeño, loved the balance that the tajin rim gave, I personally wished it was a little sweeter but that's just my preference. For my appetizer I decided to order 6 Wellfleet oysters. I highly enjoy them and was excited to have them but the oysters served were definitely not fresh. As soon as the platter was dropped at the table I could tell they weren't fresh from the color. A bit disappointing. For my meal I had the salmon with lemon dijon (the salmon can be prepared in 5 different ways). I enjoyed my meal, all components were enjoyable (mashed potatoes were delish!!). Overall this is a decent place, the service was great, food was good. The pricing on the menu is more high end but I'm not sure if the price is equivalent to the quality of food.
Glenn Laudenslager
Excellent food and solid, attentive service. Nice place right on the green, easy to find and park.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jelena Ćurčić
Everything is absolutely perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessie F.
A special occasion sort of restaurant so it appears however the ridiculous prices for the food served is over the top. If you're running a steak house with the lowest cost steak at $52, chefs should know how to cook them. Two steaks served for my meal and both not cooked correctly. Food was salty, fish was incredibly tough, and the drinks were average. The baked potato was over the top, too much stuff, and way too salty. The chowder in the bread bowl was the only saving grace and all we ate as 3 meals had to be returned and not eaten. Place has a cool vibe but it's loud and pretentious. Good food doesn't have to be so fancy and expensive. This place is not worth the crazy price tag. I will say despite it being busy, the staff were genuinely sorry about the problems with our food and we didn't pay for the meals. Too bad we couldn't enjoy it.
Michailah Williams
First time!!We were in Guilford for the day and we stopped by here to have a couple of drinks.Calming and clean atmosphere.The bar seats maybe 12/13, there are tables as well.There is also a bar-like seating area behind the bar, that seats maybe six people.The bartender, Heidi was great!!She is the bartender that you want to have for a laugh, to listen if you need to talk, she was staying pretty busy - as the bar was full.Overall she had a great presence and I will definitely stop by to see her again, when I Guilford ?I saw a couple of dishes served and they looked really appetizing. We ate before we got there.Next visit I would like to try a food item.I was with a friend and we both ordered the Lindoo And it was really good. A very well-made drink.We were there for a couple of hours and we finished our visit with Heidi's specialty, and Espresso Martini... All I can finish off with is yum yum yum ?The bathroom was super clean and I definitely appreciated that.I was also given a cool little rubber ducky because it was my birthday ❤️Thank you again Heidi for everything!!You rock!Parking: I'm really not sure about the parking. This business is on a street next to other businesses. And we walked from the train station, so we did not need parking.I did see street parking and there is a lot in the back.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Miconi
It was a Lil loud but food and service was amazing. Steak was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Big E Baked Potato
Mark Fezza
A little on the pricier side but great food. The French Onion Soup was delicious.
My husband and I love the steak here. Some of the other dishes are hit or miss. Traditional steakhouse items are well done (Cobb salad, mashed potatoes, etc). Large portions and good service. Cocktails are OK and wine selection isn't the best so we typically bring our own and do corkage.
Anna L.
The food was delicious and the atmosphere warm and inviting. The scallop appetizer was huge! And my steak was perfectly cooked. A great special occasion place.
Jim Henkel
Food and Service was amazing! Very delicious menu!
Best steak and burger we’ve had so far on the shoreline. I got the 22oz prime rib, daughter got a burger, wife got a filet mignon and all were fantastic. I got the lobster chowder in bread bowl and it was ludicrously good. We got chips and guacamole as well and it was fantastic. Nice atmosphere, great beer selection, and the historic Guilford green is beautiful and quaint. I MASSIVELY recommend.
great food and service. maybe a bit pricey but as expected.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Food and Drinks one of the best NY Strip steak i have ever had! a little pricey but worth it for a great dinner. Very friendly Staff!
We have been to Prime On whitfield two times and every time we got the tomahawk steak for two - delicious outstanding. There is one thing that I hope the chef will consider changing the presentation. Currently the stake is sliced, but the bone is just laid over the plate. We would prefer to have the steak sliced and then put back in to where it was cut from in the steak just a little bit better presentation.
Visited on a Friday night with a party of 5, while it was busy we were (thankfully) seated in an area where it was somewhat quiet and intimate. I liked the environment- very modern yet cozy. I forgot the name of the drink that I had (something with Ex Husband in the name) which was essentially a jalapeño margarita. It was good, definitely tasted the jalapeño, loved the balance that the tajin rim gave, I personally wished it was a little sweeter but that's just my preference. For my appetizer I decided to order 6 Wellfleet oysters. I highly enjoy them and was excited to have them but the oysters served were definitely not fresh. As soon as the platter was dropped at the table I could tell they weren't fresh from the color. A bit disappointing. For my meal I had the salmon with lemon dijon (the salmon can be prepared in 5 different ways). I enjoyed my meal, all components were enjoyable (mashed potatoes were delish!!). Overall this is a decent place, the service was great, food was good. The pricing on the menu is more high end but I'm not sure if the price is equivalent to the quality of food.
Excellent food and solid, attentive service. Nice place right on the green, easy to find and park.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything is absolutely perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A special occasion sort of restaurant so it appears however the ridiculous prices for the food served is over the top. If you're running a steak house with the lowest cost steak at $52, chefs should know how to cook them. Two steaks served for my meal and both not cooked correctly. Food was salty, fish was incredibly tough, and the drinks were average. The baked potato was over the top, too much stuff, and way too salty. The chowder in the bread bowl was the only saving grace and all we ate as 3 meals had to be returned and not eaten. Place has a cool vibe but it's loud and pretentious. Good food doesn't have to be so fancy and expensive. This place is not worth the crazy price tag. I will say despite it being busy, the staff were genuinely sorry about the problems with our food and we didn't pay for the meals. Too bad we couldn't enjoy it.
First time!!We were in Guilford for the day and we stopped by here to have a couple of drinks.Calming and clean atmosphere.The bar seats maybe 12/13, there are tables as well.There is also a bar-like seating area behind the bar, that seats maybe six people.The bartender, Heidi was great!!She is the bartender that you want to have for a laugh, to listen if you need to talk, she was staying pretty busy - as the bar was full.Overall she had a great presence and I will definitely stop by to see her again, when I Guilford ?I saw a couple of dishes served and they looked really appetizing. We ate before we got there.Next visit I would like to try a food item.I was with a friend and we both ordered the Lindoo And it was really good. A very well-made drink.We were there for a couple of hours and we finished our visit with Heidi's specialty, and Espresso Martini... All I can finish off with is yum yum yum ?The bathroom was super clean and I definitely appreciated that.I was also given a cool little rubber ducky because it was my birthday ❤️Thank you again Heidi for everything!!You rock!Parking: I'm really not sure about the parking. This business is on a street next to other businesses. And we walked from the train station, so we did not need parking.I did see street parking and there is a lot in the back.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
It was a Lil loud but food and service was amazing. Steak was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Big E Baked Potato
A little on the pricier side but great food. The French Onion Soup was delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Over priced for what it is. Food is just OK.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
My husband and I love the steak here. Some of the other dishes are hit or miss. Traditional steakhouse items are well done (Cobb salad, mashed potatoes, etc). Large portions and good service. Cocktails are OK and wine selection isn't the best so we typically bring our own and do corkage.
The food was delicious and the atmosphere warm and inviting. The scallop appetizer was huge! And my steak was perfectly cooked. A great special occasion place.
Food and Service was amazing! Very delicious menu!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roasted Garlic Whipped Potatoes, Bistro Truffle Fries, Garlic Roasted Vegetables, Buffalo Cauliflower, Scallop Appetizer, Crème Brulee
Best steak and burger we’ve had so far on the shoreline. I got the 22oz prime rib, daughter got a burger, wife got a filet mignon and all were fantastic. I got the lobster chowder in bread bowl and it was ludicrously good. We got chips and guacamole as well and it was fantastic. Nice atmosphere, great beer selection, and the historic Guilford green is beautiful and quaint. I MASSIVELY recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prime Salad