We ordered a medium thin crusted Pizza w/ sausage and peppers.The crust was delicious and the whole pizza tasted wonderful.?The staff at Papa Al's are so nice! I recommend Papa Al's!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey Lambert
Just ate at Papa Al's pizza ? as far a CT pizza goes I would give it a solid 8. I liked that they weren't afraid to offer unique toppings I had the mango habenario chicken pizza it was very good. I would not classify this as NY style pizza. And I felt the price on slices was a bit high I paid a $13.15 for 2 normal sized slices of the specialty pizza and a 20oz root beer ? so I would estimate the slices at about $5 a slice. Atmosphere was alright. Staff was friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Bryan Skirkanich
I literally never give reviews anywhere. But believe me when I say I do not know how this place is still open. The god awful pizza that comes from this place is a joke. I’ve recently moved out to Brookfield from Watertown and this is the closest place to me unfortunately. Gave it 5-6 try’s just when I was in a pinch and needed dinner quickly. Every single time I was disappointed. From under cooked doughy pizza and non existent sauce to the soup of a pie I had last night. Couldn’t even pick up a slice because everything fell off. Whoever runs this place needs to learn how to make an actual pizza because is NOT it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Barracuda Jarett
Unbelievable. We ordered a Sicilian pie and got home and it was dough. Called and the guy was argumentative and said that’s the way it should be. Made us another pie “well done” told us to keep this dough one, put it in the oven to cook it. Once cooked it never will cook properly so it is garbage, any baker knows that. He was very argumentative said next time order it well done. Obviously he does not get how to make this kind of pie. Plus we had to go to the bank to complain because they keep trying to charge us a second time. What’s he trying to get paid twice. Good customer service is apologetic and should have just credited us for the inconvenience. For a $25 dollar pizza it was subpar nothing to write home about. There’s a ton of pizza places. Take a ride to Tambascio’s won’t disappoint
Dana
Oh wow, where to start!!! The food there is absolutely, positively amazing. The butter nut squash soup is probably the best I ever had. The lasagna and the lobster ravoli was soooo good. I had to sample everyones so I could share this review with you.We ordered probably one of the tastiest pizzas I have ever had. The chicken Parmigiano was to die for. The group of people sitting next to me were so happy with their dinners. The garlic cheese bread with homemade pasta sauce was so yummy. Their Ceasar salad was delicious. The staff there were so friendly and welcoming. Please try this place. There's limited indoor seating, but they offer a waiting staff and have outdoor seating for bueatiful days.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan and Tomato Pesto Pizza, Chicken Parm Grinder, Baked Ziti, Salads, Tirmisu, Roll
Kevin Lupo
Stopped in on the way to visit family in PA. Service was friendly and quick even though they were busy. I got the Balboa-it was phenomenal. Gf got chick Parm egg plant- she liked it. Pleasant surprise!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
William Anderson
Philly steak sub. Asked for grilled onion, light mayo, lettuce, tomatoes. Got a pathetic sub. More onion than steak. No lettuce, or tomatoes. Asked for receipt. Got a copy of their order slip. Not an itemized receipt with prices. Wrong room #. Way over priced for this. And I tipped. Go elsewhere.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ian Savage
We love us some Papa Al's. The pizza is top notch and it has the best Chicken Francaise I've had locally.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Schalkham
Just did pizza take out was very good the 4× been
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Empire State Construction LLC
All time great place .amazing pizza sandwiches and meals .they have an amazing master pizza maker and the crew is great too .place is a God send I've been going there for so many years .thanks guysBig
We ordered a large Margherita Pizza with tomatoes. We got a soggy, undercooked doughy tasteless pizza pie that could not be eaten by hand. All the toppings didn't adhere to the dough and slid off the pie and every single slice. Unappetizing owing to taste, appearance and expectations. This was unlike any pizza we have ever tasted. Not worth a return!!!
Jonathan Almanzar
Nice place was just passing through, pizza can be a little thinner. Cozy
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mary Ann Milkowski
Only place I go and know what I want before I even get there everything is
Oh wow, where to start!!! The food there is absolutely, positively amazing. We ordered probably one of the tastiest pizzas I have ever had. The chicken Parmigiano was to die for. The group of people sitting next to me were so happy with their dinners. The garlic cheese bread with homemade pasta sauce was so yummy. Their Ceasar salad was delicious. The staff there were so friendly and welcoming. Please try this place. There's limited indoor seating, but they offer a waiting staff and have outdoor seating for bueatiful days.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beth Flenger
They used to be amazing we’ve been coming here for 4 years since we moved here it used to be the closest to a New York pizza but now it’s so inconsistent. Burnt, or undercooked the last 5X’s we’ve ordered. It’s such a shame because we really loved this place and gave it chance after chance.
We ordered a medium thin crusted Pizza w/ sausage and peppers.The crust was delicious and the whole pizza tasted wonderful.?The staff at Papa Al's are so nice! I recommend Papa Al's!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just ate at Papa Al's pizza ? as far a CT pizza goes I would give it a solid 8. I liked that they weren't afraid to offer unique toppings I had the mango habenario chicken pizza it was very good. I would not classify this as NY style pizza. And I felt the price on slices was a bit high I paid a $13.15 for 2 normal sized slices of the specialty pizza and a 20oz root beer ? so I would estimate the slices at about $5 a slice. Atmosphere was alright. Staff was friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I literally never give reviews anywhere. But believe me when I say I do not know how this place is still open. The god awful pizza that comes from this place is a joke. I’ve recently moved out to Brookfield from Watertown and this is the closest place to me unfortunately. Gave it 5-6 try’s just when I was in a pinch and needed dinner quickly. Every single time I was disappointed. From under cooked doughy pizza and non existent sauce to the soup of a pie I had last night. Couldn’t even pick up a slice because everything fell off. Whoever runs this place needs to learn how to make an actual pizza because is NOT it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Unbelievable. We ordered a Sicilian pie and got home and it was dough. Called and the guy was argumentative and said that’s the way it should be. Made us another pie “well done” told us to keep this dough one, put it in the oven to cook it. Once cooked it never will cook properly so it is garbage, any baker knows that. He was very argumentative said next time order it well done. Obviously he does not get how to make this kind of pie. Plus we had to go to the bank to complain because they keep trying to charge us a second time. What’s he trying to get paid twice. Good customer service is apologetic and should have just credited us for the inconvenience. For a $25 dollar pizza it was subpar nothing to write home about. There’s a ton of pizza places. Take a ride to Tambascio’s won’t disappoint
Oh wow, where to start!!! The food there is absolutely, positively amazing. The butter nut squash soup is probably the best I ever had. The lasagna and the lobster ravoli was soooo good. I had to sample everyones so I could share this review with you.We ordered probably one of the tastiest pizzas I have ever had. The chicken Parmigiano was to die for. The group of people sitting next to me were so happy with their dinners. The garlic cheese bread with homemade pasta sauce was so yummy. Their Ceasar salad was delicious. The staff there were so friendly and welcoming. Please try this place. There's limited indoor seating, but they offer a waiting staff and have outdoor seating for bueatiful days.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan and Tomato Pesto Pizza, Chicken Parm Grinder, Baked Ziti, Salads, Tirmisu, Roll
Stopped in on the way to visit family in PA. Service was friendly and quick even though they were busy. I got the Balboa-it was phenomenal. Gf got chick Parm egg plant- she liked it. Pleasant surprise!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Philly steak sub. Asked for grilled onion, light mayo, lettuce, tomatoes. Got a pathetic sub. More onion than steak. No lettuce, or tomatoes. Asked for receipt. Got a copy of their order slip. Not an itemized receipt with prices. Wrong room #. Way over priced for this. And I tipped. Go elsewhere.
Food: 1
Service: 1
We love us some Papa Al's. The pizza is top notch and it has the best Chicken Francaise I've had locally.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just did pizza take out was very good the 4× been
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
All time great place .amazing pizza sandwiches and meals .they have an amazing master pizza maker and the crew is great too .place is a God send I've been going there for so many years .thanks guysBig
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmesan and Tomato Pesto Pizza, Chicken Parm Grinder, Baked Ziti, Chicken Marsala, Cheese Slice
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered a large Margherita Pizza with tomatoes. We got a soggy, undercooked doughy tasteless pizza pie that could not be eaten by hand. All the toppings didn't adhere to the dough and slid off the pie and every single slice. Unappetizing owing to taste, appearance and expectations. This was unlike any pizza we have ever tasted. Not worth a return!!!
Nice place was just passing through, pizza can be a little thinner. Cozy
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Only place I go and know what I want before I even get there everything is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grilled Chicken Grinder, Greek Salad
Oh wow, where to start!!! The food there is absolutely, positively amazing. We ordered probably one of the tastiest pizzas I have ever had. The chicken Parmigiano was to die for. The group of people sitting next to me were so happy with their dinners. The garlic cheese bread with homemade pasta sauce was so yummy. Their Ceasar salad was delicious. The staff there were so friendly and welcoming. Please try this place. There's limited indoor seating, but they offer a waiting staff and have outdoor seating for bueatiful days.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They used to be amazing we’ve been coming here for 4 years since we moved here it used to be the closest to a New York pizza but now it’s so inconsistent. Burnt, or undercooked the last 5X’s we’ve ordered. It’s such a shame because we really loved this place and gave it chance after chance.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5