Creative Cakes By Donna

1565 Saybrook Rd, Haddam
(860) 345-8847

Recent Reviews

Brittany Bandani

Donna was fabulous to work with - she listened and gave us exactly what we envisioned! The samples she provided were delicious, and we were able to mix and match certain flavors to create a unique and memorable wedding cake. Our guests all loved it, and so did we!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

David Amaral

Our wedding cake was absolutely perfect! The guests loved it and so did our coworkers following the wedding! Thank you Donna!!

Sarah Schwartz

I highly recommend Donna's cakes! We worked with her for our August 2023 wedding. We chose a vanilla cake with a strawberry mousse filling with fresh strawberry. Multiple wedding guests have commented on how delicious the cake was! I have to say I agree. It was light after a big wedding meal and simply delicious. It was also very pretty with fresh flowers and nice piping. Donna was responsive and easy to work with. I would recommend!

Kaylee DiBianco

If I could give this 0 stars I would. This woman is extremely unprofessional. At my best friends wedding she told the wedding coordinator that she was 15 minutes away… 20 minutes later she still had not shown up. Called again and now she was 10 minutes away. After those 10 minutes the phone began to go straight to voicemail. This woman has absolutely no consideration for anyone. Very unprofessional and rude.

Shaela Salinger

The cake was included with our venue, but Donna did a beautiful and tasteful job! We met once with her in person, and she was able to create exactly what I was envisioning based off a few inspiration pictures. She gave us a plate of different bases and icings so we could try a variety of variations which was both fun and yummy! The cake was delicious and perfectly light/refreshing after dinner.

Kaylee Sue

This woman is extremely unprofessional. My best friend was married August 5th. She had ordered a cake from this woman and she NEVER SHOWED UP TO THE WEDDING. The wedding coordinator called her and she claimed to be 15 minutes away… 20 minutes later she still had not shown up. She called again and told her she was 10 minutes away. After that she turned off her phone so she didn’t have to answer to anyone. She had no consideration for my best friend on her WEDDING DAY. Absolutely horrible service. She is shady and will take your money.

Megan Carlo

Donna’s cake was amazing! All our guests loved our wedding cake and could not stop talking about how delicious it was! Donna was great to work with and captured exactly what we wanted for our wedding cake. I was blown away with how beautiful it came out, we loved it!

Dan Weiner

Donna was a joy to work with. She is a true professional. You can tell why she is such a trusted person when it comes to wedding cakes. She was easy to communicate with and was one of the venue’s preferred vendors and you can tell why from the taste of the cake and the process that went into getting it made.She gave us plenty of options to choose from. The cake tasting was a lot of fun. She gave us several different cake and filling flavors to take home and try. Everything was customizable and delicious. We had an almond cake with raspberry buttercream filling and pearl encrusted designs on it and the cake was executed exactly as we envisioned and was delicious!

Daniel W.

Donna was a joy to work with. She is a true professional. You can tell why she is such a trusted person when it comes to wedding cakes. She was easy to communicate with and was one of the venue's preferred vendors and you can tell why from the taste of the cake and the process that went into getting it made.She gave us plenty of options to choose from. The cake tasting was a lot of fun. She gave us several different cake and filling flavors to take home and try. Everything was customizable and delicious. We had an almond cake with raspberry buttercream filling and pearl encrusted designs on it and the cake was executed exactly as we envisioned and was delicious!

Caitlin A

Donna's cake was delicious and BEAUTIFUL! Our guests just loved how it tasted and had nothing but great things to say. Donna was a pleasure to work with and gave multiple tasting options to choose from. She took some designs we had and brought them to life in a simple but elegant design. We were also able to get GF cupcakes to add for our guests with allergies. (Cake flavor chosen: vanilla cake, strawberry cream & fresh strawberries)

Terrence Irving

Donna makes great cakes! I am a CT wedding photographer and have had the pleasure of photographing her work at least a couple of times now. The couples (and guests) always love Donna's creations. Highly recommended!

Marisa

Our wedding cake came out beautiful! When we had our tasting, we received a nice array of cakes and frosting to try. Our cake came out gorgeous! Highly recommend

Debi Levi-Attwood

Extraordinary and scrumptious! Donna went out of her way to make sure our occasion was special. The cake was pretty and delicious down to each carefully created detail. She genuinely cares about people and making them happy.

Kevin Venturini

Donna did our cake for our wedding at the Society Room and I couldn’t be happier. It was delicious and beautiful. Donna was a joy to work with ??️‍?

Jim Tomlinson

Donna was so good to work with in designing our wedding cake (we got connected through the Pond House where we had our wedding). The cake came out beautiful, was so delicious and folks really enjoyed it. Thanks Donna!

Load More