Delicious Pizza every time. The price is very fair for the quality. I highly recommend this this restaurant. I've gone there whenever I'm in old Lyme
Chelle N.
Staple of Old Lyme...for generations! Teddy's most authentic OL experience you can have! Teddy is loved by all who know him and the greatest guy! OL a small town and we're all friend with one another- we keep it positive and super friendly ! Enjoy the ambiance and dont forget to try the rice pudding! Hopefully you'll visit for a quick lunch or great dinner and you'll love it as much as we have forever and will have a great story to go home with to share of your time here!
Michael J.
Ordered chicken gyro... Clearly marked on receipt got the beef kind of disappointed... Was really looking forward to having the chicken that's what I paid for and didn't get it
Carrie D.
The food is ok. Friendly staff. Take out only. No indoor dining even though they have a dining room. Mid clean.
Susan Coelho
2nd time here and. We ordered this time a White pizza.. It was delicious! You can add your own toppings!! Great food after an Ocean day!!Parking: Parking in front of place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Broccoli Pizza
Bonnie Marquez
I had ordered two sheet pizzas ?. One cheese and one sausage and pepperoni.Both were really good and tasty. My teen and his friends loved it!!Leftovers were yummy the next day ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Janice Kraus
Ordered online.Picked it up very quickly and easily.As it was a transaction conducted in about 2 minutes, I can't speak to the atmosphere
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Tendler
Best bacon cheese burger around! Thank you ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anne M.
I stopped in once on a recommendation from someone about their chicken wings. I called in an order for takeout. I did not realize they were dry rubbed & baked. I thought they were good but not great. I actually really love traditional deep fried chicken wings, however horrible they are for you - (Fortunately I order them every once in a blue moon). Anyway, I tried a sub once, a year or so ago & it was fine but not memorable. I tried to give them another chance. Their food is not bad, It's just not REALLY GOOD. I am also concerned based on what I have seen, that their pizza dough is frozen Cosco or the like. It's just not a place that makes food that is compelling enough for me to return.
Food is good but not liking paying outside like a hot dog stand. I remember when they let people in. My ham grinder was good but was disappointed in the large pizza that would have been a medium anywhere else. Maybe because at the beach you can get away with that so for it’s location at the beach it was good, if compared to Hebron area, would have been 2-3 stars overall
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Ham Grinder, Pepperoni Pizza
Derrick Z.
Been coming down to South Lyme area for years, Teddy's is not only a staple and not to miss place the food is ALWAYS consistently good! Pizza wings subs you name it good quality ingredients!
Teresa L.
Consistency in quality and service. Not much to chose from in Old Lyme so we definitely appreciate Teddys.
Ana María Arellano
Very tasty and very fresh food. Quite a varied menu with gluten-free alternatives. Service was attentive. Niantic clam chowder was superb, although more salt than necessary, especially as it already had bacon. lump crab cake appetizer was delicious, although tiny. Dinner salad with walnuts and Granny Smith, apples was exceptional, which is a maple vinaigrette was excellent plus the freshest of ingredients. If the waitstaff offers, any alternatives, such as “ice cream or whipped cream?“ be sure to ask for the price. Aternatives can cost more. Nevertheless, the blueberry pie was out of this world.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Mica E.
Wings are soooo good! We love crispy, not wet wings and these were perfectly cooked! Pizza has a nice crisp (not droopy) crust and tasted amazing! Everyone who ordered a grinder said they were good as well-they ordered Meatball, Italian & Eggplant-Ordering is quick and easy on the app. It's all take out -which is fine. We don't mind that at all. They made dietary accommodations for our son which is nice. Would highly recommend!
Food is
Food: 5
Delicious Pizza every time. The price is very fair for the quality. I highly recommend this this restaurant. I've gone there whenever I'm in old Lyme
Staple of Old Lyme...for generations! Teddy's most authentic OL experience you can have! Teddy is loved by all who know him and the greatest guy! OL a small town and we're all friend with one another- we keep it positive and super friendly ! Enjoy the ambiance and dont forget to try the rice pudding! Hopefully you'll visit for a quick lunch or great dinner and you'll love it as much as we have forever and will have a great story to go home with to share of your time here!
Ordered chicken gyro... Clearly marked on receipt got the beef kind of disappointed... Was really looking forward to having the chicken that's what I paid for and didn't get it
The food is ok. Friendly staff. Take out only. No indoor dining even though they have a dining room. Mid clean.
2nd time here and. We ordered this time a White pizza.. It was delicious! You can add your own toppings!! Great food after an Ocean day!!Parking: Parking in front of place!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Broccoli Pizza
I had ordered two sheet pizzas ?. One cheese and one sausage and pepperoni.Both were really good and tasty. My teen and his friends loved it!!Leftovers were yummy the next day ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered online.Picked it up very quickly and easily.As it was a transaction conducted in about 2 minutes, I can't speak to the atmosphere
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best bacon cheese burger around! Thank you ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I stopped in once on a recommendation from someone about their chicken wings. I called in an order for takeout. I did not realize they were dry rubbed & baked. I thought they were good but not great. I actually really love traditional deep fried chicken wings, however horrible they are for you - (Fortunately I order them every once in a blue moon). Anyway, I tried a sub once, a year or so ago & it was fine but not memorable. I tried to give them another chance. Their food is not bad, It's just not REALLY GOOD. I am also concerned based on what I have seen, that their pizza dough is frozen Cosco or the like. It's just not a place that makes food that is compelling enough for me to return.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is good but not liking paying outside like a hot dog stand. I remember when they let people in. My ham grinder was good but was disappointed in the large pizza that would have been a medium anywhere else. Maybe because at the beach you can get away with that so for it’s location at the beach it was good, if compared to Hebron area, would have been 2-3 stars overall
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Ham Grinder, Pepperoni Pizza
Been coming down to South Lyme area for years, Teddy's is not only a staple and not to miss place the food is ALWAYS consistently good! Pizza wings subs you name it good quality ingredients!
Consistency in quality and service. Not much to chose from in Old Lyme so we definitely appreciate Teddys.
Very tasty and very fresh food. Quite a varied menu with gluten-free alternatives. Service was attentive. Niantic clam chowder was superb, although more salt than necessary, especially as it already had bacon. lump crab cake appetizer was delicious, although tiny. Dinner salad with walnuts and Granny Smith, apples was exceptional, which is a maple vinaigrette was excellent plus the freshest of ingredients. If the waitstaff offers, any alternatives, such as “ice cream or whipped cream?“ be sure to ask for the price. Aternatives can cost more. Nevertheless, the blueberry pie was out of this world.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Wings are soooo good! We love crispy, not wet wings and these were perfectly cooked! Pizza has a nice crisp (not droopy) crust and tasted amazing! Everyone who ordered a grinder said they were good as well-they ordered Meatball, Italian & Eggplant-Ordering is quick and easy on the app. It's all take out -which is fine. We don't mind that at all. They made dietary accommodations for our son which is nice. Would highly recommend!