This is a takeout review. All food is eaten promptly in the vehicle. I ordered meatballs and a pepperoni pizza. The meatballs were very good. They were most and tender and had simmered in the sauce and had great flavor. The pizza was disappointing. The crust was slightly undercooked, and with every bite I took, the entire cheese on the slice came off. The young lady at the counter was very friendly and outgoing. On a scale from 0-10, I would rate this 7.5.
Ryan Jarvis
First time getting food here I ordered pizza and wings and a Mediterranean salad. Service was great and food was ready in a timely manner. The pizza was very good and enjoyable. As was the Salad. The wings were not great at all very tiny barley any meat on them with watery sauce. Was disappointed in the wings. Everything else was good. Will definitely get another pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Ann Grano
Best pizza in town! My family has been coming here since it opened. We love trying the specialty pizzas. My guilty pleasure is the Napolitano and Buffalo chicken pizza.
First time ordering.I've never had white pizza that was just cheese on bread and baked. No garlic and oil base? Or white sauce base? Just nothing at all. And it was overdone so that made it extra dry.We also ordered fish n chips and the oil must have been old because it didn't have a pleasant taste.Maybe their other food is good but mine was not
Food: 2
Service: 4
Morgan Giosa
I normally don't write reviews, but I am saddened by all of the negative reviews of this place. For me, Suffield Pizza is by the best pizza spot in the immediate vicinity, to the point where, as a Windsor resident, I come here every time rather than one of the usual overrated spots typically patronized and exalted by those from Windsor. The pizza is exceptional (especially the sauce and crust - it is a thicker crust, more of a Greek-style crust, as opposed to New Haven or New York style, but I greatly prefer Greek-style pizza crust to anything else, so this is not a complaint), but what sets this place apart is some of their other unique dishes that you don't always find on an Italian menu. I have heard excellent things about their Polish dishes, especially their golombki, from friends and family, though I have never ordered them. My favorite dishes here that are atypical of an Italian restaurant menu are their pretzel bites with beer cheese sauce (their beer cheese is the best I've ever had anywhere, as good as you would find in a German brewpub), their soups (I love their vegetable soup in particular, when they have it - they use lentils and it's delicious), their short rib pappardelle (I personally prefer it without the tomatoes, but the pasta itself is delicious and so is their cream demi-glace sauce - I have eaten at countless fine-dining Italian restaurants in my lifetime, including Joe Bastianich's Becco in New York City, and the short rib pappardelle dish at Suffield Pizza rivals any of them), and their Back East burger (this is one of the few family style restaurants that truly knows how to cook a burger. I ordered it medium-rare because places usually screw up if I ask for medium and overcook it until it's well done, but to my surprise, the burger came out at the exact temperature I asked for). Overall, this in one of my favorite local restaurants.Vegetarian options: They were extremely accommodating of my vegan best friend, preparing for him a pizza with just crust, sauce, and veggies since he cannot eat cheese. They also offer hummus, sweet potato fries, and many other vegan and vegetarian-friendly dishes.Wheelchair accessibility: It is located right off street level, with no steps or slopes to negotiate at all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Shannon E.
I love their pizza the crust is so delicious. Best in Suffield in my opinion. The inside of the restaurant is a bit dated.
Food was awesome and price was reasonable.Parking: Huge parking lot with many shops
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chuck M.
Consistently good, on time and good customer service.Suffield Pizza has very good sales, grinders and of course pizza. They are a go to on our list of local take out joints. We've never eaten in and I don't think we will so I can't really assess that aspect of the experience. However if you need an Italian cold cut or a simple meat lovers pizza for a Sunday afternoon sporting event this is a safe bet.
Lucinda Donnelly
Friendly and very good homestle food, great pizza!
Toetall N.
I'm a big Pizza fan. While I'm not that picky about what's good and bad, avoid this place if you have pizza in mind. I've never had a thin crust pizza served in which the dough wasn't even half cooked.... until waiting nearly a hour for this one to appear. The sauce ? Bland seemingly consisting of nothing more than stewed tomatoes. My guest mentioned a couple times that she hit a patch of disgustingly odd flavor; of which, minutes later I was to hit the same level of disgust. It was, in fact, a house special. The offbeat flavor could not be nailed down to any particular item meat or otherwise. Needless to say.... We won't be going back. If you're coming back from Six Flags, and suddenly get an urge for a pizza, make sure you drive right on by.
Aaron G.
My girlfriend and I came in and had the short rib and beer cheese pizza. It was so damn good . Have been about 10 more times and got the same thing, and its always the same. I highly recomend this place
This is a takeout review. All food is eaten promptly in the vehicle. I ordered meatballs and a pepperoni pizza. The meatballs were very good. They were most and tender and had simmered in the sauce and had great flavor. The pizza was disappointing. The crust was slightly undercooked, and with every bite I took, the entire cheese on the slice came off. The young lady at the counter was very friendly and outgoing. On a scale from 0-10, I would rate this 7.5.
First time getting food here I ordered pizza and wings and a Mediterranean salad. Service was great and food was ready in a timely manner. The pizza was very good and enjoyable. As was the Salad. The wings were not great at all very tiny barley any meat on them with watery sauce. Was disappointed in the wings. Everything else was good. Will definitely get another pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Best pizza in town! My family has been coming here since it opened. We love trying the specialty pizzas. My guilty pleasure is the Napolitano and Buffalo chicken pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatballs Grinder, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Side Salad, Cheesecake, Fried Calamari
Tasty pizza. But you can’t buy slices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
First time here. Food and service were an absolute delight. Great menu - way more than just pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a great experience with great amazing food!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always a great place for lunch or dinner. The staff is super friendly and the food is awesome.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken Francese, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Side Salad, Chicken Parmesan, Suffield Burger
First time ordering.I've never had white pizza that was just cheese on bread and baked. No garlic and oil base? Or white sauce base? Just nothing at all. And it was overdone so that made it extra dry.We also ordered fish n chips and the oil must have been old because it didn't have a pleasant taste.Maybe their other food is good but mine was not
Food: 2
Service: 4
I normally don't write reviews, but I am saddened by all of the negative reviews of this place. For me, Suffield Pizza is by the best pizza spot in the immediate vicinity, to the point where, as a Windsor resident, I come here every time rather than one of the usual overrated spots typically patronized and exalted by those from Windsor. The pizza is exceptional (especially the sauce and crust - it is a thicker crust, more of a Greek-style crust, as opposed to New Haven or New York style, but I greatly prefer Greek-style pizza crust to anything else, so this is not a complaint), but what sets this place apart is some of their other unique dishes that you don't always find on an Italian menu. I have heard excellent things about their Polish dishes, especially their golombki, from friends and family, though I have never ordered them. My favorite dishes here that are atypical of an Italian restaurant menu are their pretzel bites with beer cheese sauce (their beer cheese is the best I've ever had anywhere, as good as you would find in a German brewpub), their soups (I love their vegetable soup in particular, when they have it - they use lentils and it's delicious), their short rib pappardelle (I personally prefer it without the tomatoes, but the pasta itself is delicious and so is their cream demi-glace sauce - I have eaten at countless fine-dining Italian restaurants in my lifetime, including Joe Bastianich's Becco in New York City, and the short rib pappardelle dish at Suffield Pizza rivals any of them), and their Back East burger (this is one of the few family style restaurants that truly knows how to cook a burger. I ordered it medium-rare because places usually screw up if I ask for medium and overcook it until it's well done, but to my surprise, the burger came out at the exact temperature I asked for). Overall, this in one of my favorite local restaurants.Vegetarian options: They were extremely accommodating of my vegan best friend, preparing for him a pizza with just crust, sauce, and veggies since he cannot eat cheese. They also offer hummus, sweet potato fries, and many other vegan and vegetarian-friendly dishes.Wheelchair accessibility: It is located right off street level, with no steps or slopes to negotiate at all.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
I love their pizza the crust is so delicious. Best in Suffield in my opinion. The inside of the restaurant is a bit dated.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food was awesome and price was reasonable.Parking: Huge parking lot with many shops
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Consistently good, on time and good customer service.Suffield Pizza has very good sales, grinders and of course pizza. They are a go to on our list of local take out joints. We've never eaten in and I don't think we will so I can't really assess that aspect of the experience. However if you need an Italian cold cut or a simple meat lovers pizza for a Sunday afternoon sporting event this is a safe bet.
Friendly and very good homestle food, great pizza!
I'm a big Pizza fan. While I'm not that picky about what's good and bad, avoid this place if you have pizza in mind. I've never had a thin crust pizza served in which the dough wasn't even half cooked.... until waiting nearly a hour for this one to appear. The sauce ? Bland seemingly consisting of nothing more than stewed tomatoes. My guest mentioned a couple times that she hit a patch of disgustingly odd flavor; of which, minutes later I was to hit the same level of disgust. It was, in fact, a house special. The offbeat flavor could not be nailed down to any particular item meat or otherwise. Needless to say.... We won't be going back. If you're coming back from Six Flags, and suddenly get an urge for a pizza, make sure you drive right on by.
My girlfriend and I came in and had the short rib and beer cheese pizza. It was so damn good . Have been about 10 more times and got the same thing, and its always the same. I highly recomend this place