Conspiracy

350 Main St, Middletown
(860) 236-0211

Recent Reviews

Andrew Warzocha

Wonderful drinks with a fun atmosphere. Staff was very friendly with recommendations and helped us find a drink. A little rough for big groups but we didn't have any issues. Would recommend as a place to hang late in the evening.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Valbatrax

Came to celebrate my girlfriends birthday. Conspiracy has themed drink menus that they go all out on. The flavors of the drinks and food are distinct and a delight. I absolutely recomend coming here for a great time.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 3 Cheese Plate, Buttermilk Waffle Late Night

Joseph smith

This place is always great. The menu is small but everything is delicious. The drinks are awesome. It's a small place, so you might not get a seat, planning a head and calling ahead may pay

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Campfire Old Fashion

Coach Warren

Been here numerous times, usually a pleasant experience. Had reservations for 8:30 made a week in advance. Showes up with a birthday party of 10 and was told we were bumped? Was there the phone number we gave was incorrect however it was confirmed 3 times on the phone. Hostess rude and unocomidating. Place is going downhill, sister company white dog closed recently, with this service I expect this won't last long...its a shame was once a great place. Plus as a party of 4 we got charged a gratuity fee, sure it was because the service was horrible.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 1

Kim D.

It's great. Nice people. Interesting drinks Awesome place. Very creative. Check out the Folio reading event. Great supportive crowd

Ken M.

So sad, used to love it here, place has changed since Covid, used to have best staff, no more.... Had reservations we were told when we got there we were pushed back a half hour. Service was okay at best... Miss old crew, change is not always good...

Cierrah M.

The drinks were good, we got the campfire old fashioned. The chicken sliders were also good, had a bit of spice to it which I enjoyed. And the ambience was super cool! Dark lighting and unique glassware made the experience very different!

Keena O.

I really enjoyed this spot. Almost couldn't find it as there's no real signage outside. It is dark, as others have mentioned. But it definitely helps with the vibe. The little book they have the drink menu in is so cute! The man who took our order was very kind & had no issues making me a great mocktail! Very delicious. We had pulled chicken sliders, which were lemon pepper wet with some type of slaw. A little spicy, which usually is not my thing, but I liked these. It's served with kettle cooked chips. Overall, I would definitely go back!

Patricia Bouleyb

Not impressed with the staff - person who greeted us was not very friendly and we felt like our presence was a great imposition Unfortunately we did not have reservations but were allowed to sit at the bar - we were told at least 6 times by various staff that we could only stay for an hour which wewere agreeable to. We did order food at the bar but had to ask for utensils- never got plates, we just ate out of the same dish. Apparently you need a reservation to actually get a dish and a glass of water.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Gi Joe Chatham (Gi Joe)

Loved the place and the ambiance. Kimchi nachos and the drinks were bomb!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Paul Noren

Really cool speak easy. Casual and chill atmosphere. The old fashioned with the charred marshmallow was fantastic as were the apps.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Campfire Old Fashion

Nate B.

Went for New Year's Eve when they had a special cocktail pairing menu. Both the food and drinks were very good. A little behind in service that night (our server, who was working very hard, mentioned being understaffed--tonight on a holiday).

sharanya p

Love this bar and the vibe going on thereJay is an amazing bartender, He made some exceptional cocktails ?❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Hoosieronthemove

This was my second time coming here this year, and I’m in love. I knew they have a tarot card deck of drinks and I finally got to try one. The drink I got tasted just like a fluffernutter and let me tell you, I would have ordered like 3 of this if I didn’t have to drive home, they were so tasty.Love the ambiance in here, they have really good bites to eat as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 3 Cheese Plate, Mac and Cheese, Sliders, Campfire Old Fashion, Campfire Old Fashioned

Gary N.

Feels like a speakeasy loved

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Load More