Wings and Eggplant Parm below average. No cheese on the eggplant parmesan. A few pieces of eggplant over a container of ziti. Should be renamed ziti with a little bit of eggplant. False advertisement... menu given with delivery order clearly states that a delivery charge will be applied to areas OUTSIDE of 06513. They charge delivery for addresses with a 06513 zip code and refuse to abide by the written policy on their menu. The only reason giving a 2 star was that the large pizza was average and the Greek salad was very good. Not worth ordering from them again.
Teddy Natter
Prices are already ski high and then you want to add 2$ for delivery. 22$ for a steak sub with a small soda. I could see if you were serving good steak but you’re serving frozen compressed steak.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Reanetta DuHart
I won’t even bother to put any stars because that’s to many, my husband and I ordered dinner from them as we didn’t feel like cooking. I ordered a Philly cheesesteak grinder and my husband ordered a turkey grinder. Well my Philly cheesesteak was so dry it looked like leather on bread and raw onions on the side wrapped in wax paper. My husband’s turkey grinder had thick pieces of turkey that looked as if some one carved it from a slab of mystery meat. The mayonnaise was yellow and hard . Not to mention we ordered 2 slices of cheese cake that wasn’t in the bag. $46.72 for food that had to be thrown in the trash and our dinner became a bowl of lucky charms. I tried calling liberty pizza at 11:50 pm as they were not due to close at 12:30am , no one would answer the phone at all. Never order from here unless you want good that you can won’t be able to eat.
steven gallagher
I only gave atmosphere to Stars because of what goes on outside of the building that they can't control but I'm just giving an honest opinionParking: Plenty of parking on the street Ferry and Lombard plus there's a parking lot decent size in the rear plus has security cameras and is safeKid-friendliness: I would say definitely kid friendly the employees and owners are very nice but added option there's an ice cream place two doors down same buildingWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible no stairs no ramps it's walk-in walk out roll and roll out
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Liberty Special Pizza, Pizza
Lesche Moye
Liberty pizza is good. There is time where they are super busy or not but their food is good.Parking: There are cars always parked in front and we have to park on the side of the bus stop or around the corner or down the street but that's hard to do/find also!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Pizza
Joseph cotto
The 3.8 rating is not at all the correct rating for this wonderful establishment. Each and EVERY single time I’ve ordered from here I get treated with respect. The food ALWAYS gets delivered hot and super yummy. They deliver so fast, and are so frendly on the phone. I even go in person to pick up orders sometimes and they’re always so friendly, even the individuals cooking the pizza greet me. I honestly think the ratings are bad because people just want to bring this place down due to malice intentions. No. Don’t believe the bad reviews. Tip the driver well if you’re ordering out, don’t be a cheapskate and expect quality food. Owner if you’re reading this, you guys are GREAT. Been ordering here for years and never ONCE have you guys ever treated me poorly. Hate seeing people talking poorly about a place operating with efficiency. I’m writing this right before placing my order… I couldn’t believe the review rating so I had to comment!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nani nene Nene nani
Nice staff , Good pizza great taste the sausage and cheese is the best . The pizza is really good with a nice little crunch! Low prices and coupons!! Best pizza in new
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
leo green
The rudest customer service experience I’ve had in a while. The gentleman I spoke with was very condescending and impatient. But what surprised me most was after many attempts to complete my order in a civil way, I WAS TURNED AWAY while processing my transaction with NO explanation.I don’t even want to put any more time from my day into trying to digest what has happened. Very eerie behaviour.Will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Lulu DeBlanca
got a large.pep and the pizza was very basic tasting and cut square and idk how but the curly fries were terrible. pizza flavor sophistication on about the level of little caesars. total waste of money compared to the other pizzas in the area ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Von Edwards
Very rude customer service. The food is okay but not worth the hassle of ordering. As a local I’d rather support business in my area but sheesh man.
Definitely one of my all time favorites when I lived in the area. Pizza is delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Missy
Food was very good with large portions.
Saxy Wolf
They DO NOT have Gluten Free Pizza, but come up in Map's search. Not even a mention of "gluten" on their website. (Sorry owner, if there was a way to mark this instead of leaving a review, I would.)
Thanos Brady
Worst pizza place in the Fair Haven area. Not only was the taste bad but the customer service was not good
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
William Scott
Wanted to charge us $18 for a small pizza. We have been buying the same pizza for 5 years at $12-13. Woman at counter insisted that had always been the price and no prices were changed. Not true.
Wings and Eggplant Parm below average. No cheese on the eggplant parmesan. A few pieces of eggplant over a container of ziti. Should be renamed ziti with a little bit of eggplant. False advertisement... menu given with delivery order clearly states that a delivery charge will be applied to areas OUTSIDE of 06513. They charge delivery for addresses with a 06513 zip code and refuse to abide by the written policy on their menu. The only reason giving a 2 star was that the large pizza was average and the Greek salad was very good. Not worth ordering from them again.
Prices are already ski high and then you want to add 2$ for delivery. 22$ for a steak sub with a small soda. I could see if you were serving good steak but you’re serving frozen compressed steak.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
I won’t even bother to put any stars because that’s to many, my husband and I ordered dinner from them as we didn’t feel like cooking. I ordered a Philly cheesesteak grinder and my husband ordered a turkey grinder. Well my Philly cheesesteak was so dry it looked like leather on bread and raw onions on the side wrapped in wax paper. My husband’s turkey grinder had thick pieces of turkey that looked as if some one carved it from a slab of mystery meat. The mayonnaise was yellow and hard . Not to mention we ordered 2 slices of cheese cake that wasn’t in the bag. $46.72 for food that had to be thrown in the trash and our dinner became a bowl of lucky charms. I tried calling liberty pizza at 11:50 pm as they were not due to close at 12:30am , no one would answer the phone at all. Never order from here unless you want good that you can won’t be able to eat.
I only gave atmosphere to Stars because of what goes on outside of the building that they can't control but I'm just giving an honest opinionParking: Plenty of parking on the street Ferry and Lombard plus there's a parking lot decent size in the rear plus has security cameras and is safeKid-friendliness: I would say definitely kid friendly the employees and owners are very nice but added option there's an ice cream place two doors down same buildingWheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible no stairs no ramps it's walk-in walk out roll and roll out
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Liberty Special Pizza, Pizza
Liberty pizza is good. There is time where they are super busy or not but their food is good.Parking: There are cars always parked in front and we have to park on the side of the bus stop or around the corner or down the street but that's hard to do/find also!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings, Pizza
The 3.8 rating is not at all the correct rating for this wonderful establishment. Each and EVERY single time I’ve ordered from here I get treated with respect. The food ALWAYS gets delivered hot and super yummy. They deliver so fast, and are so frendly on the phone. I even go in person to pick up orders sometimes and they’re always so friendly, even the individuals cooking the pizza greet me. I honestly think the ratings are bad because people just want to bring this place down due to malice intentions. No. Don’t believe the bad reviews. Tip the driver well if you’re ordering out, don’t be a cheapskate and expect quality food. Owner if you’re reading this, you guys are GREAT. Been ordering here for years and never ONCE have you guys ever treated me poorly. Hate seeing people talking poorly about a place operating with efficiency. I’m writing this right before placing my order… I couldn’t believe the review rating so I had to comment!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice staff , Good pizza great taste the sausage and cheese is the best . The pizza is really good with a nice little crunch! Low prices and coupons!! Best pizza in new
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The rudest customer service experience I’ve had in a while. The gentleman I spoke with was very condescending and impatient. But what surprised me most was after many attempts to complete my order in a civil way, I WAS TURNED AWAY while processing my transaction with NO explanation.I don’t even want to put any more time from my day into trying to digest what has happened. Very eerie behaviour.Will not be returning.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
got a large.pep and the pizza was very basic tasting and cut square and idk how but the curly fries were terrible. pizza flavor sophistication on about the level of little caesars. total waste of money compared to the other pizzas in the area ?
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Very rude customer service. The food is okay but not worth the hassle of ordering. As a local I’d rather support business in my area but sheesh man.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Definitely one of my all time favorites when I lived in the area. Pizza is delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Food was very good with large portions.
They DO NOT have Gluten Free Pizza, but come up in Map's search. Not even a mention of "gluten" on their website. (Sorry owner, if there was a way to mark this instead of leaving a review, I would.)
Worst pizza place in the Fair Haven area. Not only was the taste bad but the customer service was not good
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Wanted to charge us $18 for a small pizza. We have been buying the same pizza for 5 years at $12-13. Woman at counter insisted that had always been the price and no prices were changed. Not true.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 3