While on my quest to find the very best of New Haven style apizza, I was directed to Papa's Pizza II by numerous group members. All of the advice was spot on. Ordered a large white clam and finished it on-site. Crust was perfect - loved the clams & garlic - char was ideal. Easy five stars. Scott & Kim were taking care of business and were a huge complement to my overall experience. Eat in and you'll be a better apizza fan for it.
Mj O.
How pizza is supposed to be! Take out only. Some of the best pizza we ever had! Will definitely order here again and we highly recommend it to everyone that enjoys a perfect thin crust pizza.
Chris M.
This is our go to take out pizza in Milford. New Haven style Apizza and it is legit. Weekends get your orders in early, you won't be disappointed! Also, they have these outrageous meatball subs they call cones.
georgegerasi
Amazing Apizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Geoff Spence
The owner has young kids working there so he can get cheap labor. Mean while, the owner is completely incompetent. I waited 45 minutes after he said my order was ready, and then the owner gave my pizza away to someone else because they screwed up the other customers order. Asked me if I wanted a discount instead of the pizza, but instead I had to wait longer. Pizza is great but management is garbage. Go to the original Papas.
Food: 5
Service: 1
mike olsen
Awesome pizza and amazing service! Owner is very nice and goes above and beyond to make sure you’re happy! Can’t say enough good things about this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frank B.
I ordered two medium pizzas. One white broccoli and garlic and one sausage $50 What a ripoff
Emma G
Some of the best pizza (and the loveliest team!) you can find in Milford. Cannot recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maria L.
It's been our neighborhood takeout pizza place for many years. Always consistently good. The staff is friendly and community involved.
Michael M.
If you blindly ate a pie from here, you’d say New Haven all day long. You cannot get a better pizza in Milford.Tried calling today, the phone was set to ‘busy’ at 3pm. Cmon? Seriously?
Milford, are you kidding me. Do you mean to tell me this GEM of a pizza place exists when I've been going all the way to New Haven all these years. I picked up 7 pizzas today for a birthday party and despite the large order each pie was made perfectly. We got 3 cheese, 2 Roni, a di Rob and a di Madalena. People were raving. Great wood fired crust. The di Madalena was so good it was gone within 5 minutes. The kids loved the cheese and pepperoni, everyone was happy. And the people running this place are so nice - will be back.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lynne F.
Take out only, very friendly staff - was greeted when I walked in. Ordered a large mooz w/ pepperoni and calzone with spinach. Pizza was average to above average, spinach calzone was fair - it came with onion which we didn't order .
Mary S.
We finally got our hands on the Breakfast pizza! It is easily the best pizza in Milford and this pie does not disappoint. It's going eggs, tater tots, bacon and their signature hangover sauce. The crust is perfectly cooked and crispy. It only comes in a small but it was enough to serve the whole family with a side of fruit. You have to preorder or call right at 8 to see if they have any timeslots left but it's well worth the extra planning. We love this place and this pizza!!
While on my quest to find the very best of New Haven style apizza, I was directed to Papa's Pizza II by numerous group members. All of the advice was spot on. Ordered a large white clam and finished it on-site. Crust was perfect - loved the clams & garlic - char was ideal. Easy five stars. Scott & Kim were taking care of business and were a huge complement to my overall experience. Eat in and you'll be a better apizza fan for it.
How pizza is supposed to be! Take out only. Some of the best pizza we ever had! Will definitely order here again and we highly recommend it to everyone that enjoys a perfect thin crust pizza.
This is our go to take out pizza in Milford. New Haven style Apizza and it is legit. Weekends get your orders in early, you won't be disappointed! Also, they have these outrageous meatball subs they call cones.
Amazing Apizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The owner has young kids working there so he can get cheap labor. Mean while, the owner is completely incompetent. I waited 45 minutes after he said my order was ready, and then the owner gave my pizza away to someone else because they screwed up the other customers order. Asked me if I wanted a discount instead of the pizza, but instead I had to wait longer. Pizza is great but management is garbage. Go to the original Papas.
Food: 5
Service: 1
Awesome pizza and amazing service! Owner is very nice and goes above and beyond to make sure you’re happy! Can’t say enough good things about this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered two medium pizzas. One white broccoli and garlic and one sausage $50 What a ripoff
Some of the best pizza (and the loveliest team!) you can find in Milford. Cannot recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's been our neighborhood takeout pizza place for many years. Always consistently good. The staff is friendly and community involved.
If you blindly ate a pie from here, you’d say New Haven all day long. You cannot get a better pizza in Milford.Tried calling today, the phone was set to ‘busy’ at 3pm. Cmon? Seriously?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pizza Plain, Papa
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza I’ve had in a long time!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Papa
Best pizza in Milford without a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Plain, Papa
Milford, are you kidding me. Do you mean to tell me this GEM of a pizza place exists when I've been going all the way to New Haven all these years. I picked up 7 pizzas today for a birthday party and despite the large order each pie was made perfectly. We got 3 cheese, 2 Roni, a di Rob and a di Madalena. People were raving. Great wood fired crust. The di Madalena was so good it was gone within 5 minutes. The kids loved the cheese and pepperoni, everyone was happy. And the people running this place are so nice - will be back.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Take out only, very friendly staff - was greeted when I walked in. Ordered a large mooz w/ pepperoni and calzone with spinach. Pizza was average to above average, spinach calzone was fair - it came with onion which we didn't order .
We finally got our hands on the Breakfast pizza! It is easily the best pizza in Milford and this pie does not disappoint. It's going eggs, tater tots, bacon and their signature hangover sauce. The crust is perfectly cooked and crispy. It only comes in a small but it was enough to serve the whole family with a side of fruit. You have to preorder or call right at 8 to see if they have any timeslots left but it's well worth the extra planning. We love this place and this pizza!!