Pizza was not New Haven style. More like a flavorless cracker with equally bland toppings. Service was not interested in working at all. Place was supposed to be open until 11, but the lights came on at 930 with no explanation. They even shut the music and TVs off to get people out of there as quickly as possible. Even though it was fairly crowded for a Monday night, they managed to clear the place out quickly since it was clear that they weren't interested in having customers any more.
Brian B
Bartender was more worried about his tip than good service. I had a drink knocked out of my hand and instead of making me a new one he told me to "find the person who did it" and charged full price. Very selfish staff
Service: 1
Mickey Pertoso
BAR HATES THE GAYS. If you are LGBTQ this is not the place. 3 separate queer individuals were discriminated against in one evening at this establishment. The security, managers and owners have had no sensitivity training and have no respect for people with different identities. DO NOT GO HERE. If there is a pride event, UNDERSTAND that it is performative and a money grab. No level of “good pizza” will ever make up for the levels of discrimination, disrespect, and bigotry experienced, not to mention the dumpster smell throughout the establishment and DJ playing only clean versions of songs as if we’re at a summer camp for 5 year olds.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Bucky Gentry
The female bartender with the glasses and brown hair that served me at the side bar by the pizza ovens, was the nastiest, most disrespectful worker I’ve ever dealt with. She had an attitude the entire time I was there, I am handicapped and she refused to accommodate my needs. Wish I got to enjoy my time here but she made it the worst experience for me.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Justin Kagan
Classic New Haven spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jin Park
Although it is pricey, the pizza is quite delicious. The atmosphere is good and the quality of ingredients is good. Probably Connecticut 1st or 2nd place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Oscar Filipe
Great pizza! Right up there at the top with the neighboring spots. Went here before a show at shubert for the 1st time and loved the potatoe bacon and herbivore split. Note they only have pizza and salad!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kambiz Motamedi
We had 4 pizzas, the Mexican, clam, eggplants, and margarita. Mexican elote and the white clam were tasty, but eggplants and margarita were tasteless and soggy. Service was fine, but I was blown away for the high price of $8 kombucha, which was not tasting like kombucha.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Clam Pizza, Clam, Elote Mexican Street Corn Pizza
Kaitlyn A
Just discovered the great music scene in New Haven recently and will often stay overnight if seeing a show at Toads or College St. We make it a point to always go to BAR for pizza and drinks before a show! I personally think it's the best New Haven style pizza. Service is great, drinks are fantastic and pizza beats out all the rest!! You will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New Haven Pizza
Steven Anthony Baranello
OMG. that is what can be used to describe it. the pizzas were HUGE AF. i ordered a small and we shared it between myself and my friend and we went home with leftover! the staff was SUPER friendly. and they were really quick to get our order in and served. my friend ordered a drink and he said it was awesome! loved the decor and the layout!
staff incredibly rude. i went outside to smoke a cigarette and the bouncer pushed me and knocked my $17 drink out of my hand… i couldn’t believe it. maybe a “hey you can’t leave with that” would of sufficed. sucks they’re so rude bc the atmosphere was nice. couldn’t even get a refund.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 1
Mahdad Mahmoudi
Great spot for partying with friends and dancing on weekends. Pizza is pretty delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Adarsh Guler
Excellent Pizzas . Great place to eat and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
N J
I came in the evening in a weekend. There was a cover charge and I didn't understand why until I got inside. THREE BARS, PIZZA AND A CLUB ROOM?!!!! I was surprised. I'm from out of state and came for the mash potato pizza. There were a lot of middle age and older men dressed nicely. The cocktails were great and beer selection is nice. The pizza was amazing. I liked the club area however the strobe lights weren't going with music and if you have strobe induced seizures you'll have a horrible time here. Other than the horrible strobe everything was great. No table service at night which is understandable. The pizza room is off the side with a nice full bar and plenty of seating. Middle bar is where the pizza and to go is at with beer on tap. Third bar is modern and cozy fully stocked and then the bathrooms which are clean and modern and then the club room. Pretty interesting layout but I really liked the warehouse / barn decor. Came for he pizza and will be back for the pizza.
Pizza was not New Haven style. More like a flavorless cracker with equally bland toppings. Service was not interested in working at all. Place was supposed to be open until 11, but the lights came on at 930 with no explanation. They even shut the music and TVs off to get people out of there as quickly as possible. Even though it was fairly crowded for a Monday night, they managed to clear the place out quickly since it was clear that they weren't interested in having customers any more.
Bartender was more worried about his tip than good service. I had a drink knocked out of my hand and instead of making me a new one he told me to "find the person who did it" and charged full price. Very selfish staff
Service: 1
BAR HATES THE GAYS. If you are LGBTQ this is not the place. 3 separate queer individuals were discriminated against in one evening at this establishment. The security, managers and owners have had no sensitivity training and have no respect for people with different identities. DO NOT GO HERE. If there is a pride event, UNDERSTAND that it is performative and a money grab. No level of “good pizza” will ever make up for the levels of discrimination, disrespect, and bigotry experienced, not to mention the dumpster smell throughout the establishment and DJ playing only clean versions of songs as if we’re at a summer camp for 5 year olds.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
The female bartender with the glasses and brown hair that served me at the side bar by the pizza ovens, was the nastiest, most disrespectful worker I’ve ever dealt with. She had an attitude the entire time I was there, I am handicapped and she refused to accommodate my needs. Wish I got to enjoy my time here but she made it the worst experience for me.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Classic New Haven spot
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Although it is pricey, the pizza is quite delicious. The atmosphere is good and the quality of ingredients is good. Probably Connecticut 1st or 2nd place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza! Right up there at the top with the neighboring spots. Went here before a show at shubert for the 1st time and loved the potatoe bacon and herbivore split. Note they only have pizza and salad!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had 4 pizzas, the Mexican, clam, eggplants, and margarita. Mexican elote and the white clam were tasty, but eggplants and margarita were tasteless and soggy. Service was fine, but I was blown away for the high price of $8 kombucha, which was not tasting like kombucha.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Clam Pizza, Clam, Elote Mexican Street Corn Pizza
Just discovered the great music scene in New Haven recently and will often stay overnight if seeing a show at Toads or College St. We make it a point to always go to BAR for pizza and drinks before a show! I personally think it's the best New Haven style pizza. Service is great, drinks are fantastic and pizza beats out all the rest!! You will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: New Haven Pizza
OMG. that is what can be used to describe it. the pizzas were HUGE AF. i ordered a small and we shared it between myself and my friend and we went home with leftover! the staff was SUPER friendly. and they were really quick to get our order in and served. my friend ordered a drink and he said it was awesome! loved the decor and the layout!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pizza in CT period.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
staff incredibly rude. i went outside to smoke a cigarette and the bouncer pushed me and knocked my $17 drink out of my hand… i couldn’t believe it. maybe a “hey you can’t leave with that” would of sufficed. sucks they’re so rude bc the atmosphere was nice. couldn’t even get a refund.
Atmosphere: 4
Service: 1
Great spot for partying with friends and dancing on weekends. Pizza is pretty delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Excellent Pizzas . Great place to eat and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I came in the evening in a weekend. There was a cover charge and I didn't understand why until I got inside. THREE BARS, PIZZA AND A CLUB ROOM?!!!! I was surprised. I'm from out of state and came for the mash potato pizza. There were a lot of middle age and older men dressed nicely. The cocktails were great and beer selection is nice. The pizza was amazing. I liked the club area however the strobe lights weren't going with music and if you have strobe induced seizures you'll have a horrible time here. Other than the horrible strobe everything was great. No table service at night which is understandable. The pizza room is off the side with a nice full bar and plenty of seating. Middle bar is where the pizza and to go is at with beer on tap. Third bar is modern and cozy fully stocked and then the bathrooms which are clean and modern and then the club room. Pretty interesting layout but I really liked the warehouse / barn decor. Came for he pizza and will be back for the pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: New Haven Pizza