I am not usually disappointed by Big Cheese but tonight I was. My pizza was stone cold. I even gave the driver a 2.00 tip. I will never do that again.
Kenny K.
I always come here for lunch break at least once a week for pizza slices, good variety & fresh. When I order to go it is always the pepperoni with onions pizza which I love. I can't speak on their other food, I only get their pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Kali Sandy
Great prices, even better food!I am from CA, visiting friends in CT for a short time. I like to try a new local food place for each meal, and usually don't "double dip." Big Cheese was so good, I had to get it a second time to try more of the menu!! If you're a traveller like me, I highly recommend their gyros, grinders, and chicken picata :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gyro
Shaquille Jessop
I’d eat here everyday if I lived closer. Best slice I’ve had in a while. Cheese was cheesing. Pizza melted in my mouth. Good work
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William E. Ricks
Pizza-wise, this is up there as some of the best in Middletown. I love the thick dough and crust, that's how you make a strong and delicious pizza! Cheese is even, tasty and the perfect amount of stringiness. The sauce is flavorful and not too overbearing... perfectly complimentary. All in all, a fantastic pie! The price for the pie wasn't expensive either, much more favorable than other top-tier spots.Very mom and pop vibes, which is great. Small interior, so you may want to consider takeout. The location isn't bad and has some parking. Will definitely visit more as one of the better spots in this area.Parking: Mini lot in front of storefront
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Large Pizza With, Pepperoni Pizza, Large Pizza
Rj Daniels
Best grinder I ever had
David Rinaldi
Best pepperoni and anchovies pizza in Middletown. No comparison, the best!!. If you are a fan of this combo of pizza combination, you won't be
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Large Pizza
Seshubabu Challagolla
One of the best pizzas, I have ever had.. Thank you BIG Cheese.. Yummy ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza With, Wings
Shelly M.
When they first opened I'd give them 3 stars but now 1 is too much. The pizza is old and smells like feet. These people can't even speak good English so how are they going to take a custom order the way I like it. They asked me if the whole pizza was for me or not? I told em that's none of their business. They are rude and use cheap ingredients. I know good food and it ain't here.
Ellen M.
I called to place an order for a pizza delivery and when the phone was answered it sounded like someone just grunted. I ask if if was Big Cheese and the response was "What do you want", I let him know what I wanted and the response was "Give me your number". I said I'll call back and hung up. I don't care how much I like the food from any restaurant hospitality is a very big part of service. Rude. I thought I'll speak to the owner instead of leaving a review and called 2 days later. The same employee answered the phone. I asked to speak to the owner, the reply "Who are you", gave my name, he's here but he's too busy to talk to you he's making a pizza. Called Empire Pizza, very personable, and will never order from Big Cheese again.
They lied and added 10 more dollars to my card and told me one thing. Good thing instinct kicked in I checked my card. Canceled order. Calling my cars now to cancel them ... ew. I
Wendy Leenders
I ordered a pizza in the grinder tonight. The pizza is amazing my husband loved the grinder the driver we had with a great personality I really liked him I wish I would have gotten his name really cool guy thank you big cheese for always being Amazing after many
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza
Giselle
Beat cheese pizza i had in middletown honestly dont know any better ones i always go right after work or in middle of work n my client loves this pizza place . Great job n great infredients pizza not too saucy or hard at all ????
Kahlil D.
Poor service and rude delivery drivers. Delivery driver showed up with my delivery. Flat out asked for a tip. I believe that is rude. Then when I told him "here a tip don't ask for one " They fagged my phone number and said I can't order there any more. Don't worry you not the only place in town and I will never order there again
I am not usually disappointed by Big Cheese but tonight I was. My pizza was stone cold. I even gave the driver a 2.00 tip. I will never do that again.
I always come here for lunch break at least once a week for pizza slices, good variety & fresh. When I order to go it is always the pepperoni with onions pizza which I love. I can't speak on their other food, I only get their pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great prices, even better food!I am from CA, visiting friends in CT for a short time. I like to try a new local food place for each meal, and usually don't "double dip." Big Cheese was so good, I had to get it a second time to try more of the menu!! If you're a traveller like me, I highly recommend their gyros, grinders, and chicken picata :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gyro
I’d eat here everyday if I lived closer. Best slice I’ve had in a while. Cheese was cheesing. Pizza melted in my mouth. Good work
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza-wise, this is up there as some of the best in Middletown. I love the thick dough and crust, that's how you make a strong and delicious pizza! Cheese is even, tasty and the perfect amount of stringiness. The sauce is flavorful and not too overbearing... perfectly complimentary. All in all, a fantastic pie! The price for the pie wasn't expensive either, much more favorable than other top-tier spots.Very mom and pop vibes, which is great. Small interior, so you may want to consider takeout. The location isn't bad and has some parking. Will definitely visit more as one of the better spots in this area.Parking: Mini lot in front of storefront
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage, Large Pizza With, Pepperoni Pizza, Large Pizza
Best grinder I ever had
Best pepperoni and anchovies pizza in Middletown. No comparison, the best!!. If you are a fan of this combo of pizza combination, you won't be
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Large Pizza
One of the best pizzas, I have ever had.. Thank you BIG Cheese.. Yummy ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza With, Wings
When they first opened I'd give them 3 stars but now 1 is too much. The pizza is old and smells like feet. These people can't even speak good English so how are they going to take a custom order the way I like it. They asked me if the whole pizza was for me or not? I told em that's none of their business. They are rude and use cheap ingredients. I know good food and it ain't here.
I called to place an order for a pizza delivery and when the phone was answered it sounded like someone just grunted. I ask if if was Big Cheese and the response was "What do you want", I let him know what I wanted and the response was "Give me your number". I said I'll call back and hung up. I don't care how much I like the food from any restaurant hospitality is a very big part of service. Rude. I thought I'll speak to the owner instead of leaving a review and called 2 days later. The same employee answered the phone. I asked to speak to the owner, the reply "Who are you", gave my name, he's here but he's too busy to talk to you he's making a pizza. Called Empire Pizza, very personable, and will never order from Big Cheese again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best grinders all food in
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They lied and added 10 more dollars to my card and told me one thing. Good thing instinct kicked in I checked my card. Canceled order. Calling my cars now to cancel them ... ew. I
I ordered a pizza in the grinder tonight. The pizza is amazing my husband loved the grinder the driver we had with a great personality I really liked him I wish I would have gotten his name really cool guy thank you big cheese for always being Amazing after many
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Pizza
Beat cheese pizza i had in middletown honestly dont know any better ones i always go right after work or in middle of work n my client loves this pizza place . Great job n great infredients pizza not too saucy or hard at all ????
Poor service and rude delivery drivers. Delivery driver showed up with my delivery. Flat out asked for a tip. I believe that is rude. Then when I told him "here a tip don't ask for one " They fagged my phone number and said I can't order there any more. Don't worry you not the only place in town and I will never order there again