Although the shrimp fra diavlo was mildly spicy, I was pleasantly surprised that there was also mussels, clams & scallops, I was disappointed that there wasn't more SHRIMP. A few more and it would be 5 star rated.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Zoe Kramer
Called several times, no answer. I decided to go in person to order. Upon arrival, the owner/front of house/chef? was friendly and helpful. He told me it’d be 30 minutes until my order was ready. When I returned the hostess and waitress present made no effort to attend,help, or make me feel welcome. As a black man in a mostly white community I felt uncomfortable, unwelcome, and I will not be returning. Hopefully their staff learns how to practice kindness someday.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Katrina Pisani
I've had the pleasure of eating at Andy's Italian Kitchen when it was located in Farmington and in Simsbury. When I worked around the corner in Farmington, Andy's was my go-to for lunch whether dining in or taking out. At their new location in Simsbury, they renovated their space which was formally a dark restaurant, to a bright inviting atmosphere. Andy's menu has something for everyone to enjoy - delicious and priced well. Andy's service is also fantastic. We recommend Andy's to friends and family!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marjorie P.
I'd heard about this place - supposed to have really good pizza. So we decided to take the trek across the river to Simsbury to try it. Solid 4 in my opinion. I thought the pizza was good and worth the trip. My husband thought it was ...ok. Ordered the thin crust pizza with hamburger & olives. Pretty tasty & crispy, just the way I like it. Not a lot of sauce though and I did wish that there was more spice/herbs in the sauce. We also got a house salad to share - definitely a decent portion. The ciabatta bread that came with it was good. I'd heard that the pasta dishes were good. Perhaps if I can convince my husband to venture back, we'd try that. Service was good. The restaurant was clean and comfortable, very casual. There were also some tables outside.
Gabriela Sandoval
Love coming here! Thanks for the gluten-free options and for making me a delicious vegan no cheese pizza! I am hoping for vegan cheese option one day though! Thanks for considering ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marc Braun
First time visitor. Enjoyed the lasagna and tiramisu. Good food, nice place.
Stu Schulman
Food was good. Pizza was average and Chicken dish was good. Service was very
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Margaret H.
We had a great meal- salads were decent, bread was outstanding! I had capellini with sauce and meatballs. The meatballs were really good which I think is a good indicator overall. My husband had chicken Marsala and he said it was great too. The chicken wasn't breaded, but he thought that was better. He had tiramisu for dessert which he also thought was very good. We each had a glass of wine. The service was attentive but not overly so. The bill was reasonable. We will definitely come back and try some other menu items.
Evan Christensen
Food was ok. Not as good as past
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tom K.
I think I've only been there once or twice and the food was good. I don't know that it was excellent that I would go out of my way to return, but I might give it a try again.
Yum! Once you eat a bite of their bread, you'll understand the level of deliciousness that you are in for. I often have the beet/arugula/goat cheese/candied walnut salad, and it is on Point. If you have room, the gelato choices are divine. Don't wait to enjoy!
Karisa W.
This is our go to pizza spot!! The bacon cheeseburger pizza is our favorite. The toppings are so fresh and generously spread over the pizza. The crust is thick and is perfectly toasted. I would definitely recommend.
Jay T
Excellent food. It’s the family’s favorite place to go.
Candice D.
I have to say I enjoyed Andy's Italian kitchen the dining room area is a great size but still nice and cozy. The staff was Incredibly friendly. We just stopped in for a quick cheese calzone and buffalo wings. The calzone was huge and it was cooked perfectly it had the perfect contrast of cheeses so yummy and the Buffalo wings were cooked wonderfully with the perfect amount of buffalo sauce . It was a quick visit for us but I will definitely be back to try the many Italian options . This is def a reasturant I would recommend!!
Anne M.
Ok so that bacon cheeseburger pizza is fantastic! The crust tastes like a toasted bun and the flavors and toppings were just *chefskiss* all the bacon cheeseburger flavors!! I will definitely be back and thank you for setting realistic pickup times!!I managed to take a picture before I ate it all. Seriously just try this pizza already it is delicious!
Although the shrimp fra diavlo was mildly spicy, I was pleasantly surprised that there was also mussels, clams & scallops, I was disappointed that there wasn't more SHRIMP. A few more and it would be 5 star rated.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Called several times, no answer. I decided to go in person to order. Upon arrival, the owner/front of house/chef? was friendly and helpful. He told me it’d be 30 minutes until my order was ready. When I returned the hostess and waitress present made no effort to attend,help, or make me feel welcome. As a black man in a mostly white community I felt uncomfortable, unwelcome, and I will not be returning. Hopefully their staff learns how to practice kindness someday.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
I've had the pleasure of eating at Andy's Italian Kitchen when it was located in Farmington and in Simsbury. When I worked around the corner in Farmington, Andy's was my go-to for lunch whether dining in or taking out. At their new location in Simsbury, they renovated their space which was formally a dark restaurant, to a bright inviting atmosphere. Andy's menu has something for everyone to enjoy - delicious and priced well. Andy's service is also fantastic. We recommend Andy's to friends and family!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'd heard about this place - supposed to have really good pizza. So we decided to take the trek across the river to Simsbury to try it. Solid 4 in my opinion. I thought the pizza was good and worth the trip. My husband thought it was ...ok. Ordered the thin crust pizza with hamburger & olives. Pretty tasty & crispy, just the way I like it. Not a lot of sauce though and I did wish that there was more spice/herbs in the sauce. We also got a house salad to share - definitely a decent portion. The ciabatta bread that came with it was good. I'd heard that the pasta dishes were good. Perhaps if I can convince my husband to venture back, we'd try that. Service was good. The restaurant was clean and comfortable, very casual. There were also some tables outside.
Love coming here! Thanks for the gluten-free options and for making me a delicious vegan no cheese pizza! I am hoping for vegan cheese option one day though! Thanks for considering ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time visitor. Enjoyed the lasagna and tiramisu. Good food, nice place.
Food was good. Pizza was average and Chicken dish was good. Service was very
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
We had a great meal- salads were decent, bread was outstanding! I had capellini with sauce and meatballs. The meatballs were really good which I think is a good indicator overall. My husband had chicken Marsala and he said it was great too. The chicken wasn't breaded, but he thought that was better. He had tiramisu for dessert which he also thought was very good. We each had a glass of wine. The service was attentive but not overly so. The bill was reasonable. We will definitely come back and try some other menu items.
Food was ok. Not as good as past
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
I think I've only been there once or twice and the food was good. I don't know that it was excellent that I would go out of my way to return, but I might give it a try again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Yum! Once you eat a bite of their bread, you'll understand the level of deliciousness that you are in for. I often have the beet/arugula/goat cheese/candied walnut salad, and it is on Point. If you have room, the gelato choices are divine. Don't wait to enjoy!
This is our go to pizza spot!! The bacon cheeseburger pizza is our favorite. The toppings are so fresh and generously spread over the pizza. The crust is thick and is perfectly toasted. I would definitely recommend.
Excellent food. It’s the family’s favorite place to go.
I have to say I enjoyed Andy's Italian kitchen the dining room area is a great size but still nice and cozy. The staff was Incredibly friendly. We just stopped in for a quick cheese calzone and buffalo wings. The calzone was huge and it was cooked perfectly it had the perfect contrast of cheeses so yummy and the Buffalo wings were cooked wonderfully with the perfect amount of buffalo sauce . It was a quick visit for us but I will definitely be back to try the many Italian options . This is def a reasturant I would recommend!!
Ok so that bacon cheeseburger pizza is fantastic! The crust tastes like a toasted bun and the flavors and toppings were just *chefskiss* all the bacon cheeseburger flavors!! I will definitely be back and thank you for setting realistic pickup times!!I managed to take a picture before I ate it all. Seriously just try this pizza already it is delicious!