Mario's pizza and restaurant

455 E Main St, Middletown
(860) 788-7850

Recent Reviews

Javaun Haughton

This is my second time ordering from Mario’s and I have to say if I could give it a 10 star rating I would.The food was absolutely amazing and the service was top notch. This will forever be my go to when I’m craving pizza or wings?, truly a wonderful place. Thank you Eddie and Mario❤️

Dingo7

Just got a cheese pizza (I wanted something quick) and I'd say that their cheese is actually pretty good! Obviously not the best in the world, but its certainly exceptional for the price. Family operated, and the person inside was very nice and polite. I would definitely recommend if anyone is in the area and looking for somethingto eat.

Patricia Cronenberg

The Pizzas were absolutely delicious, and Our Son loved the Macaroni and Cheese bites. Wonderful customer service and friendly People. We will definitely be back in the near future.??

dina k

we ordered pizza here, it was delicious and the place looks clean and cozy inside. Workers were friendly, this place is like a hidden gem! they offer a variety of food, definitely recommend

Team Johnson

1 hour 30 minutes later he after yelling at me, "mario". Returns my money after fussing his driver out also and the driver quit with my food in the car!!! The caucasiity of him to yell at me and the driver because he wants the business but can't handle the demand. Not worth the over pricing!

Courtney Turner

Worst service I’ve had in a long time. Only giving one star because I have to. Ordered food at 6 didn’t receive my order until 7:20 when they said it would be 30 minutes. Food was cold and soggy and I learned from the owner that if we ate in the restaurant the food would be fresh and that the driver had a delivery 30 minutes from me and that’s why my food was cold. I was missing items that I ordered and the driver took off with my change without even asking if I was giving him a tip. The owner then says he’s new and the only person he can get to due to people living off of the government. Like that’s my problem???? Never again will I order from this place!

Nana-Kyi Acosta

Great pizza, garlic knots, sandwiches, fries, onion rings and wraps, oh and the desserts are good too! The owner is kind, personable, knows you by name and prices are excellent. Even my son, Gio who eats about 10 things LOVES Mario's. Mario's definitely knows how to treat their patrons!

Derek Mandeville

ILLEGAL COMPANY PAYING WORKERS UNDER THE TABLE, HE BLACKMALES HIS EMPLOYEES SO THEY SO WHAT HE SAYS. TERRIBLE FOOD AND FOOD QUALITY. MOST OF THE MEATS ARE EXPIRED, THE DRESSINGS ARE DISGUSTING AND HE DOESNT WASH HIS HANDS AFTER THE BATHROOM. TERRIBLE TERRIBLE PLACE. DO NOT EAT HERE, AS IT WILL BE CLOSING MOMENTARILY.

Doreen Armetta

There have been mistakes with our orders in the past, but to be fair, Mario’s has tried to make things right. But not tonight. Food was missing from our delivery order, which we were told would arrive shortly with another driver. My granddaughter’s meal was completely missing. The pizza was barely warm. The eggplant rolatini was cool and rubbery. We had to call the restaurant to inquire about the missing food and were told it would arrive any minute. When it got here, it was ice cold. I’m assuming it was the food that remained sitting on their counter for 45 minutes. It was loaded with pepper and the fries were like plastic. Never ordering from them again. If I could give negative stars I would.

Tammie Thompson

I had gotten a buffalo chicken pizza. It was absolutely delicious!! This was my first time ordering at Mario's. I even had to call the restaurant back and say thank you.

Alesha Coote

Very very delicious I ordered Pepperoni pizza and Buffalo wings and everything was On Point!!!! 10 across the board!! The customer service is Excellent!! Very cozy atmosphere highly recommend for all cuisine!!

Dan Scrivener

I like to order the Chicken parmigiana dinner. To me it’s one of the best values on the menu. The same meal at most other places will be $4 more. The one complaint I do have is about 50 percent of the time they don’t bring my soda. Then they only come back with it about 50 percent of that time. One night I ordered and did not bring the whole meal lol if they get that straightened out it would be great!!! I got a refund on the last soda today through slice but I am still down at least 2 that I didn’t bother complaining about

Rj Acosta

Amazing and fast service with good people there. Great pizza hot or cold.

S Brister

I absolutely love Mario’s food and their customer service. They are always friendly, know us on a first name basis and are just an all around great business. I highly recommend!

Jenn W.

After 1.5 hours AFTER placing our order and many attempts at calling and just getting a busy signal, they finally answer and immediately put us on hold. It's currently been over 20 minutes on hold while listening to them just take other customers orders. Not sure how this even ends since I'm writing as it's happening. Honestly would just like a refund at this point. Absolutely horrible management. Never again Mario's!

Load More