Waited a while to try this, then kept forgetting about it. No one I knew had tried it so I gave it a go and ordered a Pizza and a cold Caprese sub. The latter was pretty flavorless, not enough cheese, no salt & peeper. Could've used more balsamic or pesto or something. The pizza was very thin, kind of burnt, and flavor was barely meh and lacking something. Would prob not get again as I can't afford to throw away food. But maybe I'll try once more and ask for pizza to NOT be well done and definitely a different sub. Tbh, I'd prob choose Colony Grille over this, especially their amazing salad pizza!
Pizza Efficianado
Glorified English muffin pizza with watered down Prego
Kimberly A.
Terrible. Pizza was ice cold and tasteless the garlic knots came soaked in grease with no sauce. Chicken parm grinder was burnt making the bread inedible. I'm Hoping it was just an off night as this place has such great reviews I'll give it another try as I'm all about supporting local, hopefully it will be a better experience.
James Petrone
Pizza's great. My kids love it.
Diane P.
This is by far the best pizza in Milford..I know everybody raves about pappas but honestly this place blows them out of the water. Pizza is absolutely delicious..perfect crust,sauce and just the right amount of cheese and guess what every time I order its ready in 20 minutes. This is the new hidden gem of walnut beach !!!
Caitlin C.
I'm a New Yorker and this is the only pizza I allow my family to eat in CT- never had a bad pie here. Their pizza is consistent and chicken parm sub was huge and delicious! We LOVE this pizza and the super friendly people who run the place. Pretty outdoor seating, close to the beach, always a warm welcome.
Alec P.
Not sure how to feel on this one. My wife and I ordered two subs, one chicken parm and the other meatball. Also when we tried to order chicken wings the guy said there was a nationwide chicken wing shortage and he didn't have any (is this for real?) Anyways, I inhaled the first half of my meatball sub and it was amazing. My wife struggled to eat her chicken parm one. She said it was dry. I was kind of surprised but I offered to give her the other half of mine and take her chicken parm leftover. And well, I made a huge mistake because the chicken parm was inedible for me. The meat was tough and dry and I threw the rest away. I guess it's hit or miss depending on what you order. Hopefully the wing shortage is solved for them.
Stephanie Armstrong Sherman
1st time there the owner's were very nice and I totally enjoyed the pizza the sauce was awesome crust was great I will go again
Ruben Torres
Just great. The guys were real cool and there pizza was served hot. It's a great pie. The sauce, the crust was excellent. If you're in the area. Stop in.
We went to Walnut Beach on a day trip from NY and found this shop. The pizza is amazing and the man working there was so nice!!!
Anthony Teixeira
Really good place i love the pizza absolutely good
Robert R.
I really enjoyed the pizza! Excellent ingredients, perfectly cooked. The owners were really nice too, def a great atmosphere. One of them worked at Colony for a while but they have definitely created their own authentic (and delicious) style. Looking forwarding to trying more on the menu!
Kass B
The pizza tastes like frozen cheese and ragu sauce. The cheese was also JUST barely melted. The garlic knots are DRY and just have minced garlic thrown on it. They are okay I'm a pinch but I do not recommend...
Elizabeth Mcgoey
Holy Deliciousness!!! Got a bacon and onion pizza and it was incredible! Also the owners were so friendly!!! This is my new favorite pizza place!!!!
Waited a while to try this, then kept forgetting about it. No one I knew had tried it so I gave it a go and ordered a Pizza and a cold Caprese sub. The latter was pretty flavorless, not enough cheese, no salt & peeper. Could've used more balsamic or pesto or something. The pizza was very thin, kind of burnt, and flavor was barely meh and lacking something. Would prob not get again as I can't afford to throw away food. But maybe I'll try once more and ask for pizza to NOT be well done and definitely a different sub. Tbh, I'd prob choose Colony Grille over this, especially their amazing salad pizza!
Glorified English muffin pizza with watered down Prego
Terrible. Pizza was ice cold and tasteless the garlic knots came soaked in grease with no sauce. Chicken parm grinder was burnt making the bread inedible. I'm Hoping it was just an off night as this place has such great reviews I'll give it another try as I'm all about supporting local, hopefully it will be a better experience.
Pizza's great. My kids love it.
This is by far the best pizza in Milford..I know everybody raves about pappas but honestly this place blows them out of the water. Pizza is absolutely delicious..perfect crust,sauce and just the right amount of cheese and guess what every time I order its ready in 20 minutes. This is the new hidden gem of walnut beach !!!
I'm a New Yorker and this is the only pizza I allow my family to eat in CT- never had a bad pie here. Their pizza is consistent and chicken parm sub was huge and delicious! We LOVE this pizza and the super friendly people who run the place. Pretty outdoor seating, close to the beach, always a warm welcome.
Not sure how to feel on this one. My wife and I ordered two subs, one chicken parm and the other meatball. Also when we tried to order chicken wings the guy said there was a nationwide chicken wing shortage and he didn't have any (is this for real?) Anyways, I inhaled the first half of my meatball sub and it was amazing. My wife struggled to eat her chicken parm one. She said it was dry. I was kind of surprised but I offered to give her the other half of mine and take her chicken parm leftover. And well, I made a huge mistake because the chicken parm was inedible for me. The meat was tough and dry and I threw the rest away. I guess it's hit or miss depending on what you order. Hopefully the wing shortage is solved for them.
1st time there the owner's were very nice and I totally enjoyed the pizza the sauce was awesome crust was great I will go again
Just great. The guys were real cool and there pizza was served hot. It's a great pie. The sauce, the crust was excellent. If you're in the area. Stop in.
Great pie as usual. These guys do a great job!
Restaurantji Recommends
We went to Walnut Beach on a day trip from NY and found this shop. The pizza is amazing and the man working there was so nice!!!
Really good place i love the pizza absolutely good
I really enjoyed the pizza! Excellent ingredients, perfectly cooked. The owners were really nice too, def a great atmosphere. One of them worked at Colony for a while but they have definitely created their own authentic (and delicious) style. Looking forwarding to trying more on the menu!
The pizza tastes like frozen cheese and ragu sauce. The cheese was also JUST barely melted. The garlic knots are DRY and just have minced garlic thrown on it. They are okay I'm a pinch but I do not recommend...
Holy Deliciousness!!! Got a bacon and onion pizza and it was incredible! Also the owners were so friendly!!! This is my new favorite pizza place!!!!