Has been a staple in our household for years. One of the best pizza joints in the area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tammy Reardon
Fantastic varieties of pizza! all of those that I've tried have been delicious!
Food: 5
Kimberly Taylor Cross
We have enjoyed NMPS takeout. It's been our go-to for delicious crispy pizza in New Milford. We loved the The One for Meat Lovers as well as the One with Chicken, Truffle Oil & ‘Shrooms. The sauce was great and it was still steaming hot once we got it home. If you're every planning a get-together, on Tuesdays they offer an extra pie when you purchase two!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Fries, Mediterranean
John Allen
Great pizza and awesome salads. Prices are very fair for the entire menu. Lots of options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kimberly T.
We have enjoyed NMPS takeout. It's been our go-to for delicious crispy pizza in New Milford. We loved the The One for Meat Lovers as well as the One with Chicken, Truffle Oil & 'Shrooms. The sauce was great and it was still steaming hot once we got it home. If you're every planning a get-together, on Tuesdays they offer an extra pie when you purchase two!
Billy
Tried to order online and the pizza list I couldn't find looked for about 20mins gave
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Sean Murphy
Over half an hour wait for 2 Salads is something you will experience regularly while the management hounds and belittles the few employees they're able to retain :(
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jason Fuchs
It may be generous to give three stars, but since moving to New Milford I have to rate the food relative to the mediocrity around it. If you come from a city like New York you certainly can't expect fine pizza from just anywhere, but even for a small town this was poor. I would have been better off with a frozen pizza than this.
Casey Green
I loveee this place! Salmon is sooo fresh and cooked exactly how you ask. Greek salad, thin crust marg pizza, falafel, rigatoni vodka, carrot cake… it’s all amazing. I don’t live nearby but whenever I’m in town, I come here first! And wonderful people working there. Thanks!!
Harvey Webb
Used to enjoy New Milford pizza Station, but the food is far too mediocre to warrant how high prices have skyrocketed. There are far better options for less
Ordered a delivery which never arrived. Called them only to get the "maybe call their driver" response. Could care less about peoples' business. Good reason to look up "customer service" or "running a business". I'll never use them or Door Douche again.
Steve Antonacci
Large selection of pizzas which is nice. The specialty pies have an original flair. I like the fact that they delivery in a timely fashion and the food is always hot.
Kim Banton
I don't know when they changed the crust on the pizza but it's horrible. I called after I got home and asked when it was changed and was told it was the same.but it is razor thin with no crust at the edge. When you try to remove a slice it falls apart and the toppings slide off...so something is very different.
ellen palmer
Matthew was so welcoming and helpful...and the pizza was the best! Crispy crust the way we like it, very tasty sauce and cheese to die for!
Susan K.
Replacing a long-established community restaurant with take out section, New Milford Pizza Station appears to be serving as an equivalent for Greca. It is a spot to pick up Greek-style pizza. As I used to enjoy occasional beef patty melt on rye from the predecessor, Holiday, and nobody had contributed a review on what sounded like a intriguing Greek twist, I ordered the Greca burger medium rare for pick up, alongside "Greek" fries. How could this be a miss? I was looking to help expand the range of Yelp described experiences.The "Greek" fries are different in that they are topped with herbs that are popularly found in Greek cuisine. This complements the Greek-themed burger, which was topped with feta cheese. The burger was thick and encased in a pillowy, golden bun. Baby arugula and a slice of tomato completes the signature burger.I arrived early in pick up the order and had time to find friendly staff at the counter. The first red flag was that the container did not feel warm when I received it. Upon returning home I found that the majority of the burger interior was completely uncooked, appearing as fresh, lukewarm ground beef with a thin cooked exterior. My best guess is this is not a popular item, nor associated with the restaurant focus, and perhaps a thick, beef patty in the freezer had been used? This is the first time I have ever received a burger that appeared like this anywhere, and I trust this did not meet safe food guidelines. If I return in the future I will only choose from one of the many Greek dishes, which is their specialty, and provide an update.
Has been a staple in our household for years. One of the best pizza joints in the area.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Fantastic varieties of pizza! all of those that I've tried have been delicious!
Food: 5
We have enjoyed NMPS takeout. It's been our go-to for delicious crispy pizza in New Milford. We loved the The One for Meat Lovers as well as the One with Chicken, Truffle Oil & ‘Shrooms. The sauce was great and it was still steaming hot once we got it home. If you're every planning a get-together, on Tuesdays they offer an extra pie when you purchase two!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Fries, Mediterranean
Great pizza and awesome salads. Prices are very fair for the entire menu. Lots of options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have enjoyed NMPS takeout. It's been our go-to for delicious crispy pizza in New Milford. We loved the The One for Meat Lovers as well as the One with Chicken, Truffle Oil & 'Shrooms. The sauce was great and it was still steaming hot once we got it home. If you're every planning a get-together, on Tuesdays they offer an extra pie when you purchase two!
Tried to order online and the pizza list I couldn't find looked for about 20mins gave
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Over half an hour wait for 2 Salads is something you will experience regularly while the management hounds and belittles the few employees they're able to retain :(
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
It may be generous to give three stars, but since moving to New Milford I have to rate the food relative to the mediocrity around it. If you come from a city like New York you certainly can't expect fine pizza from just anywhere, but even for a small town this was poor. I would have been better off with a frozen pizza than this.
I loveee this place! Salmon is sooo fresh and cooked exactly how you ask. Greek salad, thin crust marg pizza, falafel, rigatoni vodka, carrot cake… it’s all amazing. I don’t live nearby but whenever I’m in town, I come here first! And wonderful people working there. Thanks!!
Used to enjoy New Milford pizza Station, but the food is far too mediocre to warrant how high prices have skyrocketed. There are far better options for less
Restaurantji Recommends
Ordered a delivery which never arrived. Called them only to get the "maybe call their driver" response. Could care less about peoples' business. Good reason to look up "customer service" or "running a business". I'll never use them or Door Douche again.
Large selection of pizzas which is nice. The specialty pies have an original flair. I like the fact that they delivery in a timely fashion and the food is always hot.
I don't know when they changed the crust on the pizza but it's horrible. I called after I got home and asked when it was changed and was told it was the same.but it is razor thin with no crust at the edge. When you try to remove a slice it falls apart and the toppings slide off...so something is very different.
Matthew was so welcoming and helpful...and the pizza was the best! Crispy crust the way we like it, very tasty sauce and cheese to die for!
Replacing a long-established community restaurant with take out section, New Milford Pizza Station appears to be serving as an equivalent for Greca. It is a spot to pick up Greek-style pizza. As I used to enjoy occasional beef patty melt on rye from the predecessor, Holiday, and nobody had contributed a review on what sounded like a intriguing Greek twist, I ordered the Greca burger medium rare for pick up, alongside "Greek" fries. How could this be a miss? I was looking to help expand the range of Yelp described experiences.The "Greek" fries are different in that they are topped with herbs that are popularly found in Greek cuisine. This complements the Greek-themed burger, which was topped with feta cheese. The burger was thick and encased in a pillowy, golden bun. Baby arugula and a slice of tomato completes the signature burger.I arrived early in pick up the order and had time to find friendly staff at the counter. The first red flag was that the container did not feel warm when I received it. Upon returning home I found that the majority of the burger interior was completely uncooked, appearing as fresh, lukewarm ground beef with a thin cooked exterior. My best guess is this is not a popular item, nor associated with the restaurant focus, and perhaps a thick, beef patty in the freezer had been used? This is the first time I have ever received a burger that appeared like this anywhere, and I trust this did not meet safe food guidelines. If I return in the future I will only choose from one of the many Greek dishes, which is their specialty, and provide an update.