Yummy pizza if you like thicker crust. Very affordable only $11. For small pepperoni.
Johnae
Today I got a rude lady on the phone . I hung up and called back and said “I was just speaking to someone with an attitude “ and she goes and admits it was her. Right then and there she knew she was being rude . I asked to speak to the manager and he comes on phone stating “nothing much he can do” He didn’t even care about my complaint . If you don’t care about how your customer feels then you shouldn’t be in business. I recently stop eating here and was ordering for someone anyways . When observing they do not wear gloves nor mask and one guy kept walking around and then touch the food. Just for anyones information.
Amare Jay
Customer service not great. Made me not even want to order from this place. If you hate your job so much you should quit.
ernest malafronte
Our go to spit for really great take out pizza
Joe Cafasso
Good quality pizza. Thicker crust than New Haven style pizza, but it's very good. Convenient location and good parking.
Carolyn Levesque
Best greek style pizza in the area.
Katie S.
I haven't been to this place in years as we usually order from another place in town. The other place was closed recently so we tried American Pie again and both my husband and I were both stumped as to why we haven't ordered from here more often! The staff was very friendly and there were people inside eating when I picked the food up. It's a smaller place on the corner of an intersection. The pizza was perfect so tasty. The antipasto salad was awesome too and very filling. We will definitely be ordering from here more often! The only downside is they don't deliver but it's only a few minutes from me so it's worth the drive. I forgot to take a picture as we were too excited to eat but I will take one next time!
Chris Barnett
Hands-down the best burger I’ve eaten in a very long time the guy behind the counter is awesome and very attentive even came to my truck to ask me if I wanted any additional coffee while I waited Orono fantastic market
Scottie Grace
Great food at reasonable prices
Jessie Hufnagel
The food is not bad however no one in their kitchen wears gloves or washes hands between tasks. They go from answering the phone, to grabbing a ticket and making a pizza with no hand washing
Met someone upon moving to town months back. Asked him with all the pizza place around here , what's the best. If Naugatuck has one thing it has pizza places !! But he recommended it and he should have. I order two large salads and it was only a small spread out on a large container. I order a red pie no cheese. And ended up still getting a cheese pie. The regular pizza was LOADED with cheese!! Wouldn't even stay on the crust. The wings were the best thing on my order. Probably won't try this again. Oh yeah , " guy in the back, you dropped that container on the floor and you looked at me to see if it saw you. And yea I did! Why would you put a persons food in that now knowing we look each other in the eyes ?! Lol" And your front counter girl has a little rude mouth. Good luck!
Clarence Winston
GREAT PIZZA. I come from Thomaston to get it
chad nimons
I read a review saying the burgers here were great so I tried it. Yeah pretty damn great. Beats out shinkys on AMI and is neck and neck with counsils in Bradenton FL. Pretty close to the greatest burger I've had.
dreams walker
please change the time of closing on here. my husband went to get food at 9 and they said they were closed and it was far from 10pm. smh
Mr Reyes
Amazing taste, great food, I love this pizza place. I tried pepperoni pizza and the sausage and peppers Calzone it was so tasty ?
Yummy pizza if you like thicker crust. Very affordable only $11. For small pepperoni.
Today I got a rude lady on the phone . I hung up and called back and said “I was just speaking to someone with an attitude “ and she goes and admits it was her. Right then and there she knew she was being rude . I asked to speak to the manager and he comes on phone stating “nothing much he can do” He didn’t even care about my complaint . If you don’t care about how your customer feels then you shouldn’t be in business. I recently stop eating here and was ordering for someone anyways . When observing they do not wear gloves nor mask and one guy kept walking around and then touch the food. Just for anyones information.
Customer service not great. Made me not even want to order from this place. If you hate your job so much you should quit.
Our go to spit for really great take out pizza
Good quality pizza. Thicker crust than New Haven style pizza, but it's very good. Convenient location and good parking.
Best greek style pizza in the area.
I haven't been to this place in years as we usually order from another place in town. The other place was closed recently so we tried American Pie again and both my husband and I were both stumped as to why we haven't ordered from here more often! The staff was very friendly and there were people inside eating when I picked the food up. It's a smaller place on the corner of an intersection. The pizza was perfect so tasty. The antipasto salad was awesome too and very filling. We will definitely be ordering from here more often! The only downside is they don't deliver but it's only a few minutes from me so it's worth the drive. I forgot to take a picture as we were too excited to eat but I will take one next time!
Hands-down the best burger I’ve eaten in a very long time the guy behind the counter is awesome and very attentive even came to my truck to ask me if I wanted any additional coffee while I waited Orono fantastic market
Great food at reasonable prices
The food is not bad however no one in their kitchen wears gloves or washes hands between tasks. They go from answering the phone, to grabbing a ticket and making a pizza with no hand washing
Restaurantji Recommends
Met someone upon moving to town months back. Asked him with all the pizza place around here , what's the best. If Naugatuck has one thing it has pizza places !! But he recommended it and he should have. I order two large salads and it was only a small spread out on a large container. I order a red pie no cheese. And ended up still getting a cheese pie. The regular pizza was LOADED with cheese!! Wouldn't even stay on the crust. The wings were the best thing on my order. Probably won't try this again. Oh yeah , " guy in the back, you dropped that container on the floor and you looked at me to see if it saw you. And yea I did! Why would you put a persons food in that now knowing we look each other in the eyes ?! Lol" And your front counter girl has a little rude mouth. Good luck!
GREAT PIZZA. I come from Thomaston to get it
I read a review saying the burgers here were great so I tried it. Yeah pretty damn great. Beats out shinkys on AMI and is neck and neck with counsils in Bradenton FL. Pretty close to the greatest burger I've had.
please change the time of closing on here. my husband went to get food at 9 and they said they were closed and it was far from 10pm. smh
Amazing taste, great food, I love this pizza place. I tried pepperoni pizza and the sausage and peppers Calzone it was so tasty ?